8 ms·
The thing is, most of the changes MLB (well, basically Rob Manfred) has proposed lately don't really "improve" anything. The last good change was introducing t
by ubernostrum 9y ago
The thing is, most of the changes MLB (well, basically Rob Manfred) has proposed lately don't really "improve" anything.
The last good change was introducing the ability to challenge a call and get it reviewed. Since then we've seen the slide and collision rules, which mostly nobody -- even, at times, the umpires -- seems to understand well enough to apply. And the new pitch-less intentional walk, which was just pointless as a time-saver. And this year the mound-visit count, which is pointless again. And now proposals like starting extra innings with a runner in scoring position, because apparently the drama of a tied game with potential sudden-death situations isn't interesting and we just need to make sure it ends as quickly as possible, or ideas for how to make defensive shifts illegal so hitters never have to adjust to how the defense is playing.
Baseball is always going to be a more slow-paced game than the other major sports. That's inherent in the game. The solution should be to find ways to embrace that and showcase the interesting things that lead to it having the pace it does. And really the biggest focus ought to be on solving the ridiculous maze of restrictions on watching major-league baseball without a cable TV subscription, since the game needs to maintain a base of younger fans and those fans increasingly are not going to have traditional TV subscriptions.
Baseball is currently literally in the business of telling people "it's nice that you want to pay hundreds of dollars to watch our sport, but we're not in the business of letting you do that". This recent article gave a good overview of how that happened despite MLB having probably the best streaming and online service of any major US sport:
https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/04/major-league-baseball-blackout-rules-alienate-fans/ https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/04/major-league-baseball...
- oplav 9y agoRob Manfred has been pretty open about one of his goals being pace of play and speeding up games. Pitch-less intentional walks and limiting mound visits both help achieve that goal. > proposals like starting extra innings with a runner in scoring position Manfred has said this is a rule that will not make its way into the majors [0]. The objective is to lower pitch counts for developing pitchers in the minor leagues. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxMK_Wwgvl8&feature=youtu.be&t=555 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxMK_Wwgvl8&feature=youtu.be...
- phamilton 9y ago> Pitch-less intentional walks... help achieve that goal. IBB occurred 970 times in 2017. Assuming the pitch-less intentional walk saves 5 minutes each time it occurs (which is a high estimate), the average game time dropped by 2 minutes. That's not a huge difference. EDIT: had the wrong numbers, updated with the right numbers.
- trophycase 9y agoAverage game time dropping by 2 minutes with miniscule to zero effect on gameplay (may change player fatigue slightly) is absolutely massive in my opinion