6 ms·
The hood is exactly the wrong place. Blocks, radiators, even oil pans would be far better. But imho the real market for these will be in low-power environment
by sandworm101 9y ago
The hood is exactly the wrong place. Blocks, radiators, even oil pans would be far better.
But imho the real market for these will be in low-power environments. Or defense: submarines have near-unlimited heatsink potential and lots of <100 heat sources.
- agumonkey 9y agoI know I was just pitching for a customer level add-on and not a factory level one. There's also the exhaust pipe which has high temp gas in. I can't find it again sadly but I found a japanese lab who made thermoelectric pipes with not too poor efficiency (aimed at building water pipes but probably workable for vehicles).
- sandworm101 9y agoThe problem with extracting heat from exhaust pipes has never been conversion efficiency but weight. To harvest a useful amount of heat from a combustion engine requires lots of pipe, (surface area) which impacts engine performance. It might work in a fixed power station where weight/size isn't an issue, but you aren't going to see them on a motorcycle exhaust.
- agumonkey 9y agohaving a heavier material around the pipe would impact performance ? Im surprised but Im not an engineer so Im learning.
- jsjohnst 9y agoNo, having a long pipe impacts performance as it puts back pressure on the engine.
- agumonkey 9y agoSome resistance like concept for fluids ?
- jerf 9y agoA manifestation of drag: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics) Stuff doesn't move through pipes for free. Given that we'd probably have to put tons of turns into this pipe, too, those are even more expensive. Contrary to probably-locally-popular opinion, cars have been engineered to within an inch of their lives, and the quest for better fuel economy has been a huge focus of the industry for decades, pretty much countered only by "customer safety" and "what will the customers pay for". If there was an efficient way to recover the heat, it would probably already be getting used, as evidenced by all the other mechanisms already in a car if you look.
- agumonkey 9y agoI do get all this, but you know very well that "what customers would pay for" is very much contextual and thus "energy economy" is not only a fixed law. I'm sure zero percent of the market cared about pollution or high efficiency in the 90s and today it's a sizeable chunk (Im guessing but I'd bet a dollar it's at least a single digit %). Today having something in that scavenge heat at some cost might be a plausible marketing argument. Back to physics, so pipe are like wires for electrons, some energy will be wasted. But aren't turbo equipped engines using part of the flow to improve the engine fuel quality ? I should search if people try to expand on that. I know Turbos had some issues but I never read in details and this was long ago.
- jsjohnst 9y ago> But aren't turbo equipped engines using part of the flow to improve the engine fuel quality No, turbo is used to force more air into the intake side of the engine. It uses exhaust gas pressure to spin a turbine which is used to compress more air into the cylinder between cycles. That, combined with more fuel to maintain proper balance, gives you increased combustion, thus more power.
- arethuza 9y agoThat made me wonder if anyone had tried tracking submarines based on the heat they leave behind - turns out the Soviets had a technique that integrated various sources including heat : https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a28724/submarine-sonar-soks/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a28724/...
- 3pt14159 9y agoI don't really think submarines are going to stay stealth from major powers for much longer. Underwater drones are too easy and once they lock on a sub they can follow it constantly.
- vinceguidry 9y agoThe ocean is a really, really, really big place. You don't even have to submerge in order to stay relatively hidden. We don't publish the exact coordinates of carrier groups because they're really hard to find when underway. You can fly a plane around for days looking for one and not find squat. No number of drones that we can realistically produce and operate can adequately blanket the ocean. The Pacific ocean is bigger than all of the Earth's landmasses combined. Imagine trying to find a ship-sized vehicle moving through an area the size of Wyoming by plane, that's about how hard it is to find a whole carrier group just moving on the surface of the water, with publicly available information. Without it, you're looking for a needle in a haystack the size of Wyoming.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoReally? Surface area of planet Earth: 500M km2. Horizon radius at a height of mount everest: 300km. Surface area visible: 282K km2. Number of drones needed to cover the area: 1773. Multiply it by 5 to 10 to be sure. Incredibly realistic.
- vinceguidry 9y agoWhy not make them fly higher so you can increase the horizon even farther? In fact, why not put them in orbit?