6 ms·
Why I'm declining funding from Ruby Together
- swrobel 9y agoAs a recent victim of André's petty wrath, I completely agree with the sentiment
- netule 9y agoCare to elaborate a bit?
- swrobel 9y agoI apparently violated the Bundler CoC by disagreeing with their implementation of --jobs <n> that actually runs n - 1 jobs. When I questioned what I had actually violated, he accused me of making a joke about racism and blocked me. https://twitter.com/swrobel/status/984894874330656768 https://twitter.com/swrobel/status/984894874330656768
- sergiotapia 9y ago"codes of conduct" are a net negative and a blight on open source repos. If you maintain a repo, please don't fall to that scam. Not surprised he behaved that way.
- swrobel 9y agoI would've disagreed with you a few months back, but now seeing how a CoC can be pulled out as a catch-all to silence anyone who disagrees with you, I'm firmly in your camp.
- burntsushi 9y agoI don't use a CoC on any of my projects, but I would have reacted similarly to your comments. My issue tracker isn't your personal place to vent unconstructive frustration. Reframing this is as simply shutting down disagreement (which happens all the time in my issue trackers quite peacefully) is just plain disingenuous.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoI'm trying hard to follow what is happening on that twitter thread. Can you put your joke here? I don't see any jokes or mention of race anywhere on your Twitter.
- swrobel 9y agoYeah, sorry, I will try to make a long story short. For years I've had Bundler set to just run jobs equal to the number of cores on my system. However, I noticed it was running one less so I assumed I was doing something wrong. After hours of banging my head against the wall, I finally found that it Bundler subtracts 1 from the number of jobs you pass to it, but this behavior has been removed from master (for eventual 2.x branch). A bit irate, I engaged in the following exchange w/ Andre, in which he accused me of violating their CoC for posting a bit of a kneejerk comment, which I apologized for, but questioned what I possibly could've violated in the CoC, in the process making a wisecrack about the ridiculous term in it about "making casual references to slavery or indentured servitude." Anyway, if you really want to dig in, here's the github thread: https://github.com/bundler/bundler/pull/5808#issuecomment-381027767 https://github.com/bundler/bundler/pull/5808#issuecomment-38... In the end, he banned me (it says 24 hrs in his comment, but it seems permanent) which has now prevented me from submitting a PR to document the very "feature" that threw me into this rage to begin with. Way to run an OSS project!
- keithnz 9y agoI think his response, except for the ban, was appropriate
- threatofrain 9y agoWas part of his response that he doesn't need the money of someone who makes racial jokes? Good riddance? That's a pretty strong statement to make over Twitter, esp. since if you read through the whole thing, that's someone trying to forcefully make a suggestion about racial insensitivity, which is at best journalistic twisting. What irks me about such responses is that it's not your prerogative to retract anything you say about anyone over the internet. It might not even be your prerogative to correct any of your statements.
- danso 9y agoYou weren't accused of "making a joke about racism". He posted the part of the CoC [0] that he believed you to have violated. He then gave you a 24-hour-block because your remark "counts as doubling down" on what he originally accused you of. I guess he didn't appreciate you implying that the CoC is a bunch of facile garbage. [0] https://github.com/bundler/bundler/pull/5808#issuecomment-381254777 https://github.com/bundler/bundler/pull/5808#issuecomment-38...
- mlevental 9y agoGod damn you people are sensitive. I see a guy (swrobel) venting about a bad API and using words like "infuriating", "REASONS", and several exclamation marks. he was confused about where he was skirting code of conduct because what he'd done was express disapproval of a design decision. he quotes the coc and then alludes to clauses that he believes would actually merit a warning - "slavery" and "indentured servitude" is language in the coc. note this isn't false dichotomy because the extreme end of the spectrum he's distinguished his comments from are explicitly forbidden by the coc. yes he used a smiley. God forbid. he also apologized and but somehow that's not being taken in into account by either you or indirect. then indirect responds with a positive prescription of the coc rather than a negative proscription (ie if it were a real contract it would be completely immaterial to the case since the rules cited don't forbid things only encourage). finally supposing we do take the rules cited by indirect as negative ("only this kind of language and behavior is allowed") there's not a shred of constructive feedback in indirect's initial response other than "don't do this" which just begs the question of whether he did anything to begin with. swrobel didn't show antipathy for anyone (he vented frustration about code). he didn't use exclusive language (he didn't say anything about any people at all), and he wasn't dismissive of any viewpoints because none were expressed by anyone. so what really happened? indirect felt he was being criticized and used his small bit of power to silence the critic under the auspices of being just. lol.
- swrobel 9y agothank you for stating this far more eloquently than I was able to
- 9y ago
- golemiprague 9y agoHe should have known that if the main point of the agenda is to "increase diversity" then something is rotten in the core of it.
- Libturd 9y agololruby
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gabeh 9y agoI'm genuinely curious if my perception that the Ruby community has more drama than other communities is actually true.
- deedubaya 9y agoA community without drama is probably a low movement community. It all boils down to the type of drama that is important. Drama over technical choices is probably a good healthy conversation to have in a community. Drama of someone potentially abusing power given to them by the community is bad. I can't recall any other instances of this type of drama in the ruby community, but maybe someone else can remember?
- lokopodium 9y agoMost of this drama is stirred up by just two people.
- deedubaya 9y agoSomething is obviously broken for a prominent contributor to the ruby community to decline funding from Ruby Together, regardless of the cause or reasoning. So sad to see this drama arise in the ruby community, but sometimes there are no other option. I commend those who tried to resolve the issues quietly having the resolve to stand up for what they believe is right, even if it rocks the boat.
- ksec 9y agoWhy is it always Ruby? Why does the Ruby Community in general get much more drama then anywhere else. I am convinced a certain Programming languages and stack as well as Open Sources License attract certain type of people. And these people who are attracted to Ruby seems to cause more drama then the norm.
- lokopodium 9y agoCoraline Ada Ehmke.
- isaac32767a 9y agoRight, because prominent people always have good reasons for what they do and never behave badly.
- rhapsodic 9y agoHere's another example of drama generated by André Arko: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15084792 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15084792
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ksec 9y ago$20,000 USD every month? Why does it take so much to run RubyGems? I am guessing these cost are not just hardware cost?
- nkantar 9y agoSidestepping the questionable wording (part of the OP's point is that RubyGems is _not_ funded by Ruby Together), bandwidth and human time are probably far more significant portions of operational cost than hardware.
- spotman 9y agoSounds like a good time for a fork of bundler.
- isaac32767a 9y ago"Platonic ideal"? Do you even know what that term means? I think you mean "goals".
- KindOne 9y agoPage is 404'ing. Mirror: http://archive.is/gOm3s http://archive.is/gOm3s https://web.archive.org/web/20180420220028/https://samphippen.com/why-im-declining-funding-from-ruby-together/ https://web.archive.org/web/20180420220028/https://samphippe...