3 ms·
While I'm in agreement in principle, in practice there are significant creative differences between conductors as to what the composer intended. Then there's t
by Kadin 16y ago
While I'm in agreement in principle, in practice there are significant creative differences between conductors as to what the composer intended.
Then there's the issue of pieces that have traditionally been performed one way, but then something turns up indicating that the composer may have meant it differently (I dimly recall this happening with something of Beethoven's in the last decade or so). Do you drop 100+ years of tradition and audience expectation in favor of originalism? What if the evidence of original intent is an early draft? There's a lot of room for well-meaning disputes there.
So at least with music old enough to not have any recordings made at the time the composer was alive, there are always going to be differences of opinion on how to translate the score into sound waves. Very serious enthusiasts will want multiple recordings.
- sp332 16y agoHe just disliked the idea of on orchestra having a trademark "sound". Bernstein actually said, if you can listen to a few bars and know which orchestra is playing, they're doing it wrong.