4 ms·
That's another bigger factor: if Apple doesn't include it as a standard for their mobile phones it's not going to get anybody anywhere unless all carriers seem
by giancarlostoro 9y ago
That's another bigger factor: if Apple doesn't include it as a standard for their mobile phones it's not going to get anybody anywhere unless all carriers seem to care to implement it at all. At which case I'm not seeing why pushing for XMPP wouldn't be as valid? Carriers have the capability to power XMPP networks that work accross carriers... Also requires less reinventing the wheel and being locked down to "Google said do this."
- aNoob7000 9y agoWhat I'm worried about is carriers not following the standard completely or charging for it.
- icebraining 9y agoCharging for what? The messages? Yes, supposedly RCS is designed to allow for per-message billing, like SMSs.
- 21 9y agoThere is no way you can charge again for messaging in a world of WhatsApp & co.
- 21 9y agoXMPP is a terrible square wheel.
- diggan 9y agoWhile I'm sure your opinion would be interesting, the comment you left here is very much not so. Instead of saying "I don't like this" and leave it at that, HN expects you to be able to write down your arguments and opinions so others can understand them. What you done here is lazy. Some further explanation about your view would probably be interesting. Otherwise, please don't comment at al.
- huhtenberg 9y agoYour comment is completely out of line and amounts to little more than a condescending public flagellation followed by a request for the OP to, basically, keep their mouth shut. I suspect I am not the only one here on HN who has far a much larger issue with self-righteous comments like yours than I would ever have with the OP's comment, even if it's a trivial one-liner.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoI disagree. GP isn't saying to keep their mouth shut; it's saying to put up or shut up, which is emphatically different. "$FOO is bad" isn't totally worthless, but it's weak, especially when it would have taken 45 seconds more to say, "$FOO is bad because it's implemented poorly/inconsistently, has weak support for encryption, [...]". And comments calling out unhelpful comments are slightly unpleasant, but still desirable feedback of what the desired norms are around here.
- wskinner 9y agoGGP is thoughtless. GP is mean. There are thoughtful ways to point out that someone is not contributing. He could have left a link to https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. In fact, a mocking reply like this does itself violate the HN guidelines in at least one way: it certainly doesn’t assume the most charitable intent for GGP’s comment. Comments like GGP are why we have downvotes, and why comments that get a lot of them appear gray. No need to humiliate someone for the sake of signaling your own virtue.
- jjrh 9y ago> if Apple doesn't include it as a standard for their mobile phones it's not going to get anybody anywhere unless all carriers seem to care to implement it at all. It's a GSMA spec, and according to wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GSMA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GSMA) the GSMA like 800 operators as members so pretty good chance this is going to get implemented (apparently Sprint already has?). Sounds like this is a carrier lead charge, most likely in response to folks ditching SMS for more flexible/featured alternatives.