4 ms·
> Child advocates have also raised alarms about the ease with which smartphone-equipped children are exposed to inappropriate videos and deceptive advertising.
by DanBC 9y ago
> Child advocates have also raised alarms about the ease with which smartphone-equipped children are exposed to inappropriate videos and deceptive advertising.
COPPA has unfortunate consequences. My 7 year old child watches youtube. He can't have an account, so he uses my account. Youtube thinks an > 18 year old is watching the videos, and so places ads for gambling and alcohol on the videos he watches.
There's no mechanism to tell Google that:
i) My child is under 18 and so cannot legally buy the products being advertised (and in the UK it's illegal to target alcohol to children)
ii) I campaign against alcohol and gambling adverts, and that's the only reason they think I have an interest in the product. I'm never going to buy these products.
The Youtube Kids product isn't available on my laptop, and he's not interested in many of those videos.
And the fix seems simple enough: allow a toggle for "viewer is under 18".
- pjc50 9y agoIt sounds like an adblocker would be responsible parenting best practice here.
- scrollaway 9y agoNot letting a child on the web without an adblocker is, in general, responsible parenting. The ad industry is at its scummiest when it comes to ads targeted at kids (and it's been that way for decades, it's just especially visible on the web).
- prepend 9y agoThat’s because Google doesn’t care because you let him watch. Lots of companies comply with coppa (Amazon, Netflix, Apple, Microsoft) and Google could if they carded enough. But even if their kids app was available on your laptop, it’s still inappropriate for kids. So you letting your kid watch YouTube as an 18 year old is a personal decision and not much to do with coppa existing or not existing.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoAgree. My kids learned how to lie about year born when they were in grade school.
- Natsu 9y agoI'd simply watch YouTube without an account? I've not seen any reason to log in unless you're going to upload a video or leave a comment and he could get you for that.
- dannypgh 9y agoI think you're looking for familylink: https://support.google.com/youtubekids/answer/7124142?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtubekids/answer/7124142?hl=en