9 ms·
Not your Tibetan Buddhism
- est 9y agoIn Chinese internet pop culture, Tibetan Buddhism == 密宗 == having sex with your master.
- volgo 9y agoWouldn't be surprised if it's scandal filled like the Catholic church. When you combine mysticism and people in position of absolute spiritual leadership and people who willingly believe it, you get some interesting relationships...
- tombh 9y agoIt very much is scandal-filled. Just take the recent coming to light of Sogyal Rinpoche's abuses of power: https://www.lionsroar.com/letter-to-sogyal-rinpoche-from-current-and-ex-rigpa-members-details-abuse-allegations/ https://www.lionsroar.com/letter-to-sogyal-rinpoche-from-cur... Not to mention the extraordinary mess that was Chögyam Trungpa.
- thanatropism 9y agoI enjoyed reading Lions' Roar until Trump won the election.
- yorwba 9y agoMy dictionary translates 密宗 as Tantric Buddhism, which in the West is also associated with sexual rituals. (But as I understand, those are not actually as common as some would prefer.)
- flyingcircus3 9y agoAnyone who lives near mountains long enough understands cabin fever. Is it any wonder the humans that live in the Himalayas experience cabin fever to a greater extent? Stoicism, or Buddhism, in my view, is simply the most efficient ideology for surviving in dangerous environments.
- pokemongoaway 9y agoYep can't get much cabin fever if you're actually training! :)
- qntty 9y agoCan you explain what you mean by cabin fever? Is it just boredom with being inside? And if so, how does it relate to being near the mountains?
- flyingcircus3 9y agoJust watch The Shining. All work and no play made Jack a dull boy. All play and no work is just as bad. Cabin fever is extreme introversion, to the point that you have cut off social contact with most people for an extended period of time. You effectively create an echo chamber of one. I have found it to be prevalent in areas of rugged natural beauty, such as mountainous regions. As an introvert, one can fill all of their free time exploring this paradise forever. But as you get better at seeking out more rugged and wild adventures, it almost serves as a positive feedback loop for your introversion. Thus, when you are in a stressful situation, the escape hatch is to get out in nature away from all those pesky humans. The "logical" conclusion is that you should just buy a cabin in the woods. Then you don't have to deal with any people, and your already in your comfort zone 24/7. The downside of all of that is you eventually become singularly focused on whatever your echo chamber has reinforced. And when you live among mountains, without focussing on all of the immediate danger that constantly surrounds you, that danger has extreme consequences.
- tombh 9y agoGlad to see this article getting some attention. My university training is in Religious Studies and it became clear pretty quickly that Buddhism suffers just as much as any other religion from the pathologies of global institutions of power. The one that always gets me, as it's so glaringly obvious, is that Buddhism is so audaciously and unapologetically male-dominated. It just seems embarrassing to me that on the one hand the teachings place so much emphasis on kindness to all living beings, yet none of the major lineages (until recently under Western influence) have female lineage holders - therefore those that are considered worthy enough to pass the teachings on to the next generation.
- gtirloni 9y agoReligion is not detached from the cultural aspects of where it exists. Such was/is the situation in Tibet, male-oriented. The Catholic Church says priests can only be male too. Women weren't given much freedom in society when these policies were defined. Western-adapted Buddhism lineages are much more open to women in general.
- b6 9y ago> Buddhism is so audaciously and unapologetically male-dominated From what I understand, the Buddha taught anyone who was interested without the slightest regard for gender, age, wealth, caste, or anything else -- 2500 years ago, in India. The monastic orders have very reasonable rules about how new monks or nuns get legitimacy by being approved by former monks or nuns, and that worked for, I think, over a thousand years. The problem is, for some reason, the female lineage suffered a break, and there was no contingency plan for restoration. But this is now occurring, at least in Theravada. Please don't paint it as if Buddhism is sexist. It is actually amazingly and remarkably non-sexist, back in a time when this was unheard of.
- paloaltokid 9y agoI think the parent is talking about the people in the "ism" of Buddhism, not the Buddha himself. I think it's similar in Christianity. We have no idea what Christ believed, but his followers sure have had some regressive attitudes towards women. Also, I'd agree with you that Buddhism itself is not sexist. But many of the practitioners are as sexist as everyone else. We shouldn't assume that just because someone practices a certain religion or spirituality that they are perfect.
- jackstraw14 9y agoBuddhism originated from a man sitting very still under a tree for a while. The core issue I think this article ignores, is a Western buddhist's need to identify their spiritual life with a specific geographic region across the globe. The goal of Buddhism is not to create an alliance to eventually rule the world and compete with evil Western forces, but to develop a way of life through personal enlightenment that allows a better world to emerge. These constructs in between us and enlightement only have life because of the energy we give to them. When the Dalai Lama talks about ways of finding personal peace, that's because it's the key point that you need before you can even know if your calling is to put your energy toward saving the Tibetan Buddhists.
- est 9y ago> Buddhism originated from a man sitting very still under a tree for a while. Buddhism originated from a wealthy prince, who enjoyed every aspect of upper-most human life, began to ponder why there miseries exists among humans.
- hliyan 9y agoAnd then he spent the next decade studying with every philosopher he could find, from theists, atheists, agnostics to materialists and then finally decided to figure things out on his own. Only during the last period before his enlightenment did he sit under a tree. His meditations would not have borne fruit without all the experiences that preceded it. Source: raised as a Buddhist.
- gerbilly 9y agoI second this. And let's not forget he pursued ascetic practices for six years and nearly starved to death[1], then he sat under a tree with a very particular goal in mind. [1] He would later characterise these practices as a false path.
- voice_of_reason 9y ago"The goal of Buddhism is not to create an alliance to eventually rule the world and compete with evil Western forces, but to develop a way of life through personal enlightenment that allows a better world to emerge." Suttas of Pali canon, the most ancient collection of Buddhist texts, are not dedicated to building a better world, though they contain advise on how to achieve happier and more peaceful existence. The goal of Buddha's teaching is an escape, a release from the endless cycle of rebirths, that is achieved through renunciation and non-clinging to the world and the concept of "self".
- zdw 9y agoThis is an interesting article because it exposes how little most Westerners know about non-Western thought and history. Most westerners can probably name dozens of western countries that rose and fell, but are unlikely to be able to name more than one or two of the Chinese dynasties. To provide a parallel to western culture, the view most westerners have of Buddhism is like if Christianity was portrayed purely as a well sanitized Joel Osteen prosperity gospel book, ignoring the entire history of violence in the old testament, the east/west catholic/orthodox split, upturn of the protestant reformation, and all the other "historical nasty bits". And with Buddhism being offered based on that pop-culture sanitized version, no wonder people are surprised when they dig deeper (as would be the case with any long-standing religion).
- gcb0 9y agothe funny thing is that this is the way japanese people see Christianity. in most japanese literatute and anime, cristians are always persecuted and pure of hearth and whatnot. oh and also not a male dominated religion at all, they even have women leading mass in some cases.
- digi_owl 9y agoSpeaking of Japanese, i ran into a claim some time back that the view of Bushido that we have now is one fabricated by a Japanese writer. That effectively transplanted European chivalry over long after the samurai had turned into career bureaucrats, and was called out on it by his contemporaries.
- kazinator 9y agoEuropean chivalry is also a fabrication due to writers.
- krapp 9y agoYou may be referring to the Tofugu article Bushido: Way of Total Bullshit[0], also discussed on HN two years ago[1]. I don't know why you've been downvoted - your comment brings up a good point, that no culture exists in a vacuum. Japan was being influenced by Western culture even during the Sakoku period when the entire country was locked down, albeit in a very controlled way. [0]https://www.tofugu.com/japan/bushido/ https://www.tofugu.com/japan/bushido/ [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11990721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11990721
- spicymaki 9y ago“Buddhist-based mindfulness practices are used to teach dissatisfied cogs in corporate systems to suck it up” Mindfulness practice like everything else is much more complicated. It is more than a management tool for complacency. There are times when you have to really just have to suck it up and times when you don’t. The overall goal is to stop torturing yourself about things you cannot control even if you are trapped with no options. The more you peer through delusion the less you need to suck it up. You might even start to see new possibilities where none were apparent.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThere is a big difference between an individual using it as a tool to cope with the difficulties of corporate life and a business using it to try and improve their bottom line.
- spicymaki 9y agoAgreed. However, there are people in organizations that are actually trying to improve the welfare of the employees (by introducing mindfulness programs) who work in soul-less corporations. In the company I work for, the mindfulness program is a bottom up initiative, but we do need to request for office space and budget to run it. To that end we do need to demonstrate why this might be in the interest of the company to fund it.
- Erlich_Bachman 9y agoHow do you differentiate between a business using it to "improve their bottom line" vs a business that is trying to provide their employees with some increased life quality? Is everything a business does evil just because they are a business?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIs everything a business does evil just because they are a business? If a business really wanted to deal with the excess stress in their organisation then they would start with the causes rather than trying to treat the symptoms.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Noos 9y agoI hate how westerners view Religion. "Oh, Buddhism is a thing of peace an enlightenment, as opposed to Christianity, which a vicious God condemns people to hell." Never mind the fact that Buddhism has multiple hells whether its Chinese or Japanese (possibly in the hundreds where the tortures to people are all described in glowing detail.) We're talking about the faith that gave us Sokishinbutsu, self-mummification while alive. Most folk Taoist and Buddhist beliefs would probably horrify people who tend to think New Age bowdlerization of eastern faiths is what really goes on.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoThe "facebook motivational quote" approach to spirituality is naive and romanticized as many other topics. You are vastly generalizing "how westerners view Religion" while, at the same time, cherry-picking and oversimplifying facts about Buddhism.
- qntty 9y agoSeeing as Christianity is by far the most popular religion in western countries, I don't think that's an accurate way to portray how "westerners" view religion.
- spicymaki 9y agoI find it funny how we can revere anything historical, the more I learn about history, the more I get disillusioned by people and institutions. Currently I feel there are two ways to meet that problem: With ignorance: "Oh, Buddhism is a thing of peace an enlightenment, as opposed to Christianity, which a vicious God condemns people to hell." or with acceptance: "There are people who just did things in contexts I might just never truly understand, some of it might be of value and some of it might not be of value. Is there anything I can learn from that?" Nothing is untainted. The best anyone can do is just separate the wheat from the chaff and move on.
- Jeaye 9y agoHitchens has a section on Buddhism in God is Not Great[1] wherein he discusses some violent atrocities in which Eastern Buddhism has taken part (Japanese Buddhism during WWII, for example), as well as the malevolent sex acts forced upon female practitioners. Worth a read. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Is_Not_Great https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Is_Not_Great
- justicezyx 9y agoGood to see such articles from western writers, as the same content from anyone with a Chinese heritage would be easily labeled government sponsored propaganda (most of it is, but that's not the reason to dispute their validity).
- zenbai 9y agoThe way this article talks of Tibetan Buddhism without comparing it or contrasting the teachings in it to the Theravada school of Buddhism practiced in Thailand and Myanmar is very disappointing. It is painting another wrong image of Buddhism as a whole. It is almost like if someone never knew what Christianity was about and after learning about a sect (church) with strange practices proceeds to write an article talking about it using the name of the church interchangeably with Christianity as a whole- to a group that knows nothing about Christianity. This is especially disappointing because the Theravada school is the school that emphasizes philosophy more than rituals (other than meditating) and is thus actually closer to the Western idea - even though it is not exactly the same, because again Westerners including the author of this article mostly know nothing about Buddhism. The result is this articlle paints a picture that Buddhism as a whole isn't really worth learning about. Yes the author says he is talking about 'Tibetan Buddhism' but he doesn't inform the reader of other schools of Buddhism that may be more interesting to learn about and that don't have an emphasis on tantric rituals and mysticism that he is complaining about.
- amriksohata 9y agoI've always wondered why abrahmaic religions (Christianity, Islam, Judaism) never question why they came after Eastern religions (Buddhism, Sikhism, Hinduism, Jainism)
- mythrwy 9y agoBuddhism is more recent than Judaism though and Sikhism is a lot more recent than Judaism, Christianity or Islam. Other than that, probably for the same reason Hindus don't question why Hinduism came after tribal shaman religions. Because in the believers mind maybe age doesn't matter and if it does, it's simply that people were foolish before religion X appeared.
- fsiefken 9y agoalso see the chapter on the dalai lama in 'stripping the gurus' by geoffrey d. falk for that other side of buddhism http://www.strippingthegurus.com/stgsamplechapters/dalai.html http://www.strippingthegurus.com/stgsamplechapters/dalai.htm...
- Zyst 9y agoThis article is, from what I can tell, genuinely well informed. Throughout the last few years I've read around 8 books on Buddhism, Meditation as a practice, and Zen Buddhism. And some of the differences that popped up were bizarre to me. Incredibly so in the Tibetan side of the literature. Even more so because I started with a very westernized view: The Zen Programmer. It took me over a year of some non-focused research to get a general idea of what was going on, and I feel this article actually summarizes, and ties it together pretty well. It is fairly simplistic of course, but you can't go too in depth in a handful of pages. I do feel they explained the situation more eloquently than I would have.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoI fail to see the conclusion of the article. Yes, Buddhism is much more than most people think. Yes, it's much different than most people think. Nevertheless, if someone gets interested in it, they should do some background research - and very often do. After that, when you deepen your knowledge, you naturally learn much more about the history and culture. In the case of Tibetan Buddhism, it's also a bloody and unpleasant story, with all kinds of degeneration, also of religious nature. It would be naive to expect that one religion would be magically devoid of these. For example, the famous yogi Drukpa Kunley sings about nuns who have sex, and then, ashamed, bury their newborn so that the walls of the monastery are filled with their corpses. Similar things were happening everywhere. Nevertheless, this has nothing to do with the essence of the religion, which in the case of Tibetan Buddhism is Dzogchen and Mahamudra, and which can be practiced without any monasteries, complex rituals, and other elements of Tibetan culture.
- TACIXAT 9y agoThis is very similar to what happens to Daoism. You have this rich esoteric tradition, a monastic and religious tradition, and people in the west labeling it a philosophy. Since I practice esoteric Daoist meditation I'm interested in other traditions. I've heard cool things about Tibetan Buddhist practices, but as the article said, it's really difficult to find the esoteric stuff in English.