5 ms·
> Even if we ignored the logistics of such a challenge and agreed on the conclusion, why is the same logic not applied to things like alcohol and all the harms
by naasking 9y ago
> Even if we ignored the logistics of such a challenge and agreed on the conclusion, why is the same logic not applied to things like alcohol and all the harms that results (drunk driving, alcoholics ruining their lives, etc).
Indeed, and we already tried that, and it led to the rise of organized crime. But I think it's important not to get sucked into "slippery slope" style reasoning. There can be good reasons why banning alcohol would be problematic, but banning guns would not. It depends on the surrounding culture. For instance, if enjoying a drink a few times a week was universal, but almost no one owned a gun.
> The overall argument has valid points and problem points, but the discrepancy of when it is applies makes discussing the validity harder when it seems people aren't being transparent about their motivations to begin with.
I think it's largely because people see symptoms, and look backwards in the causal chain to something they think they understand and can blame as "the" problem. People are pretty weak with nuance on tough and emotionally charged issues.
- moomin 9y agoThe thing is, you don’t really need to theorise about how to stop school shootings. It’s been done. It just required people to prioritise children’s lives over a minority hobby. (I’m from a country where owning a gun is legal, but controlled, and has no school shootings. We used to have less control, and school shootings happened.)
- pathseeker 9y ago>The thing is, you don’t really need to theorise about how to stop school shootings. It’s been done. It's still theorizing because there are no comparable countries to the US that have done it when it comes to the number of guns already out there (300+ million) and the importance of the 2nd amendment to many of the citizens. >It just required people to prioritise children’s lives over a minority hobby. If you see it as a "minority hobby" rather than a right, this makes complete sense. Would you also suggest banning protests in response to violence and death at protests because it's even more of a "minority hobby" than gun ownership?
- dwild 9y ago> Would you also suggest banning protests in response to violence and death at protests because it's even more of a "minority hobby" than gun ownership? He didn't suggested banning, he suggested controlling them which is extremely different. I don't know for your country (but I'm pretty sure it's the same), but in mine protest are controlled too. You need to give your plan well in advance and it need to be approved first. You never seen a protest becoming illegal and people getting arrested for it?
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y ago>He didn't suggested banning, he suggested controlling them which is extremely different. And which is the next step for someone who does want to ban it. At least in the US the discussion has reached the point where one side no longer trusts the intentions of the other side, so anything that could eventually help a ban (such as a registry) is seem as being for the purpose of eventually helping a ban. This isn't without reason either, given that many past compromises are now seen as not enough and begun being presented as errors in previous laws that need to be fixed.
- aplummer 9y ago1st point: It’s been done for hundreds of millions of people and hundreds of millions of guns, and it’s regulation not removing all guns, which is already done in the US, you can’t get a rocket launcher, so why am assault rifle? No banned guns, just licenses, gun safes, regulation on types, reasonable ownership limits (all farmers I know in Aus have 5+ guns) - that’s all it takes to stop mass shootings. If it’s a hobby that’s fine, that’s a valid application reason for example, you just have to prove you like guns and go to a range or subscribe to a gun magazine and you can buy them. That 30 minute hurdle provides a barrier to enough people.
- leereeves 9y agoCivilians can't buy assault rifles in the US. What civilians buy is a hunting rifle that looks like an assault rifle.
- cl0ne 9y agoIt's not a hobby to everyone, some people survive by subsistence hunting.
- aplummer 9y agoI think they should have clarified in urban environments, people outside of cities use guns is basically every country, even japan.
- leereeves 9y agoWe've already tried to ban guns in (many) cities while allowing them outside those cities. Criminals just leave the city to buy guns. Now people in cities want to solve that by forbidding people outside the cities from owning guns.
- aplummer 9y agoNobody in any sane country has or city has banned guns. It’s just regulation like cars or planes or doing electrical work or cutting up fugu
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y agoAt least for cars there is no regulation. Using them on public property (public roads) has certain regulations, but not for use on private property.
- leereeves 9y agoHow shall we define banned? Obviously no government anywhere has completely banned guns - they all arm at least some portion of their police and most allow bodyguards to carry guns to protect the wealthy and powerful. I used the word banned meaning "made impossible for a large number of people to own legally". Governments that theoretically allow permits but rarely grant those permits in practice have effectively banned guns.
- Dramatize 9y ago
- pathseeker 9y ago>For instance, if enjoying a drink a few times a week was universal, but almost no one owned a gun. 1 in 3 own a gun in the US. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/one-three-americans-own-guns-culture-factor-study-finds-n384031 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/one-three-americans-own... 1 in 2 had a drink in the last month: https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-consumption/alcohol-facts-and-statistics https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-co... From that same source, 88,000 people die annually from alcohol-related diseases, making it the 3rd leading cause of death in the US. Culturally, guns and drinking are the same order of magnitude in the US. From a death count though, alcohol dominates.
- naasking 9y agoThe concentration of gun ownership varies markedly across regions though. Not sure that's true of drinking, which I expect would be pretty universal. In any case, at worst your data suggests that banning guns in the US would be just as impossible as banning alcohol turned out to be, which very well could be true.
- davedx 9y agoI have another take (I have an alcoholic relative and know quite a few people who don't drink at all) on this. An alcoholic has many chances to turn his or her life around. It's a long, slow story. It's not inevitable. With the right support, it's possible to stop drinking and lead a healthy and fulfilling life. Contrast this to the kind of events that result in deaths from guns in the US. The recent school shooting of course springs to mind. A bunch of kids were shot and killed. They had no chance. None. It's not just the end statistics but the method at which we arrive at them.
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y ago> A bunch of kids were shot and killed. They had no chance. None. Why did you compare an alcoholic that harms none but themselves with people who were shot? Wouldn't a drunk driver killing people be a more apt comparison?