3 ms·
First off, you're mistaken. In general, baring disability, you don't collect a military retirement for under 20 years of service. You do get a TSP, but that's c
by astura 9y ago
First off, you're mistaken. In general, baring disability, you don't collect a military retirement for under 20 years of service. You do get a TSP, but that's contributions made by the sailor, the Navy doesn't contribute to that.[1][2] Sounds like either your grandpa got military disability benefits, you misunderstood what a TSP was, or he might have even been lying to you.[3]
You choose to drain your retirement early, if you didn't have that option (in other words, your employer controlled your retirement instead of you) you wouldn't magically get extra money to pay for cancer treatments - your retirement portion of your salary would just be unavailable for you to use. Just because you didn't use your retirement account for its intended purpose, that doesn't mean that defined contribution retirement plans are "broken."
In general, its probably not a great idea to drain retirement accounts to pay for bills, as they have some protection from creditors... at least talk with a bankruptcy attorney beforehand. I would personally rather declare bankruptcy than drain my retirement accounts.
It might just be me but I'd prefer controlling my money over my employer doing so, my employer might not even be around in five years. You can't prevent your employer from "investing" your retirement fund into Bernie Madoff's pyramid scheme[4], but you can prevent yourself from doing that. In the past I've worked at places where I don't trust upper management to make the right financial decisions. I'm glad I have a 401(k) because I can collect significant tax benefits from maxing it out.
Your wife obviously isn't going to get a retirement saying home with the kids with or without employee controlled pension, so I don't understand what that complaint is about? Or how it relates to retirement accounts.
In my opinion, if your employer offers a 401(k) they should be legally required to a) be opt out rather than opt in and b) be legally required to contribute some amount. That would fix some issues with people not prioritizing saving for retirement, however, unless you make draining your retirement account illegal then you aren't going to prevent people from doing dumb stuff.[5]
[1] They have actually changed that recently, a few years ago they introduced a new defined TSP contribution option that you may opt into instead of the defined benefit option.
[2] Some exceptions apply for war vets living in poverty
[3] I'm so sorry to bring up that possibility, I don't want to be mean, but its a fact that most people who claim to be in the special forces are lying, its a common thing.
[4] The NY Mets lost a bunch of money in Bernie Madoff's pyramid scheme.
[5] Dumb stuff being the guy I know who cashed out his retirement account to buy furniture.