6 ms·
> You can remember the past and not the future because whatever you remember is your past. Conveniently enough, this direction of time coincides with the one w
by kgwgk 9y ago
> You can remember the past and not the future because whatever you remember is your past.
Conveniently enough, this direction of time coincides with the one where the fusion of hydrogen atoms into helium in the Sun emits radiation (rather than the alternative direction where the Sun absorbs from the space exactly the radiation required to fission helium atoms to obtain hydrogen), the one where separated gases mix (rather than the alternative direction where mixed gases separate spontaneusly), coffee gets cold (rather than hot), etc.
- lisper 9y agoIt's not "convenient", it's necessary. If the sun absorbed radiation in this way, you would not be able to see it. You can only receive information from photons that you absorb (and hence are emitted by something else), not from ones that you emit and are absorbed by something else. That's why you can never see a black hole.
- kgwgk 9y agoIf the arrow of time is the one it is by classical necessity, what does introducing entanglement and quantum metaphysics add to the discussion?
- lisper 9y agoBecause you have to explain how the classical arrow of time emerges from the time-reversible unitary transformations of quantum mechanics.
- kgwgk 9y agoWouldn't your explanation ("if sun absorbed radiation in this way, you would not be able to see it") work exactly the same to explain how the classical arrow of time emerges from the time-reversible laws of classical physics? (Edit: fusion/fission are atomic processes not properly accounted for in classical mechanics but I hope you understand what I mean. If there is a classical arrow of time there is no need to explain it again from a quantum point of view.)
- lisper 9y agoI don't think so, but I guess it's possible. I haven't really thought it through. All kinds of weird shit happens in a counterfactual world where the second law of thermodynamics is violated. It kind of reminds me of the Feynman sprinkler problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feynman_sprinkler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feynman_sprinkler My guess is that if you really could carry this argument through without reference to the asymmetry of entanglement that it would be a major breakthrough in the philosophy of science.
- pdonis 9y ago> I don't think so, but I guess it's possible. The classical laws are time reversible, so the time reverse of a solution that describes, for example, two gases mixing together, is also a solution (and would describe the two gases separating themselves spontaneously). The usual classical argument for why we don't observe the time reversed solutions is that they would require such precise initial conditions that in practice they never happen.
- Filligree 9y agoBut if our eyes regularly emitted photons in this manner, surely evolution would find a way to detect the event?
- lisper 9y agoYou can detect the emission of the photon (by, for example, measuring the reaction force created by the fact that the emitted photon has momentum). What you cannot do is receive any information about whatever ultimately absorbs that photon.
- Filligree 9y agoThe fact that a photon was emitted is, itself, information. It means there's a star out there to absorb it. Of course stars aren't the only things that would absorb photons in this manner, but they'd absorb a lot more than other objects, and you could probably do something with the spectrum as well.
- lisper 9y ago> It means there's a star out there to absorb it. No, it doesn't. If it did, then flashlights would behave differently depending on what you were pointing them at.
- Filligree 9y agoWe're talking about hypothetical time-reversed light, not the usual kind.
- lisper 9y agoWhat does it mean for TR-light to be emitted and absorbed then? Does TR-light carry positive or negative energy? Because if it carries negative energy, and it is absorbed before it is emitted, then TR-light behaves exactly the same as regular light. You've just swapped the meaning of "emitted" and "absorbed".
- pdonis 9y ago> If the sun absorbed radiation in this way, you would not be able to see it This isn't an explanation, it's just a restatement of the problem. The radiation process itself is time reversible: the case where the sun emits and your eye absorbs, and the case solution where your eye emits and the sun absorbs, are both valid solutions of the equations describing the physical laws. Saying that the eye has to absorb radiation to see it just restates the fact that, in our actual universe, we do in fact see the sun by our eyes absorbing radiation--i.e., that that solution of the laws is the one we live in. It doesn't explain why that solution of the laws, and not the time reversed one, is the one that's actually realized.
- lisper 9y ago> This isn't an explanation Yes, I know. It wasn't meant to be an explanation, it was meant to be a very specific and narrow response to a very specific comment. The full explanation is in the article I linked to above, which is too long to reproduce in an HN comment.
- pdonis 9y ago> The full explanation is in the article I linked to I'll take a look. I see that it's several years old; if I have comments, should I post them there, or here?
- lisper 9y agoAs you wish. Comments on old articles get moderated, but they still get posted (I just have moderation turned on as an anti-spam measure). And a fair number of people are subscribed to my comment stream so you may get better feedback there.
- pdonis 9y ago(Addition to my other post made just now) I think the point is also valid that has been raised by others in this subthread, that the argument about emission vs. absorption of radiation is also valid classically, so it doesn't explain why you need to bring in quantum entanglement for an explanation.
- lisper 9y agoWell, yeah, it does. The reason you need to bring QM into it is because you can't explain the arrow of time classically.
- pdonis 9y ago> you can't explain the arrow of time classically. What you mean is that you don't like the classical explanation (as you said in your other response to me upthread). That's not the same as "can't".
- raattgift 9y agoI don't see why you need QM for that. In the classical GR picture, at a BH (black hole) event horizon there are no timelike worldlines that leave the BH; inside the horizon there are no lightlike ones that leave the BH either. All worldlines are thus directionally constrained and any object can only march further inwards towards the gravitational singularity. This is a feature of a BH metric. It isn't that much of a stretch to have a classical BB (big bang) metric constrain all worldlines to march outwards from the gravitational singularity. Shazam: the arrow of time is then set by global geometry. QM isn't even needed for half of the BH information loss problem to manifest itself: if you drop a spherical shell of mass M into a Schwarzschild BH or two spherical shells each of mass M/2 into a Schwarzschild BH, at late times who can know this? In the classical case, no BH evaporation means no information lost (it's just locked up somewhere else); but if we allow complete evaporation then we have to have stored that information somewhere. Non-evaporating growing black hole has a clear arrow-of-time due to global asymmetry; evaporating black hole formed by collapse should in principle be fully time-reversible. QM just sharpens the picture by providing a mechanism for evaporation, bringing in unitarity and other features, and letting us drop in collections of particles into arbitrary black holes such that a no-hair black hole can hide an awful lot of quantum numbers inside. It also gives us hope for a structure that replaces the gravitational singularity. Likewise in the BB case, we'd like to avoid marching back to a gravitational singularity so we can bring in a similar QM structure to replace it (although you can do that with "throat" models fully classically, see slide 17 at https://www.slideshare.net/seanmcarroll/what-we-dont-know-about-the-beginning-of-the-universe https://www.slideshare.net/seanmcarroll/what-we-dont-know-ab... and refs therein). Similarly, we expect there to be an enormous number of quantum numbers in the hot dense phase of the universe, and unitarity, and so forth. In these cases the thermodynamic arrow of time is the set of transformations that leave the equilibrium state unchanged. We can do that in the classical regime as well as the quantum one, given some additional symmetries (including but likely not limited to translation invariance and Gallilean boost invariance) and keeping well away from the ultrarelativistic limit. With a small positive cosmological constant, much of the early universe gas can be constrained to remain at essentially the same comoving coordinates as its daughter products that collapse into structures like galaxies, although things get ugly in the infinite temperature limit. Statements arguing that the arrow of time is driven by increasing quantum correlations are great slogans, certainly enough to help focus theorists' attention, but I think they do not capture a required feature of an expanding FLRW universe's early epochs.
- fizx 9y agoDon't worry! Around e^(10^120) years from now, if the unitarity of the global wavefunction holds (it might not vis-a-vis inflation and the eventual unification of GR and QM), we'll hit the Poincare recurrence of the universe and those things will happen!