4 ms·
Agree they "Vultures" were the suckers in this case. Although I was initially inclined to agree with the tone of the article, just the numbers in the article i
by toss1 9y ago
Agree they "Vultures" were the suckers in this case.
Although I was initially inclined to agree with the tone of the article, just the numbers in the article itself disproved it's main thesis.
Near the end:
> "Bain, KKR, and Vornado will have to write off their investment, of course. But they did suck around $200 million in fees out of Toys 'R' Us over the course of their ownership."
Near the beginning:
>"The trio put up $6.6 billion to pay off Toys 'R' Us' shareholders. But it was a leveraged buyout: Only 20 percent came out out of the buyers' pockets."
Net, using these numbers, is that the buyers put in $1320 million and took out $200 million, a net loss of $1.12 billion dollars. This doesn't mention the $5Billion lost by the other investors (minus whatever interim payments were made).
The board and shareholders did well to get out when they did, and I'd hypothesize that the employees, while still losing jobs, had the jobs with the buyout for years longer than they otherwise would have.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- benmmurphy 9y agothe article doesn't go into much detail about what the management fees were for or how much of the fee would be profit to the LBO group. its entirely possible that the LBO groups have a management staff on hand they parachute into their investments and this fee pays their wages and there is nothing much else left over.
- toss1 9y ago>"doesn't go into much detail" -- the article specifically stated that they totaled $200m in fees. The author was specifically trying to find and account for those fees. If there were more, the author would have included it as more fees supported his point better. So, you are claiming that the author somehow didn't find over a billion dollars in fees for them to break even over 15 years? If so, he's a pretty incompetent journalist. And, even if there are a billion in 'hidden' fees, they still lost money. For them to have made even a modest 5% interest for 15 years, which is a very modest/baseline profit goal for finance pros, you'd need to find almost $2billion in missing fees. So, where's the money?