5 ms·
ICONOMI Proof of Solvency: Technical Overview
- sitepodmatt 9y agoIs this Deloitte USA or one of the franchises elsewhere? The China Hustles show how easy it is to corrupt these franchises elesewhere, e.g. PWC (China franchise) - although curly braces are rarely mentioned next to PWC name. https://www.netflix.com/title/80221646 https://www.netflix.com/title/80221646 I find it hard to believe Deloitte or the others have auditors with the necessary "blockchain" skills to properly audit these anyway, maybe they pointed them to a bootstrap3 web UI block explorer for <whatever ShitCoin> and said there you see! LMFAO https://www.iconomi.net/audit https://www.iconomi.net/audit - thats it? some HTML page, not even a Deloitte branded PDF? no Deloitee announcement on their website or any official channels? Come on even Tether trainwreck tries harder than this. Reality is the real/full audit includes disclaimers that much of the information has not been verified and taken on face value. The Deolitte or PWC audit stamp will be included as standard in ThemeForst/TemplateMonster lets-ICO scam templates just as much as the linkedin profile pics next.
- notahacker 9y agoI'm pretty sure the actual audit stamp isn't a piece of clipart and the Deloitte logo reproduced in an off-brand colour with what looks like a subtly different or inaccurately shrunk font (check the D, o and i as well as the horrible kerning)... And that Deloitte would be delighted to use the word "blockchain" in a press release if they'd actually conducted the audit. Impressed with what appears to be an unusually flagrant lie.
- cryptogeek 9y agoApparenlty it's Central European part of Deloitte? Going by the title of the auditor: Director CE Blockchain Innovation Lab of Deloitte Found here: https://www.chipin.com/iconomi-transparency-crypto-industry-first-blockchain-audit/ https://www.chipin.com/iconomi-transparency-crypto-industry-...
- cryptogeek 9y agoAnother portal covering the same: https://www.finextra.com/pressarticle/73562/deloitte-runs-the-rule-over-iconomi-digital-ssets/wholesale https://www.finextra.com/pressarticle/73562/deloitte-runs-th... Looks legit.
- jlgaddis 9y agoThese two links are just parroting the press release. It'll be "legit" when you can grab the PDF of the audit from Deloitte's web servers directly and read it for yourself.
- jstanley 9y agoNote cryptogeek account appears to have been created specifically to talk positively about ICONOMI. Neither chipin.com nor finextra.com seem particularly authoritative.
- notyourday 9y agoI googled. I looked, but maybe not enough. What I cannot see if Deloitte making this announcement. I only see ICONOMI's claims. Could someone possibly post a link? That link should obviously point to deloitte.com -- the same site that medium puff piece points to.
- tialaramex 9y agoWell, it _really_ ought to link to some neutral third party that just administrates stuff, as if the audit repository belonged to Deloitte that lets them take things back afterwards which is also bad. However there might well not be such a third party for the Wild West of cryptocurrency. "Hooray" ? Maybe someone will build one with blockchain :(
- gregorkobal 9y agoDeloitte press release: Setting New Standards for the Blockchain Industry: Deloitte verified ICONOMI’s digital assets https://www2.deloitte.com/si/en/pages/press/blockchain-industry.html https://www2.deloitte.com/si/en/pages/press/blockchain-indus...
- jstanley 9y agoInterestingly, from https://www.iconomi.net/audit/201804 https://www.iconomi.net/audit/201804 > * Reserves were verified by Deloitte. This number includes funds locked in a Parity multi-sig wallet containing $42,773,123.61 USD in value. ICONOMI is solvent even if the locked funds are not included in the reserves. They basically are missing $42m because it's stuck in a Parity multi-sig wallet. Parity multi-sig wallets no longer work. They're apparently solvent anyway so it's no big deal, but I'm surprised that information is relegated to a tiny footnote.
- baby 9y agoThat is hilarious. More info on Parity multi-sig wallets available here: https://www.dasp.co/#item-2 https://www.dasp.co/#item-2
- thisisit 9y agoThere is a huge problem with this audit. If we look at the page: https://www.iconomi.net/audit/201804 https://www.iconomi.net/audit/201804 There are liability and reserve line items. ICONOMI made special effort to spell out their liabilities - giving user and DAA level breakdowns in coins. But, there are no details on what the reserves look like. We get only one line explaining they had 42 million in parity multisig wallet. The problem with such approach is that we don't know what all things were considered during the audit. This leaves lot of questions unanswered. For example - Does ICONOMI hold cash? If yes, then what happens if liability coin values outgrows their cash.
- cryptogeek 9y agoGood question. Not directly visible from ICONOMI audit page, however this page has more info: https://www.chipin.com/iconomi-transparency-crypto-industry-first-blockchain-audit/ https://www.chipin.com/iconomi-transparency-crypto-industry-... They hold user assets directly I would get from this statement: "The final result of the blockchain audit proved that the ICONOMI platform is solvent, user balances are as reported and the reserves cover the liabilities" or this one "The balances of digital assets as shown on the ICONOMI platform for each user reflect the actual balances held by ICONOMI on behalf of its users."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jesusthatsgreat 9y agoIconomi publish quarterly reports and in the latest one they had over $9m cash. They've also previously said they always aim to have ~2 years of runway in cash to protect against a long term bear market: https://medium.com/iconominet/iconomi-financial-report-q4-2017-17da25349f3d https://medium.com/iconominet/iconomi-financial-report-q4-20...
- thisisit 9y agoThat is good on ICONOMI that they publish such reports. But, this kind of misreporting really lowers my confidence in ICONOMI. First, they only have a profit and loss statement which looks correct. What is does this burn rate entail? Second, the Balance sheet is out of whack. This makes me wonder if they have a finance guy on their payroll. Balance sheet needs to contain Asset and Liabilities. This report actually contains coin and cash balances. Third, the actual balance sheet was delivered by this Deloitte report. Given that they have this data, how hard was it to prepare a proper report and tell everyone what were actual their assets and liabilities? They seemed too focused on liabilities. It seems either Deloitte audit was fake or ICONOMI is knowingly hiding their numbers.
- gregorkobal 9y agoDeloitte press release: Setting New Standards for the Blockchain Industry: Deloitte verified ICONOMI’s digital assets https://www2.deloitte.com/si/en/pages/press/blockchain-industry.html https://www2.deloitte.com/si/en/pages/press/blockchain-indus...