5 ms·
> owning is cheaper than renting This is the key thing! Obviously owning is cheaper than renting, as renters have to cover the costs of their landlord owning,
by chrisseaton 9y ago
> owning is cheaper than renting
This is the key thing! Obviously owning is cheaper than renting, as renters have to cover the costs of their landlord owning, and then some profit for them on top of that.
- pwinnski 9y agoA house built today of a certain size can be purchased with a lower monthly payment than it can be rented, yes, for exactly the reason you describe. A house built ten years ago, or twenty years ago, or thirty years ago, can often be rented much more cheaply than a house built today can be purchased. An apartment of the same size as that hypothetical house might be higher or lower, since the economics of apartment buildings tend to be different. A 1-bedroom or 2-bedroom apartment can quite often be rented more cheaply than a 3-bedroom house. "owning is cheaper than renting" is exactly the sort of generalization that gets people into trouble. Every situation is slightly different.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pgwhalen 9y agoWhile this is mostly true, it’s important to understand that rents are not just “cost + profit.” They are market based. Sure, the market often pushes it towards something close to that formula, but it is not a guarantee, and many of the subtleties of buying vs renting are lost on those who reduce it to that formula.
- closeparen 9y agoYour landlord is probably not buying at the same instant he signs a lease with you, and he could be benefitting from economies of scale that you don't have by purchasing capital, homes, and maintenance services in bulk.
- cosmie 9y agoThe market tends to decouple from that logic in an appreciating market. My landlord bought the house I'm in about 10 years ago. His mortgage is a fixed monthly payment that's locked in from when my house was worth less than half it's current value. The rent for where I live tracks really closely to the mortgage rate it'd cost me to buy at it's current valuation. For any investor that bought a rental right now, they'd barely make anything per month. But for my landlord that bought 10 years ago, he nets $1k - $1.5k per month above his costs. It's also not as straightforward in a depreciating market, either. In a depreciating market, some property owners may rent a property out at a loss, with the expectation that the monthly loss is temporary and less than the loss they'd take it they sold now.
- ghaff 9y ago>The market tends to decouple from that logic in an appreciating market. I don't know how decoupled but I definitely know of cases where someone bought and has a good longterm tenant and that tenant gets a pretty good rate because they're profitable, a known entity, and low maintenance.
- cozzyd 9y agoIn the case of renting a SFH from a random person, that might be kind of true (but not all landlords make money off renting anyway), but consider: - Your landlord may have a lot more capital to buy homes with no mortgage and the and ability to maintain homes cheaper than you can or remodel homes cheaper than you can. - Your landlord might be a large apartment complex where the economics are different from SFH.
- usaar333 9y agoAs sibling comments note, not necessarily due to appreciation being baked into housing costs. Additionally, the owner and renter may have different risk tolerances where in the renter is comfortable putting cash in the stock market, the owner might want lower-risk, lower-yielding assets. Finally due to tax distortions, the owner may have a better deal on their own house than a prospective new owner could get. The Bay Area is an example where renting is much cheaper than owning: https://medium.com/@usaar33/why-you-shouldnt-buy-a-home-in-the-bay-area-right-now-9eff37da8d6 https://medium.com/@usaar33/why-you-shouldnt-buy-a-home-in-t...
- refurb 9y agoThat's not true at all. My landlord bought the condo I live in 10 years ago when it was worth maybe 30% of what it is today. My rent right now is ~40% of what my mortgage would be if I bought the place. We're both happy!