3 ms·
Nobody ever wants to hear this, but I have to say it anyhow: read A Random Walk Down Wallstreet, give up, and invest in index funds.
by patio11 16y ago
Nobody ever wants to hear this, but I have to say it anyhow: read A Random Walk Down Wallstreet, give up, and invest in index funds.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoI'll see your Malkiel and raise you a Bernstein: http://www.amazon.com/Four-Pillars-Investing-Building-Portfolio/dp/0071747052/ref=dp_ob_title_bk http://www.amazon.com/Four-Pillars-Investing-Building-Portfo... The conclusion remains the same, however. Oh, how terribly dull it all is when compared to a nice game of craps.
- adrianscott 16y agomalkiel's work is based on flawed assumptions which lead to flawed conclusions -- i recommend reviewing those before spending time on his book.
- HockeyPlayer 16y agodetails and a link to the flaws please...
- Retailslave 16y agoI hope this is not "above me" I don't know as much as the average hacker would probably know about markets. I'm 20 and don't have THAT much knowledge. >>give up, and invest in index funds. Alright, Any book recommendations for that?
- patio11 16y agoIt is not a commentary on you, but rather on markets. On average, investor performance is market average minus expenses, and this holds regardless of investor sophistication.
- btilly 16y agoActually my understanding is that investor performance is usually better than the market average, but not by enough to meet expenses. Therefore after market returns usually lose. Markets are not perfect. But the imperfections are small. There was a study I saw a decade ago about whether any funds produced better results than chance. Due to the difficulty of modeling the possibilities, only mutual funds were considered. So people like George Soros did not get counted. In the end 2 names had performed high enough that, with 95% confidence, their performance was not by chance. Their names were Peter Lynch and Warren Buffett. Peter Lynch retired before he got to the 99% confidence. Interestingly both Peter Lynch and Warren Buffett recommend low cost index funds for average investors.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- adrianscott 16y ago"Due to the difficulty of modeling the possibilities" ;) love it... the research field is littered with bad assumptions or self-imposed constraints leading to bad conclusions... intellectual laziness, imho. If one doesn't want to become one of the best investors one should go home (i.e. not bother trying to trade, other than for entertainment). There are investors that are consistently among the best, such that it is not a matter of chance. (check out Bayes theorem; Buffett also gives a nice explanation of this)
- adrianscott 16y ago0% return over 5-10 years is the best you can do?... and even if you accept the conclusion, then of course there is the question of which index ;)