3 ms·
A common story in manufacturing is an anti-union story: labour pricing itself above what capital wants to spend. And a common sub-story in this story, is trying
by ggm 9y ago
A common story in manufacturing is an anti-union story: labour pricing itself above what capital wants to spend. And a common sub-story in this story, is trying to use automation as a big cudgel to beat labour, especially organized labour with.
And, Elon Musk is said (by unionists) to be pretty anti union. Silicon Valley is said to be pretty anti-union. New capital, the Ayn Randeans, they're pretty anti-union.
So, I suspect there is another side to this story: If you want to try and use robots to avoid confronting your labour issues, you need to understand the value labour brings to an endevour. There is no dumb labour, there is only expensive and cheap labour. Cheap labour is rarely worth it. Expensive labour is often necessary.
Cutting corners includes trying to avoid having to employ people.
Jeff Bizos is also very anti unions. But, he automated very slowly. I think his work floor practices in the packing mills he runs is very bad, but if we discount that, it is perhaps far more sensible: learn how to run supply chain logistics with the minimum sensible automation, then slowly increase.
I suspect had Musk swallowed his pride, and his anti union and anti labour views, and employed people, and organised labour, he might have avoided this problem. Of course, he would have walked into another problem: organised labour is not cheap.
But then, a tesla isn't cheap either.
How does he make rockets? Does he use robots, or people, or a blend of both?