2 ms·
I liked this meme better the first time around -- when it was called CASE tools. Or how about the second, when it was called UML code generation? The computer
by bitwize 9y ago
I liked this meme better the first time around -- when it was called CASE tools.
Or how about the second, when it was called UML code generation?
The computer magazines of the 80s and 90s are littered with advertisements from fly-by-night companies promising: "Develop this app with ZERO lines of code!"
The problem with codeless development environments is -- okay, instead of code I'm going to represent programs with something else, say, a symbolic language based on flowchart symbols. The problem is, once my flowchart symbols become concrete enough to be executable by computer, they also become isomorphic to constructs in some programming language. So you haven't really gained anything in expressive power, but you have:
* possibly made things more comprehensible for visual thinkers (at the expense of verbal thinkers). Note that men skew visual and women skew verbal, so this may be considered sex discrimination.
* forced the developers to engage in far more rat wrestling
* required as a hard dependency a particular development environment in order just to get the "code" up on the screen, let alone interpret or change it, thus committing the mortal sin of vendor lock and, in QuickBase's case, locking the application into a cloud platform which may go away when the company liquidates
* made the program more difficult to version-control, diff, or perform large-scale edits on (outside those explicitly supported by the tool)
* turned complex programs into visual clutter, making them far more difficult to manage
* made it difficult or impossible to do things which violate the tool's assumptions about the program structure or function
And there will be assumptions, because the way to gain more expressive succinctness than is exposed by a typical programming language, and hence to build the case for using such a visual tool in the first place, is to assume like crazy. Assume that there is a database, that the application will appear as various forms and reports, that programmers will never need or use certain constructs/patterns, etc.
So invariably these attempts to take the code out of software development fail, and get relegated to niches akin to the skeevy back pages of PC Magazine right next to the porn advertisements. It seems to be happening again, as lastI heard QuickBase wasn't doing too good.