3 ms·
I wonder if this trend will result in further stratification of American society. I mean, we've always had enclaves where rich people lived and poorer people li
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
I wonder if this trend will result in further stratification of American society. I mean, we've always had enclaves where rich people lived and poorer people lived, but they generally used to be at least nearby each other in large metros.
Now, though, this city stratification feels like a multi-layer sieve. E.g. San Francisco is still a super-desirable city to live, if you can afford it, so the people who can't get pushed to mid-tier cities, and then in those mid-tier cities poorer people get pushed out as the city gets less affordable. The whole SF Bay Area -> Austin -> (now still less expensive cities like Chattanooga, Pittsburgh, etc.) fits this pattern.
- hueving 9y agoIt's always been this way. People didn't go west because they had a good life on the east coast.
- bilbo0s 9y agoBy the time the "GENT-rification" reaches Chattanooga and Pittsburgh though, it's become something more akin to "SQUIRE-ification". The people moving in are not nearly as wealthy, so people are not really being pushed out in the numbers that they are pushed out in places like Manhattan or San Fran. It's the difference between a few thousand hundred-thousandaires moving in, as opposed to a few thousand millionaires and billionaires moving in. There really is a material and nontrivial difference in the housing market ripples resultant from these two hypothetical immigrant waves. Far fewer people, if any, wind up displaced in the third and fourth tier cities that the hundred-thousandaires move into. Developers operating in these cities simply can't afford to remake the markets the way you can in the larger cities. The numbers typically don't allow for it. Whereas in the first tier cities, the market in entire swaths of these cities can be remade and become astronomically unaffordable in a matter or 5 or 10 years. And the numbers in that large market make it very profitable for a developer to do so.
- closeparen 9y ago>"The people moving in are not nearly as wealthy, so people are not really being pushed out in the numbers that they are pushed out in places like Manhattan or San Fran." Backwards! Third-tier cities have contracted from their 20th-century peaks, so easily commutable lots and even homes are simply vacant. They're affordable to mere hundred-thousandaires because they're drowning in supply (though it might need some work). Displacement doesn't happen as much because abundance means you can get your own spot without taking someone else's. The crappiest apartments in the San Francisco neighborhoods that time forgot are still insanely expensive next to national norms. No development is necessary for sufficiently high migration (against sufficiently low housing stock) to create a capacity crunch, and you're just as evicted when you're outbid by $500 vs. $5000.
- pm90 9y agoIts already happened to a certain extent. Most expensive American cities have some core industry: Sf = tech, NYC = finance, LA = movies, Chicago = commodities. This clustering of talent attracts even more talent, keeping the city’s economic engine humming along. Since the housing stock and transportation takes longer to evolve, the big cities see higher and higher rents. Usually economic downturns stabilize things a little bit. But we’re now in the midst of the longest economic expansion ever seen in the history of the US.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoYou have to keep in mind that this economic migration to and from cities is something that's been happening for centuries and likely since the beginning of human civilization. The US is a particularly great illustration of this since it's such a new nation. Every single city in the US was a remote backwoods not all that long ago. And then the same process happens over and over. Some city begins to attract more and more people. This results in development and growth. Those that succeed during this period rise to the top and thrive. Some of those that do not move on and try to take part in what becomes the next great opportunity. Take San Francisco for instance. The thing that brought it from being a backwoods to a major city was the gold rush of 1849, which is also where the name of the football team 'The San Francisco 49ers' comes from). You get a huge influx of people, lots of money and resources flowing, and the next thing you know it's one its way to becoming one of the largest cities in the US with massive growth. However, the opposite can also happen. For instance Detroit used to be one of the most desirable cities in the US. It was the 4th largest city in the nation with a surplus of great high paying jobs. This wealth and opportunity ended up attracting vast numbers of people - more than there was opportunity for. And then on top of that what jobs and opportunities there began declining. And next thing you know people are leaving the cities and droves and today it's home to countless empty buildings, the second highest crime rate, and one of the highest unemployment rates in the country. In the end the point is that cities, and the demographics within them, are in constant shift. Thing's change over time and it's always up the individual to find where the greatest 'value' is, with the meaning of 'value' certainly varying quite heavily from person to person.