11 ms·
I don't think a single one of my friendships involve a common enemy, beyond both of us being allied against boredom. Physics is unrecognizable after being passe
by whatshisface 9y ago
I don't think a single one of my friendships involve a common enemy, beyond both of us being allied against boredom. Physics is unrecognizable after being passed through the dirty lens of journalism, and I guess this is what happens when they report on fields with even messier situations.
>Game theory models predict it, real-life examples confirm it. “In order to band together, we need a common enemy,” Dr. Christakis said.
What do these models say about behavior around shared tasks? There are a lot of prisoner's dilemmas and tragic commons in the world but there actually are some cases where you can get something out of nature while other people help. Maybe that's why hackers tend to not be very xenophobic, they have something to focus on other than dividing up the morning's pie.
- mantas 9y agoPoor hackers still face same dividing the pie problem. Thats like saying people who got a hobby are less xenophobic. Which I doubt is true. More like rich people don’t care about daily issues of poor people and then there’s a divide resulting in Trump.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoThe very next graph moderates that statement: “Fortunately, he added, no model insists that the out-group must be exterminated or otherwise eliminated from the scene. “It’s possible to treat the out-group with mild dislike or even grudging respect,” he said. “Cultivating in-group distinctiveness does not require that the other must be killed.” And look: you’re giving the perfect example of such “mild dislike”! Quote: “The dirty lenses of journalism”. I agree that xenophobia is somewhat rare among “hackers”, but I don’t think you can easily deny some ingroup/outgroup dynamics in this scene. Social sciences and the liberal arts are routinely ridiculed. “The media” is constantly treated as incompetent (see above). And misogyny is somewhat common.
- whatshisface 9y agoCriticism of science journalism isn't in-group/outgroup, it's a claim about the state of the world. How do we know this? If I became a science writer, I wouldn't change my mind. Likewise, I think that most of the criticism of the humanities comes from people that read that kind of stuff in college and didn't like it. I don't work at McDonalds, so is it tribalism if I say I don't like BigMacs? There's no apology or justification for misogyny, though.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoSure... and xenophobia is just clearly seeing that foreigners are dirty. And when the Xenophobe vacations in Mexico, they still thinks these people around them are dirty.
- whatshisface 9y agoI don't think science journalists are stupid or morally inferior, I just observe a very bad track record of confusing and misleading articles. When I tell people to take them with a grain of salt, things get better. There are good science journalists, but I can't practically pass out lists of names. It sounds like the principle you're bringing in to play here could make anything count as xenophobic, so long as it involved a negative opinion and more than one group. This is dangerous because there are many opinions which are not xenophobic and are useful: misclassifying them as xenophobic introduces the error of "useful xenophobia," which is a very dangerous mistake. Edit: I think I've debugged the issue. I'm treating these things like they're true and were discovered independently, and you are treating them like they're false (or at least unjustified) and spread socially. I know that in my case I've learned to not like science journalism first-hand, by reading articles while knowing about their subject matter (an incredibly surreal experience).
- IAmEveryone 9y agoNo, the point is that hating on journalists is a group dynamic. It’s so common on HN for example, that it is frankly impossible all of its purveyors came up with the idea independently. That’s true even if the collective complaints have a basis in fact. People are social animals, susceptible to group-think. There’s really nothing wrong with that, as long as we’re willing to accept the possibility and don’t succumb to the firehouse effect.
- whatshisface 9y agoIt feels like the metric for "xenophobic groupthink" that's being used here could end up matching anything. It feels right because it's leading to an answer that feels right (that scientists should stop saying mean things about scholars in the broader sense, I agree they should), but that doesn't mean that it's a good principle: what about all the other cases? >It’s so common on HN for example, that it is frankly impossible all of its purveyors came up with the idea independently. That’s true even if the collective complaints have a basis in fact. If our complaints have enough of a basis in fact, then why would it be unlikely for everyone with the right domain knowledge to realize the same thing? The idea that something can be factual but also still somehow based in groupthink belies an understanding of the word that leads back to another common criticism of the humanities...
- goatlover 9y ago> Maybe that's why hackers tend to not be very xenophobic, they have something to focus on other than dividing up the morning's pie. But certainly tribal when it comes to technology choices.
- mpweiher 9y agoYep. Hackers generally don't care what you look like, as long as you use choice of emacs/vim, spaces/tabs, dynamic/static typing, FP/OO, web/native, etc. And that's tribalism based on choices, not on immutable characteristics. And most people take it with a grain of salt.
- mantas 9y agoDressed up (suit and tie kind of dressed up) people are likely to get a stare or too though. It's very hard to draw a line on immutable vs chosen traits. I had some people argue that communists killing rich people or entrepreneurs is fine since it's "based on choice". Although technically it is a choice, I couldn't agree that someone can drop what they did their whole life on a whim.
- mpweiher 9y ago> Dressed up Hmm...you can't choose how you dress? > killing rich people ... choice Hmm...I'd humbly suggest that the primary problem here is not the "based on choice" part, but rather the killing part. Not suggesting that's the only problem, but certainly the high order bit. The next bit would be that previously, these were considered admirable qualities, not evil ones. So something about ex post facto laws, which tend to be broadly unconstitutional if you have rule of law. So I don't really think it's hard to draw a line between immutable and chosen traits, and I also don't think that distinction plays much of a role, if any, in the examples you give.
- mantas 9y ago> Hmm...you can't choose how you dress? I was commenting this about "hackers generally don't care what you look like". Not "based on choice" part. > Hmm...I'd humbly suggest that the primary problem here is not the "based on choice" part, but rather the killing part. Personally I'm uncomfortable with killing or oppressing anybody. Some people feel that oppressing or killing "based on choice" is fine. I'm not comfortable to split traits by choices or immutable.
- vervez 9y agoThis is a little bit of a tangent but I was just listening to a program on NPR about baboons and their relationships. Specifically, the toxic effect of being the alpha-male. While I couldn't catch the whole program, I did hear they mentioned that while baboons have tumultuous lives surviving, mating, and dealing with alpha males, they do have a small opportunity for friendship with one another. One of the surprising findings from a study on baboons was that the baboons who were friendlier/not alpha-males tended to have more offspring than the alphas. A case of nice guys winning and friendship being more meaningful than dominance. Here, I'd gander that it's less about game theory and more about evolution of a cohesive unit. And that's my baboon tangent.
- socrates666 9y agoIt has also been shown that alpha makes, in business, tend to lose money owing to short sighted thought processes. In fact, the guy who originally coined the idea that humans have an alpha male concept pulled back on the notion, saying that he was mistaken in comparing human hierarchy to wolves. Humans aren't actually hierarchical. We believe in equality and because of this can form many different kinds of social structures (which is where political struggle comes from, i.e. democracy, Communism, socialism, etc.) It's nice when someone steps up and volunteers to do all of the work though.
- darkerside 9y agoThe customer, whoever that may be, is certainly an out group in that case
- samirillian 9y agoYeah, i think that's the distinction between cooperative and non-cooperative games. Though the formal definition might be a bit different from the naive interpretation of those terms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative_game_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative_game_theory
- toothbrush 9y ago> Maybe that's why hackers tend to not be very xenophobic Actually, i respectfully question that assertion. In my limited experience, groups of hackers have actually been much more on the homogenous side than random other groups of friends or freely-associating people (recent examples off the top of my head: a recent software developers meetup, or the makeup of the engineering department i work in – spoiler: it's overwhelmingly white, male, able-bodied and middle-class, straight). And IMHO, a lack of diversity certainly signals that something is going on. You might find the term "xenophobia" too strong, but exclusion is real and happens, _especially_, i would argue, among hackers. You needn't actively say something silly like "i don't like women joining my hackathon" for there to be a very palpable jock-nerd atmosphere that will turn off many folks that aren't white/middle-class/male. I think this might be an unpopular opinion here, but i believe it bears pointing out. A while ago i read a very thought-provoking book entitled "Unlocking the Clubhouse" by Margolis and somebody else whose name eludes me. If you're not already convinced by the unapproachable ivory-tower side of STEM fields, that book may convince you.
- q12we34rt5 9y ago>groups of hackers have actually been much more on the homogenous side >it's overwhelmingly white, male, able-bodied and middle-class, straight). And IMHO, a lack of diversity Nice job. I think you managed to touch just about all the bases in the buzzword lottery.
- qznc 9y agoThese are not buzzword. The words have a precise meaning.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago"You're wrong because you used buzzwords" is no better than a buzzword itself. Can you address their actual point?
- q12we34rt5 9y agoWhat point? Let me inform you of something. When I was growing up, I remember quite clearly being teased and bullied because I liked to read a lot and I liked messing around with computers. The peer group I surrounded myself with were other people just like me who also put up with the merciless bullying. Everybody else self-selected out of my peer group and did everything they could to make me feel lesser because of my interests. But now all of a sudden the internet and smartphones catch on and now coding is "cool". And the same people that selected themselves out of my group now accuse me of being "xenophobic" and "homogeneous". The fucking gall.
- Viliam1234 9y ago> I don't think a single one of my friendships involve a common enemy, beyond both of us being allied against boredom. Similar here. The "common enemy" in my friendships typically refers to something impersonal, such as the universe or sickness or falsehood; but often something much less dramatic, such as boredom or being alone. Maybe this is just a way to reuse the ancient brain circuits that evolved to create coalitions against human enemies. But the evolutionary purpose of something, and how I use it in my everyday life, those are often two different things. Maybe most people only use those ancient brain circuits the old way, dunno. That sounds horrible, but I guess it could explain some horrible parts of reality. But it's definitely not the only way.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> Maybe that's why hackers tend to not be very xenophobic, they have something to focus on other than dividing up the morning's pie. There was a study (I don't have it handy, I'm afraid) showing that women were a much higher percentage of programmers in the earliest decades of computing, and those numbers fell swiftly and kept falling as the field became established and commercial. That at least implies to me that women felt the pressure of an increasingly unwelcome environment in computing, as the field matured and expectations stratified. Hackers, in my experience, are less xenophobic than many groups, but I wouldn't hold them up as a bastion of acceptance either.