3 ms·
"The NoSQL guys are people who know nothing about databases and their first reaction is to lash out, so I'm not surprised, [by the reaction]," he said. I guess
by wccrawford 16y ago
"The NoSQL guys are people who know nothing about databases and their first reaction is to lash out, so I'm not surprised, [by the reaction]," he said.
I guess he's not above a little mudslinging.
This article wasn't about NoSQL at all. It was about his new competitor to the existing databases, SQL and NoSQL alike.
- ergo98 16y agoHe knows how to get press, and playing up that confrontation yields links and references. Just as many NoSQL pieces start off with some often ridiculous attacks on YeSQL. I'm still trying to understand how SciDB differs from VoltDB. We're currently evaluating VoltDB for some analysis processes.
- jhugg 16y agoVoltDB is focused on mutating an in-memory dataset at ultra-high speed with full transactions and ACID. SciDB is focused on analyzing petabytes of scientific data in array form, where people care about things like data provenance and accumulated error bounds. Almost polar opposites in use, but similar in philosophy. Both believe specialized systems are the way to handle specialized workloads.
- ergo98 16y agoVery interesting, thank you. This is the most concise description of this product that I have yet seen.
- dkarl 16y agoThat comment was about the NoSQL community's hostile reaction to his criticisms of MapReduce, and it does indeed show that they're not interested in knowing about databases, because they read his criticism in the context of an imaginary (or only-real-because-people-think-it's-real) SQL vs. NoSQL struggle. Instead of seeing it as an analysis of the shortcomings of MapReduce (and being curious about the perspective or needs that might make those shortcomings important,) their simplistic reaction was that he was fighting for the wrong side and needed to be discredited. One of the comments on the blog exemplifies the reaction perfectly: Technically, I agree with much of this article ... <snip> ... But none of that matters. It’s all about hearts and minds, and if the DB industry adopts the attitude in this article, it’s back to what I said at HPTS back in 2001: We Lose. Screw content, screw technical judgment, it's about attitude and "winning" the struggle "against" existing database technologies.