14 ms·
The illusion of time
- creaghpatr 9y agoThe past is a faulty memory and the future is an illusion of ego.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoSo if I had a good memory, there would be no past? I don't buy it. Or, all memory is faulty, and that's all we've got of the past? In that sense, this might be true.
- Certhas 9y agoTime is an illusion, but by the same token so are space and coffee. So maybe that's not a useful way to use the word "illusion"....
- joslin01 9y agoNo not by the same token. Coffee is a physical manifestation. Time is a perspective or measurement.
- Certhas 9y agoI'd like to see you try to define these terms.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- joslin01 9y agoCoffee is sitting there as a bunch of molecules. Can you point at time as a bunch of molecules sitting there? If not, it's not by the same token.
- Certhas 9y agoI take your bunch of molecules ("physical manifestation") and squash them into a black hole. Now they have been turned into an aspect of the structure of space and time ("a measurement or perspective"). So no, space and time are not "measurements/perspectives" that are fundamentally distinct from "a bunch of molecules".
- joslin01 9y agoOk so you change the situation drastically by squashing them into a black hole, something nobody really understands, and tell me coffee and time are interchangeable. Right. Also I never said space was measurement/perspective, I said time was. You believe what you want to believe, but maybe stick to a single scenario in the future. I'll say it again, a cup of coffee just sitting there is distinct from time.
- ben_w 9y agoWhile I agree that was a poor example for much the same reasons, I think I have a much better comparison: Duration is as much a measurement/perspective as displacement, this is an observation which led to Special Relatively. If time can be called an illusion, so can position.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoIf duration is a simple displacement between two points in another direction of space then you are right, the two are equivalent: you have then also accepted that time does not flow and lacks intrinsic direction for it is precisely these properties that separates "time" from "space". Time flows and is irreversible, this is what makes it special, and it is the denying that the flow and irreversibility are inherent properties of time that constitutes "dispelling the illusion". In other words, saying that "time is an illusion" is saying "time is just like space".
- ben_w 9y ago
- jackstraw14 9y agoTime as a measurement is an abstraction.
- TuringTest 9y agoThe molecules in the coffee are constantly changing and rearranging themselves. That change is a physical manifestation itself. So time is a perspective in the same way that thinking of a cup of coffee as an object is a perspective. Both exist as something that can be observed in reality, and you're the one that clumps several billions of observed phenomena (changing molecules) into something observed (either a cup, or a second, depending on what you fixate upon).
- Certhas 9y agoNicely said.
- 0xFFFE 9y agoPlease don't say coffee is an illusion, I basically run on coffee. :)
- agumonkey 9y agoit's one cheap and common enough illusion
- jerf 9y agoFortunately, you are an illusion too, so it all works out. I, too, think the word "illusion" is grotesquely overused in this area. It's a sophomoric equivocation between the denotation of illusion as being something that isn't there in the sense that it appears to be and the connotation of illusion as something that doesn't exist, and then getting high and going "whoooaaaaa" as you try to straddle the two things. Time clearly exists. Less clearly, but very well established, is that physics has already told us that our common sense ideas about time are already special cases, so we already know it isn't what we think it is. Equally well established is that we're not done understanding time yet. So the idea that time may not be what we thought it was is not so much "whooooaaa" as "duuuuhhhhh". Personally I find thinking about it and learning about it to be plenty interesting enough without the "illusion" word getting stuck in there, and indeed, if anything, spraying the word "illusion" around like rockets in a Quake deathmatch just makes it harder to understand what is being said.
- ende 9y agoIt’s not the coffee that is the illusion, it is the sense that you are running.
- liberte82 9y agoWhen taking hallucinogens and in a few cases without, I've had instances where my ideas and concepts of time have begun breaking down. It's a very weird feeling, when you begin becoming uncertain about how or if time works. And impossible to "grasp" when you're not experiencing it and are back in a "normal" mindset.
- aklemm 9y agoSimilarly I recall being under the influence and suddenly I was experiencing more than one timeline and those timelines started to collide like a snake swallowing it's tail. Fun stuff.
- empath75 9y agoIf someone were to ask me how long an LSD trip lasts, I would always say: "Exactly one eternity".
- ybrah 9y agoYeah bro time is just an illusion bro
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sctb 9y agoCould you please start posting civilly and substantively like we've already asked? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- k__ 9y agoReminds me of "The Jaunt"
- dstroot 9y agoBased on relativity photons do not experience time. They “hit” something the instant they are created - even if we perceive them to have existed for billions of (light) years.
- liberte82 9y agoFrom the perspective of a photon, everything in the universe is happening here and now.
- doubledad222 9y agoIs this REALLY accepted as true? Photons are fast, but they're not instantaneous. They still take millions of years to travel between galaxies. For something to be truely timeless, I'd expect it to be able to teleport. Is this incorrect?
- inteleng 9y agoIn the frame of reference of the photon, the moment it is created and the moment it is destroyed are one and the same.
- cuspycode 9y agoAssume a really fast rocket is traveling from galaxy A to galaxy B. Due to relativistic length contraction, the distance between the galaxies is less as seen by the rocket than it is for a stationary observer in either galaxy. So the travel time from the perspective of the rocket (the "proper time" of the rocket) is less than the travel time measured by a stationary observer. And when you work out the math, the rocket's proper time approaches zero in the limit as the speed of the rocket approaches light speed.
- whatshisface 9y agoThe speed of light is constant, which means that there is no reference frame where a photon is stationary. If you are "riding along" with a train it appears stationary so we take that as being the reference frame of the train. By the above it's clear that there is no reference frame of a photon I.E. there are no true statements about what it's "like" for photons.
- choxi 9y ago> The malleability of space and time mean that two events occurring far apart might even happen in one order when viewed by one observer, and in the opposite order when viewed by another. Why doesn't this break the rules of causality? I found this answer on Quora (https://www.quora.com/Is-chronological-order-of-events-preserved-for-different-observers https://www.quora.com/Is-chronological-order-of-events-prese...) but I don't understand it.
- simonh 9y agoIt doesn't break the rules of causality because this can only occur for non-causally connected events. In other words, we only see this for independently occurring events, which both happen before a light signal could have travelled from the location of one event to the other.
- jpindar 9y agoHowever, you can hear (which is a form of observation) it for events that are not independent. If a rifle is fired toward you (hopefully you are safe behind a berm) you hear the bullet impact first, then you hear the shot because the bullet travels faster than sound.
- simonh 9y agoBut not faster than light, so in theory you could ‘see’ (optically detect) the gun firing and the sound wave travelling through the air before it reached you. The information about what is happening is theoretically available and could be collected given a well designed experiment. What you’re describing is just an illusion created by our limited aural perception.
- whb07 9y agoIt doesn’t break the rules of causality because they arent even related. Let’s say I poke a balloon with a needle, the poking event causes the balloon to pop. The pop will never ever occur without me first poking it, irrespective of any number of viewers across all possible distances. Now for the distortions in time perception, it does matter as to who the viewer is. Everyday you wake up you experience energy that’s being radiated from the Sun that’s roughly 8 minutes away (at the speed of light). And yet, there’s cosmic events which have released energy that have happened millions and millions of years ago which have yet to reach us because we are so far away. So from our perspective the Sunlight from today is an older event than the truly much older supernova explosion that has yet to reach our planet. That which when we finally detect it, it will be a “new” event which again is much older than our Sun.
- joslin01 9y agoHappy to see my passing thought "How can time be real?" is actually being given serious academic study. If you take reality to be right here, right now (what else could it be?), time cannot exist, it just helps us map change.
- empath75 9y agoIt's been given serious scientific study for decades and there have been multiple pop-science treatments of it even. And even well before that: For what is time? Who can easily and briefly explain it? Who even in thought can comprehend it, even to the pronouncing of a word concerning it? But what in speaking do we refer to more familiarly and knowingly than time? And certainly we understand when we speak of it; we understand also when we hear it spoken of by another. What, then, is time? If no one ask of me, I know; if I wish to explain to him who asks, I know not. Yet I say with confidence, that I know that if nothing passed away, there would not be past time; and if nothing were coming, there would not be future time; and if nothing were, there would not be present time. Those two times, therefore, past and future, how are they, when even the past now is not; and the future is not as yet? But should the present be always present, and should it not pass into time past, time truly it could not be, but eternity. If, then, time present — if it be time — only comes into existence because it passes into time past, how do we say that even this is, whose cause of being is that it shall not be — namely, so that we cannot truly say that time is, unless because it tends not to be? —Augustine of Hippo, Confessiones lib xi, cap xiv, sec 17 (ca. 400 CE)
- codeulike 9y agoSo how does change happen?
- joslin01 9y agoOne reaction at a time in a chain of reactions. If you lift your arm up, are you asking me how did that happen? Muscles fired to go from point A to point B. I'm confused by your question to be honest; are you telling me change occurs because of time? Or trying to tell me change depends on time? Then yes, but change is just a perspective as well. There's only ever going to be right here, right now.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dustfinger 9y ago> He posits that reality is just a complex network of events onto which we project sequences of past, present and future. I wonder if the "we project" part is the author's choice of words or Carlo Rovelli’s. It is not explained and therefore has not definitive meaning.
- chaoticmass 9y agoTime is an illusion. Lunchtime, doubly so.
- mattkevan 9y agoVery deep. You should send that in to the "Reader's Digest". They've got a page for people like you.
- fzzzy 9y agoIt’s a quote from Douglas Adams.
- deadmetheny 9y agoThat is also a quote from Douglas Adams. It's literally the following line from the original quote.
- Senderman 9y agoHe was riffing - the 3rd line is "It’s a quote from Douglas Adams." At least, as it appeared in the comments on HN.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- IloveHN84 9y agoThat's why I need a 48h long day? 24h seem too few for me
- codeulike 9y agoThe End of Time by Julian Barbour said something similar. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_End_of_Time_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_End_of_Time_(book) Its interesting, the but the picture of reality that it conjures up is ultimately a bit of a stretch, in my view. Kinda creating a bunch of new problems just to try and get rid of the time problem. If it was a code refactoring, it would strike you as a questionable one.
- bobthechef 9y agoIf time did not exist in some fashion, then change would be impossible. Remove time and everything is simultaneous or eternal. What we say was or will be exists along with all we say presently is. Naturally, this leads to a contradiction. Imagine something moving along a trajectory that was at position p1, is at position p2, and will be at position p3 is now in all three positions. Add another object on an intersecting trajectory. A collision occurs when two objects are at the same position at the same time. Without time, these objects are both colliding and not colliding.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoDraw two crossing lines: the lines are mostly not touching except at the point they cross, so they are both touching and not touching depending on where you look. Is this a contradiction?
- bobthechef 9y agoAt the POINT of intersection. Those objects are both at the point of collision and not at the point of collision.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoThe same is true for the crossing lines: they are both at the point of crossing and at all the other points along their length.
- dmfdmf 9y agoTime is an illusion, freewill is an illusion, etc. are all attacks on and denials of consciousness. The fact is that consciousness exists and has identity. In the past consciousness was treated as supernatural but the "modern" attempts to deny it are no less irrational.
- 21 9y agoPhysics hasn't still decided if our universe is completely deterministic or no, if all the apparent quantum randomness was not already determined (think about a seeded random number generator). You are trivializing a very deep question: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdeterminism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdeterminism
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoOK, but "the universe is not completely determined because of quantum randomness" != "I have free will", or even "consciousness is real".
- Senderman 9y agoPretty sure you're not both talking about the same thing.
- lisper 9y agoI made basically the same argument four years ago: http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar... It's actually pretty obvious once you understand how entanglement and measurement are related, i.e. the are the same physical phenomenon.
- kgwgk 9y ago> You can remember the past and not the future because whatever you remember is your past. Conveniently enough, this direction of time coincides with the one where the fusion of hydrogen atoms into helium in the Sun emits radiation (rather than the alternative direction where the Sun absorbs from the space exactly the radiation required to fission helium atoms to obtain hydrogen), the one where separated gases mix (rather than the alternative direction where mixed gases separate spontaneusly), coffee gets cold (rather than hot), etc.
- lisper 9y agoIt's not "convenient", it's necessary. If the sun absorbed radiation in this way, you would not be able to see it. You can only receive information from photons that you absorb (and hence are emitted by something else), not from ones that you emit and are absorbed by something else. That's why you can never see a black hole.
- kgwgk 9y agoIf the arrow of time is the one it is by classical necessity, what does introducing entanglement and quantum metaphysics add to the discussion?
- lisper 9y agoBecause you have to explain how the classical arrow of time emerges from the time-reversible unitary transformations of quantum mechanics.
- axilmar 9y agoIt may be that time does not exist, but the universe certainly does have states, which are deployed simultaneously (hence time is an illusion). But this means the universe is 100% deterministic.
- wuliwong 9y agoThe author's physics might be real science but this seems like semantics to me. In addition, the idea that "time is an illusion" is equal parts physics and psychology. While the author maybe a professional physicist, I doubt they are much more than an armchair psychologist.
- kirse 9y agoI always saw time as a way of applying numerical labels to a state of the universe. In my view, the universe only ever exists in one state, albeit constantly changing at the "speed" of light. It is our biological capability to remember past states and envision future states that project this notion of time into everything. Time is lodged into almost all of physics because the only way we can do something useful (not being God and not knowing the absolute equations sans-units) is to compare present values to previous-present values. That division sign wedged into every relative unit of measure - kg, sec, meter, etc - is basically a way of saying "as compared to". Present as-compared-to the-previous-present. What-is-now ÷ the-remembered-now. Universe-at-Planck-Tick #145 ÷ Universe-at-Planck-Tick #144 All of the universal constants come down to comparing a present state to a previous-present state and noticing that the delta between them is a consistent value. I don't think this is really news to many, but it helped to make physics and the some of the exotic math behind it make more sense to me.
- tradedash 9y agoYou might like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellular_automaton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellular_automaton I think about time in a similar manner. The delta between point A and point B is the mutation state and point A is the initial state that was mutated into B.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoYou might want to read some of Julian Barbour's writing, in particular his "The End of Time: The Next Revolution in Physics" where he tries to explain a theory of timelessness with an apparent arrow of time. Here is a rather long interview I found (and only skimmed to confirm its mostly relevant): https://www.edge.org/conversation/the-end-of-time https://www.edge.org/conversation/the-end-of-time
- pdonis 9y ago> In my view, the universe only ever exists in one state > All of the universal constants come down to comparing a present state to a previous-present state The problem with this as you state it is that it is not relativistically invariant; there is no absolute "present" for the universe as a whole. However, a more restricted version of this, where the notion of "present" is not applied to the whole universe but only to a single observer's worldline, works fine.
- pcurve 9y agoI wish all mobile sites were as beautifully designed and spaced as this one.
- hi41 9y agoThere was a post on the 13.7 blog at NPR. It said that it is ok incorrect to think of time as an illusion or an emergent property and that scientists are doing a disservice by doing so. Time is real it said. I looked but couldn't find that article.
- doctoboggan 9y agoI think this is a fascinating subject. Time is something we all experience and intuitively feel exists, yet is remains so elusive to actually nail down and study. The Youtube channel PBS Spacetime did some of the best explorations of ideas in this area that I've heard: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GguAN1_JouQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GguAN1_JouQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHRqibyNMpw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHRqibyNMpw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5l1KxgHH2Ek https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5l1KxgHH2Ek
- qwerty456127 9y agoI have always been perceiving time just this way. What the article describes seems just obvious while fitting in the common model of time an schedules is rather hard and always very stressing for me.
- jpmoyn 9y agoWhile I can understand the basic concepts behind theories like this, I much prefer to live in my very human bubble of ignorance. I just don't feel like dealing with the existential dread.
- emodendroket 9y agoThis is strangely reminiscent of the part of Saint Augustine's Confessions I found the most trying to finish.
- carapace 9y agoWhat is the duration of "now"?
- Senderman 9y agoSeems infinite so far.
- 8bitsrule 9y ago"When his lifelong friend Besso died. Einstein wrote a letter to Besso's family, saying that although Besso had preceded him in death it was of no consequence, '...for us physicists believe the separation between past, present, and future is only an illusion, although a convincing one.' " http://everythingforever.com/einstein.htm http://everythingforever.com/einstein.htm
- karmakaze 9y agoA good analogy I like to use is 'time legs'. Imagine if you were a leaf falling from a tree, being blown about the ground and air. You would be in 3-space but only experiencing it as a passenger. A leaf as no legs. We lack 'time legs' and if we had them, we would realize that time isn't a special thing.