3 ms·
I thought this was going to be another UBI article. Pleasantly surprised to see data on CCT and UCT programs, but somewhat frustrated that this basically is an
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I thought this was going to be another UBI article. Pleasantly surprised to see data on CCT and UCT programs, but somewhat frustrated that this basically is an article about what works in less developed countries. It doesn't appear to really have lessons for the US.
In the US, there is plenty of capital and infrastructure. Nonetheless, there are systemic problems that make poverty excessively hard to escape.
One of those is the general dearth of affordable housing* in the country. This is worse in some places than others, but it is a problem everywhere.
A second issue is that jobs are moving to big cities. More affordable small towns are being gutted. This means people can go where the jobs are and face a high cost of living, or go where things are cheap, yet still be unable to earn enough due to lack of earning opportunities.
I think we have a potential solution available: Remote work and online earning opportunities.
But one problem I see is that people in big cities are more likely to be clued in about such. Small towns and rural areas seem to be into Facebook and not terribly internet savvy.
I think if we can make a concerted effort to increase the supply of affordable housing and also work on finding ways to help Americans outside of big cities to get more savvy about using the internet to improve their bottom line, we don't need to continue to live in fear of some dystopian future where robots have all our jobs and UBI seems like our only hope.
* https://www.geekwire.com/2018/every-100-families-living-poverty-west-coast-no-30-affordable-homes/ https://www.geekwire.com/2018/every-100-families-living-pove...
- LMYahooTFY 9y agoThe title is quite awful buzzword bilge IMO. There are very obvious depravations suffered by impoverished people and those things all have literal price tags. This requires zero critical thought by anyone on HN. What conditional and unconditional handouts demonstrate is the in the same vein as other social problems we face: Do we offer people the freedom to choose a path and possibly take a bad one? Or do we block all paths but the one we're pretty sure is 'the correct one'?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI don't see why we can't do both. I would like to see some attempts to help people find a good path forward, and some attempts to just be generous and kind hearted. I met a man recently who told me he was once within a day of being homeless. His last day in housing, having not paid his mortgage in months due to a serious back injury, he ran into someone who knew him who offered to not only get his mortgage caught up, but keep paying it while he recuperated until he was able to return to work. One of the big differences between The Haves and The Have Nots is The Haves frequently had access to resources even when something had gone terribly wrong in their lives. The Have Nots either never had access to such resources or the resources ran out before their level of need was met. That man was able to rebuild his life. How many homeless people could rebuild their lives if someone was willing to gift them many months of rent? Most people on the street will simply never see that level of generosity. And then we blame them for failing, not recognizing that others are doing better not due to personal virtues per se, but simply good fortune or kindness done to them.
- Domenic_S 9y agoThe lion’s share of homeless are there because of untreated mental illness (25%) or addiction (another 33%, although I personally lump this in with mental illness). The kindest thing we as a society can do is de-stigmatize mental illness and addiction and treat it as any other medical issue. It’s easy for us, especially in the valley, to think it’s just a matter of writing a check — with enough cash airdrops or free apartments homeless would solve itself. Rather, the problem is complex and multifaceted and requires us to confront uncomfortable truths about ourselves and how we perceive mental illness and addiction.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoOf course, money alone does not fix this. I've had a class on homelessness and public policy. I spent 5.7 years homeless. I'm the author of the San Diego Homeless Survival Guide and something of a SME on homelessness. I'm trying to develop real solutions and I'm jazzed to learn that the state I moved to last fall is trying to establish statewide single payer healthcare. I just found that out this morning. I think single payer health care and adequate quantities of affordable housing would make a serious dent in the homeless problem. It won't fix it for everyone, but if it cut it by 50 percent, that would be awesome.
- manicdee 9y agoNote that all the schemes involving giving free housing to the homeless also come with counselling and psychiatric help. That the problem is multifaceted doesn’t mean that free money and housing won’t significantly reduce the symptoms. You doctore will still prescribe anti-inflammatories even if the problem is a broken bone. The anti-inflammatories aren’t there to fix the bone, they are there to ease the other symptoms to make recovery easier on everyone.
- sharemywin 9y agoIt's funny no one would hand a child money directly. But, some how magically at 18 years of age everyone instantly becomes an "adult" and well you are conferred all the rights and responsibilities of such. And well how's that working out for society?