> Sure, but I wouldn't choose "a random friend" to run my FB replacement service, I'd choose a trusted friend. How does this relate to scuttlebutt? There's no

> Sure, but I wouldn't choose "a random friend" to run my FB replacement service, I'd choose a trusted friend. How does this relate to scuttlebutt? There's no scuttlebutt “service”; it's a tool and a protocol, like a pen and the English language. > no matter how good Facebooks security team are at patching and auditing servers - THEY ARE THE ADVERSARY IN THIS CONTEXT! I think this is the salient point: if you send data to your friend, they necessarily have that data and can leak it; but there's no need for a stranger with unknown motives (Facebook) to also have that data.