2 ms·
> None of this detracts from the fact that racial categorizations are useful and predictive for the overwhelming majority of the Earth's population, just as the
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> None of this detracts from the fact that racial categorizations are useful and predictive for the overwhelming majority of the Earth's population, just as the questionable status of Pluto doesn't interfere with research on extra-solar planets.
The issue is that racial categories are completely arbitrary to begin with. The fact that the members of each category are not completely indistinguishable doens't mean the category makes any sense.
For example, you could categorize animals into two groups, one containing all animals that are small, nocturnal or green and the other containing all other animals. The members of each group will certainly have differences, but that doesn't change the fact that the category itself is incoherent. There is no good reason to draw a line in that particular place.
And, in the case of race, a very good reason not to -- the category was originally created as a tool of oppression and used to drive a wedge between people, which is what it continues to do whenever people continue to use it.
- fvdessen 9y ago> The issue is that racial categories are completely arbitrary to begin with It's not entirely arbitrary. If you run a clustering algorithm on the human genome you get clusters that match quite well the usual definition of races and ethnicities.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoYou get clusters that match quite well with geographic origin for obvious reasons. But that isn't race. Irish, Sicilians and Kazakhstanis will be in three different clusters even though they're all supposed to be the same "race".