6 ms·
Corporations have not gotten rid of retirement plans, they've gotten rid of unsustainable defined benefit retirement plans (pensions) in exchange for defined co
by pc86 9y ago
Corporations have not gotten rid of retirement plans, they've gotten rid of unsustainable defined benefit retirement plans (pensions) in exchange for defined contribution retirement plans (401ks).
- cortesoft 9y agoWhile I agree with you, I think it is important to note that defined benefit plans aren't INHERENTLY unsustainable. If you do the math right and are realistic, you can off them. You just can't underfund them or assume unrealistic stock market gains.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoThey're unsustainable because they require the ability to predict what will happen in the world 10,20,30+ years into the future, a feat that no one is capable of, hence the decline of defined benefit pensions. Except for those that can lean on taxpayers to make up for the miscalculations and erroneous assumptions.
- cortesoft 9y agoIf it was true that we can't predict the future well enough to provide a fixed income, then annuities wouldn't be a thing. We are certainly capable of predicting the future well enough to do it, the problem is that current management often has an incentive to be too optimistic about future returns when deciding how much to fund a pension. Annuity companies don't have those rose colored glasses, so they do a better job.
- sandworm101 9y ago>> then annuities wouldn't be a thing. Annuities are not pensions. They pay fixed amounts based on some interest rate. The difference is in the lifetime of the beneficiary. We all die eventually, normally befor hitting 100. Short of magic, that isn't going to change much. The difference with a defined benefit retirement plan is that the cost of benefits can rise drastically. Look at the difference in the cost of health care today and in 1960.
- rileymat2 9y agoThere are also inflation adjusted annuities. If you think this through, I don’t think you will see a dramatic difference.
- Frondo 9y agoIf no one can predict what will happen 10, 20, 30+ years in to the future, why is it okay when we're subjecting individuals' retirements to that same inability to predict the future?
- lotsofpulp 9y agoTheoretically, so they have skin in the game and that would prevent the endemic fraud in taxpayer funded pensions like we have. Realistically, you should be cultivating social capital by way of raising a family or networking with useful people if you really want a secure future.
- Jach 9y agoWhat does the math look like to you? I mean, back when I was a teenager I realized that this century is different, I shouldn't expect to do what my dad did and end up (albeit through a series of acquisitions / mergers) at the same company for 30-something years with a payout plan at the end. Sometime in 2012 I saw this article[0] which starts off: "The average lifespan of a company listed in the S&P 500 index of leading US companies has decreased by more than 50 years in the last century, from 67 years in the 1920s to just 15 years today" I doubt things look any rosier 6 years later. So what does the math look like when the firm lifespan of the most profitable companies is quite a bit less than the lifespan of someone's useful working period? [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/business-16611040 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-16611040
- cortesoft 9y agoIt means we shouldn't tie retirements to the company you are working for.
- Jach 9y agoWho is "we"? I'm curious how you propose to do the math right so that you, as an employer, can offer a plan that resembles a pension, and if it ends up being any different in practice than contributing to a 401k (which does transfer with jobs so is independent of your company).
- cortesoft 9y ago'We' being society. I think we put too much responsibility onto companies, expecting them to provide health insurance and retirement benefits to employees. Both of those things should not be tied to your job.
- Kalium 9y ago> You just can't underfund them or assume unrealistic stock market gains. You're absolutely correct. You cannot do these things and have functional DB plans. An issue arises when contemplating the incentives. Every person involved in the up-front planning for DB plans is incentivized to be wildly unrealistic about the future. It's not like anyone doing the negotiating will have any real consequences, so why not offer lower contributions to win your election / union approval / make quarterly numbers? DC plans have the distinct benefit of helping incentives align. It puts the costs on the balance sheet in the short term, and accountability is much more immediate. It's not a perfect compromise. For pretty much everyone, ideally run pensions are better. It's just that getting there has proven at best incredibly difficult and unreliable.
- logfromblammo 9y ago...And then gradually reduced their employer contributions to said plans to a pittance, or even zero. At that point, you might as well do your own thing with Vanguard or Fidelity. The net result is the company got rid of the retirement plan, and started reselling other companies' commercial retirement plan products to their employees.
- astura 9y agoEven if your employer's contribution is zero there's significant tax benefits for contributing to a 401(k) vs "doing your own thing with Vanguard or Fidelity." You can also "do your own thing with Vanguard or Fidelity" in an IRA, which has the tax benefits of a 401(k), however, the yearly contribution limits are unreasonably low, especially compared to a 401(k).
- logfromblammo 9y agoConceptually, the company is no longer contributing anything towards employee retirement. They are a transparent entity, ticking off the minimum requirements to realize the benefits from section 401(k), and don't do anything beyond telling the payroll company to divert X amount from the employee's paycheck, managed by that company, to their retirement fund account, managed by yet another company. If there is no employer contribution, you essentially already are doing your own thing, except with whomever your company picked to be the retirement benefits manager, instead of it being your own choice. So you create your own IRA at the company you pick, and roll over everything from your employer's 401(k) into it every time you switch jobs.
- astura 9y agoLet me be clear: hallow retirement plans really grind my gears. So much so that I strongly believe they should be illegal, either offer a real retirement plan or don't offer one at all. Minimum employer contributions should absolutely be mandatory. I also think that IRA and 401(k) contribution limits should be combined, so none of this "$5,500 IRA limit and $18,500 401(k) limit," it should be "$24,000 combined 401(k)/IRA limit." I was just saying that if you are young and have $10,000 a year to save for retirement you are better off, from a tax perspective, saving $5,500 into an IRA and $4,500 in your hallow 401(k) rather than saving $5,500 into an IRA and $4,500 in your Fidelity brokerage account. That's it.
- plurgid 9y agoSure, but the fuller picture is more like this. Nearly every major industrialized nation's infrastructure was bombed to hell after WW2, except America. To the victor went the spoils, and so our economy boomed to a much much greater degree than it would have otherwise. This lasted for a generation or two, and certain aspects of that capitalist feeding frenzy were enshrined as cultural values. The idea that there was a social contract between employers and employees, and that an average hard working American wouldn't be tossed out on the street if they got sick, would have a house to live in and would not have to toil in their old age, was baked into America. If you work hard and you're loyal, you'll be ok. However, where that was seen as a Governmental function after the Great Depression, in the boom years after WW2, the economy was simply flooded with money. When there's that much money and opportunity around, it's easy to start thinking that the Government was the problem. That the social contract would always remain, and that we could trust our bosses who we knew and worked with every day far more than some politically motivated government bureaucrat. Corporations bought the politicians. Then the politicians passed laws to make the bribery legal. Then slowly those post WW2 culturally enshrined easy answers became law. Now we have people seriously talking about "trickle down" economics as if it were a real thing. Because it was kinda like that in the 50's when we were the only major industrial powerhouse in the world. Now we've privatized nearly our entire healthcare system, because in the 50's hell, going to the doctor was cheap and how could that be anyone's problem but yours? And now we have no retirement plans other than "we will let you put some of your own money into the stock market tax free, but hey if the market tanks you're on your own bruh! (even though you had zippy control over that)" Again, because maybe that would have made sense in the 50's and 60's, and god knows if anything might have seemed true in that era it must be the word of God himself. The problem of course, is that now that the winning team picks the referees, there's pretty much no way out of this. The government SHOULD be providing healthcare, and decent retirement so that business doesn't have this burden. But then it'd be too easy to start new businesses. The referees picked by the last winning team aren't too keen on that.
- RestlessMind 9y agoThanks for the historical perspective. Now what about times before 1950's, when societies were typically /not/ flooded with money? You mention that "The government SHOULD be providing healthcare, and decent retirement". Was that the norm before 1950's anywhere? If yes, how did the math work out? I believe longer lifespans coupled with generous safety net provided by the government is a historical anomaly, propped up due to the growth spurt that happened post great depression + ww2. Now that things are reverting back to historical norms, we should rethink the way society is structured.
- wnissen 9y agoPensions are cheaper than 401(k) accounts. I will say it again, this is simple actuarial math: Pensions are cheaper than 401(k)s. Three reasons: 1. Some people will die before they collect, others will live far longer. With a pension the former subsidize the latter, and everyone who needs income gets it. In a 401(k) everyone has to save like they're going to live forever, or risk running out of money. If you keep your withdrawal rate at 4%, you probably could live forever, but that means you need 25 times your salary saved. Twenty five years salary! A pension does not need nearly the same level of assets. 2. A pension can ride out a "bad" market because some people are paying in while others are paying out. In a 401(k) if you retired in 2009, you took a lifetime hit, even with a balanced portfolio. And you can get hit by a bad market and a long life at the same time! 3. Individual investors are morons. They buy overpriced funds and do a lousy job managing them. I am a moron, but at least I know it and invest accordingly. Vanguard did a huge study of all their individual retirement accounts, and number of trades that produced the best return was: zero. Every trade you make (statistically) is buying high and selling low. Pension managers aren't perfect, but they pay attention to expenses and don't chase the latest hot stock. Therefore you need much less of a contribution to fund a pension. It depends on how you assess these factors, but Joey Schmoe is going to have to save 15% or more of her salary to get the same retirement security as a pension contribution of 10%. A pension is only unaffordable if those contributions aren't made, and then a wave of retirements sets off an unsustainable withdrawal. But that's not a feature of defined benefit vs. defined contribution, rather it's governments who use shady accounting rather than making a small contribution annually. When you add in the fact that almost everyone who contributes to 401(k)s is well-off (half the population doesn't even have access), it is hard to imagine a method that is less likely to lead to comfortable retirements.
- thewopr 9y agoThis is super interesting and something I've never thought about. One other issue I have noticed with 401k's. Do 401k's exacerbate inter-generational income inequality? I know a number of people who are going to, in the next few decades, inherit very sizable 401k accounts. This is great, in that their parents were very frugal, saved well, and had comfortable retirements. But on the flip side, a pension would have died with that person, now there is this ongoing inter-generational transfer of wealth that otherwise wouldn't have occurred.
- rhizome 9y agoTotally unrelated to the continually growing multiple of executive compensation over employees, I'm sure.
- apercu 9y agoNo, corporations shifted the risk to their workers.