4 ms·
Bitcoin is inflationary, and will remain so until 2140. It's just that the increase in demand is even bigger than the increase in supply. What you're actually
by icebraining 9y ago
Bitcoin is inflationary, and will remain so until 2140. It's just that the increase in demand is even bigger than the increase in supply.
What you're actually asking for is not an inflationary currency, but one that automatically adjusts its inflation rate to the demand. But that's not easy to achieve technically, and even if you could, it comes with its own issues, as the Swiss central bank can tell you.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Bitcoin is inflationary, and will remain so until 2140. It's just that the increase in demand is even bigger than the increase in supply Inflation is a measure of prices, not the money supply. Since our economy prices in U.S. dollars and Bitcoin has, for the most part, gone up vis-à-vis the dollar, Bitcoin itself has mostly been deflationary.
- icebraining 9y agoThis is quite besides my main point, but in any case, it's your economy, not ours; I don't see why the USD should be the measuring stick. The reality is that the amount of Bitcoin is being inflated every ten minutes.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> I don't see why the USD should be the measuring stick For inflation, it's not. A basket of real goods and services is. There are few practical baskets whose price, in Bitcoin, isn't falling.
- jtmcmc 9y agothat is not what inflation means in an economic sense.
- coralreef 9y agoWell, all nation state currencies get printed out of thin air. I don't see the downside to block rewards / BTC creation every X minutes, especially with a fixed supply limit.
- splintercell 9y ago> Inflation is a measure of prices, not the money supply. It depends, when this word was coined, it simply meant increase in money supply. We can prove it by looking at the word for inflation in other languages, for instance in Hindi it is 'Mudrasfiti', which literally means 'increase in currency'. Increase in money supply leads to increase in prices ceteris paribus, so people tend to conflate the two concepts. OP is correct in saying that 'Bitcoin is inflationary and will remain so until 2140'. Whether the prices in bitcoin rise because of that is independent of the fact whether bitcoin is inflationary.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> when this word was coined, it simply meant increase in money supply "Inflation was initially used to describe a change in the proportion of currency in circulation relative to the amount of precious metal that constituted a nation’s money" [1]. It was less a synonym for increased money supply than for debasement. From the 1930s, however, "the Keynesian revolution in economics...separated the word inflation from a condition of money and redefined it as a description of prices." Now "the term has become nearly synonymous with 'price increase'." Economists have no view on money supply per se. They do, however, have a view on price deflation. It is bad. Bitcoin, if treated as a currency, is price deflationary. As such, it inherits the junk that come with price deflation, namely hoarding in favor of real activity. > We can prove it by looking at the word for inflation in other languages, for instance in Hindi it is 'Mudrasfiti', which literally means 'increase in currency' This is not a proof... [1] https://www.clevelandfed.org/newsroom-and-events/publications/economic-commentary/economic-commentary-archives/1997-economic-commentaries/ec-19971015-on-the-origin-and-evolution-of-the-word-inflation.aspx https://www.clevelandfed.org/newsroom-and-events/publication...
- splintercell 9y agoMore importantly, someone has to benefit from the inflation at the end of the day. It's either going to be: * The token issuing authority, I don't think you'd like that * The existing token holders, but then don't they already benefit from increased prices of their tokens? Its like as if, you cannot create a system where you do not benefit the early adopters AND have them evangelize for you for free.