3 ms·
> If the sun absorbed radiation in this way, you would not be able to see it This isn't an explanation, it's just a restatement of the problem. The radiation p
by pdonis 9y ago
> If the sun absorbed radiation in this way, you would not be able to see it
This isn't an explanation, it's just a restatement of the problem. The radiation process itself is time reversible: the case where the sun emits and your eye absorbs, and the case solution where your eye emits and the sun absorbs, are both valid solutions of the equations describing the physical laws. Saying that the eye has to absorb radiation to see it just restates the fact that, in our actual universe, we do in fact see the sun by our eyes absorbing radiation--i.e., that that solution of the laws is the one we live in. It doesn't explain why that solution of the laws, and not the time reversed one, is the one that's actually realized.
- lisper 9y ago> This isn't an explanation Yes, I know. It wasn't meant to be an explanation, it was meant to be a very specific and narrow response to a very specific comment. The full explanation is in the article I linked to above, which is too long to reproduce in an HN comment.
- pdonis 9y ago> The full explanation is in the article I linked to I'll take a look. I see that it's several years old; if I have comments, should I post them there, or here?
- lisper 9y agoAs you wish. Comments on old articles get moderated, but they still get posted (I just have moderation turned on as an anti-spam measure). And a fair number of people are subscribed to my comment stream so you may get better feedback there.