4 ms·
> is the observed matter's thermodynamic arrow of time determined by whether the model is expanding or collapsing? I don't see any reason why these two would h
by pdonis 9y ago
> is the observed matter's thermodynamic arrow of time determined by whether the model is expanding or collapsing?
I don't see any reason why these two would have to be connected, since the FRW model as it is used in cosmology is only supposed to describe the average behavior of matter on very large distance scales. It certainly is not intended to describe, for example, a cup of hot water on my kitchen table cooling as it exchanges heat with the surrounding air.
> in a collapsing background, can we have observed systems in which Boltzmann entropy is increasing?
Why not?
> In the collapsing dust background we have an initial configuration with a large coarse-grained entropy, and marching "forward" in time we see the Boltzmann entropy decreasing
If you choose the initial configuration precisely enough, yes. But again, in an actual collapsing universe you most likely would not have such a precisely chosen initial configuration, since such a configuration would have to be extremely smooth, i.e., it would have to have an extremely small variation in density. Our actual universe is nothing like that--it's highly clumped. A collapsing universe with lots of clumps separated by empty space would not collapse into a "big crunch" state in the very small volume of phase space you describe. Its "big crunch" state would be very different--lots and lots of inhomogeneities being magnified by the collapse.
(Roger Penrose discusses this kind of model in, IIRC, The Emperor's New Mind, in the context of proposing his "Weyl Curvature Hypothesis", which says that an "initial" state is one with zero, or at least very small, Weyl curvature. The "big bang" state of our own universe was like that. But the "big crunch" state of a universe that is clumped like ours as it collapses would have very large Weyl curvature--diverging to infinity as the final singularity was approached. A "real" black hole final singularity would be similar--look up "BKL singularity" for an actual known solution to the Einstein Field Equation of this kind.)
(Note, btw, that in an idealized FRW solution, the Weyl curvature is zero everywhere. So in a universe that exactly realized such a solution, the issues described above cannot arise. But of course, as I said, our actual universe is not a precisely idealized FRW solution; that's only an approximation valid on large distance scales.)
> This is the implicit (and here, third) gauging, wherein we pick out and totally order hypersurfaces by their coarsest-grained Boltzmann entropy.
I see. I agree that, in general, we cannot prove that such a gauging even exists. I'm not sure whether anything significant in our current cosmological models depends on assuming that it does.
> I'm not sure we should trust that the RW metric should be always-expanding or always-contracting.
I'm not sure what you mean. If you are referring to the fact that there are also solutions which start with a big bang, expand, then recollapse into a big crunch, that's true; these solutions are their own time reverses.
> What evidence conflicts with us being in one region of a reproducing cosmology where we have possibly many (unobserved but not necessarily in principle unobservable) hot dense phases and many cold sparse phases, where the one that we can see (back to the surface of last scattering) is only relatively low entropy?
This looks like an eternal inflation model. AFAIK at least some such models are consistent with what we know.
- raattgift 9y ago> This looks like an eternal inflation model Yes, and the particular one I was thinking about was Carroll & Chen arXiv:hep-th/0410270. Rather than an expanding cosmology < (t-axis horizontal; x vertical) or an expanding and recollapsing <>, they have something closer to ><, which close to what I had in mind with, "... RW metric [might not be] always-expanding or always-contracting". Of course <> fits that too. I'm not sure we're really disagreeing on anything now - I think that we agree that while the homogeneity-on-every-slice constraint is a useful picture for many things, it's not really useful for distinguishing the ends of time of e.g. a collapsing universe with three crucial epochs: one that's smooth and low entropy, one that's lumpy and higher entropy, and one that's even higher entropy, exactly (as you wrote) because that's not what the standard model can yield on its own; you need to perturb around the model, for instance. Once you're doing that, you're not doing physics in the model sensu stricto. But surely for a question like this we want to depart from homogeneity on every slice? For smoothness I just assume that reheating after inflation does that and we get clumping after baryogenesis. For a recollapsing universe (with eventual galaxies), if you can give me a sketch of a mechanism for dismantling late-epoch structure into something reasonably similar to the dark ages in our universe, I'd go away and have a think about think about how to distinguish the different ends of time. But otherwise, I agree '"big crunch" state would be very different--lots and lots of inhomogeneities being magnified by the collapse' and argue that distinguishes the two ends of time sufficiently that a thermodynamic arrow of time points towards increasing entropy. > If you choose the initial configuration precisely enough Yes, that's the kernel of the argument. > > in a collapsing background, can we have observed systems in which Boltzmann entropy is increasing? > Why not? Let me try to tighten the wording: in a collapsing universe where the entropy the entropy at one end of time is higher than the entropy at the other, can we have long-lived mutually-interacting systems where one is decreasing in Boltzmann entropy as it gets closer to the higher-entropy end, while the other is increasing in Boltzmann entropy as it gets closer to the higher-entropy end? Or does the one with more DOF's "correct" the other?
- pdonis 9y ago> I'm not sure we're really disagreeing on anything now Agreed. :-) > in a collapsing universe where the entropy the entropy at one end of time is higher than the entropy at the other, can we have long-lived mutually-interacting systems where one is decreasing in Boltzmann entropy as it gets closer to the higher-entropy end, while the other is increasing in Boltzmann entropy as it gets closer to the higher-entropy end? I don't see why not. The only constraint the second law imposes is that net entropy has to increase; it certainly doesn't forbid one of a pair of interacting systems from decreasing in entropy, as long as the other's entropy increases at least as much.