3 ms·
> [undefined behavior for optimization] Yes, I am aware that that is the excuse. It still is a terrible excuse. > because you violated an invariant at some p
by mpweiher 9y ago
> [undefined behavior for optimization]
Yes, I am aware that that is the excuse. It still is a terrible excuse.
> because you violated an invariant at some point of program execution.
Not true. The code in question is a callback, so my code is getting called by Apple code, and ARC dereferences a pointer it has no business de-referencing.
May I remind you that the code that crashed due to a segfault was
{
return 0;
}
Also, if you think "You have violated something, for which we will give you no diagnostic, and therefore we feel free to crash you at some random other place in the program that has nothing to do with the place where the alleged violation took place, again with no diagnostics" is reasonable...well, could I interest you in purchasing a bridge in New York? Or some Nevada oceanfront real estate?
And no, you don't need a "safer" language like Swift, you just need to not go for the crazy modifications the optimizer writers pushed into the C standard.
- saagarjha 9y ago> if you think "You have violated something, for which we will give you no diagnostic, and therefore we feel free to crash you at some random other place in the program that has nothing to do with the place where the alleged violation took place, again with no diagnostics" is reasonable No, I generally don't, which is why I use a safer language like Swift most of the time (well, that, and the fact that I can take advantage of a nicer standard library). You put "safer" in quotes, because I don't think you quite understand how compiler optimizations are supposed to work. I think Chris Lattner's three part series, "What Every C Programmer Should Know About Undefined Behavior"[1], is a great explanation from a compiler writer for why dangerous optimizations have to exist. It certainly helped me when I was in a similar place as you, not quite understanding why the optimizer did seemingly stupid things. Really, the crux of the issue is that every language has tradeoffs: you can program in assembly and know exactly what your program is doing, but you lose the portability and convenience of higher level languages. Then you have the C family of languages, where you get access to some higher level concepts at the cost of ceding control to a compiler. The compiler's job is to generate assembly that matches what you are trying to do in the most efficient way possible. Of course, if it did so too literally it would be very slow to account for every single "stupid" thing you could have done, so there are some general rules that are imposed that you must follow in order for the compiler to do what you want. Then, of course, we have the high-level languages which do account for every stupid thing you might do, and so can provide proper diagnostics. [1] http://blog.llvm.org/2011/05/what-every-c-programmer-should-know.html http://blog.llvm.org/2011/05/what-every-c-programmer-should-...
- mpweiher 9y agoI have programmed in C since ~1986, so please don't try to explain the language to me, and don't assume that my POV comes from a place of ignorance. The craziness with undefined behavior is a fairly recent phenomenon. In fact, I started programming in C before there even was a standard, so all behavior was "undefined", yet no compiler manufacturer would have dreamed of taking the liberties that are taken today. Because they had paying customers. The actual benefits of the optimizations enabled are fairly minimal, and the cost is insane, with effectively every C program in existence suddenly sprouting crazy behavior, behavior that used to not be there. Yeah, and while I know Chris personally, like and respect him, I am not taking his word for it. > The compiler's job is to generate assembly that matches what you are trying to do in the most efficient way possible Exactly: "matches what you are trying to do". The #1 cardinal rule of optimization is to not alter behavior. That rule has been shattered to little pieces that have now been ground to fine powder. Sad times. See: Proebsting's law, "The Death of Optimizing Compilers" and "What every compiler writer should know about programmers or “Optimization” based on undefined behaviour hurts performance"
- saagarjha 9y ago> I have programmed in C since ~1986, so please don't try to explain the language to me, and don't assume that my POV comes from a place of ignorance. I apologize for my tone, it was more patronizing that I had intended it to be. > The craziness with undefined behavior is a fairly recent phenomenon. In fact, I started programming in C before there even was a standard, so all behavior was "undefined", yet no compiler manufacturer would have dreamed of taking the liberties that are taken today. I feel that the current renewed focus on optimizing compilers has really been born out of the general slowing of Moore's law and stagnation in hardware advances in general, as well as improvements in program analysis taken from other languages. Just my personal guess as to why. > Exactly: "matches what you are trying to do". The #1 cardinal rule of optimization is to not alter behavior. That rule has been shattered to little pieces that have now been ground to fine powder. The optimizing compiler has a different opinion than you do of "altering behavior". If you're looking for something that follows what you're doing exactly, write assembly. That's the only way you can guarantee that the code you have is what's being executed. A similar, but not perfect solution is compiling C at -O0, which matches the behavior of older compilers: generate assembly that looks basically like the C code that I wrote, and perform little to no analysis on it. Finally, we have the optimization levels, where the difference is that you are telling the compiler to make your code fast; however, in return, you promise to follow the rules. And if you hold up your side of the bargain, the compiler will hold up its own: make fast code that doesn't alter your program's visible behavior.