4 ms·
For electric planes I'd like to see dual battery dual inverter/motor twin props for redundancy. Sure I trust a good electric more than gas, but why not offer mo
by phkahler 9y ago
For electric planes I'd like to see dual battery dual inverter/motor twin props for redundancy. Sure I trust a good electric more than gas, but why not offer more than just that?
- dschuler 9y agoMulti-engine planes are more complex to fly and require a different license. If an engine quits during takeoff, the plane is going to yaw toward the failed engine side, among many other issues. The plane doesn't just fall out of the sky when the only engine quits, anyway - you can glide quite some distance, provided you've got the altitude to do it.
- dmurray 9y agoI never really understood this. Sure, it's complicated to compensate for asymmetric thrust. But if you know how to fly a single-engine plane with no engines, surely you can figure out a two-engine plane with one engine? At worst you can turn off the functioning engine and be back in the situation you understand.
- dschuler 9y agoThe FAA publishes a couple of books, including the Airplane Flying Handbook [0], that has a good intro chapter to multi-engine flying [1] that goes into some of the issues that come up. [0] https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/handbooks_manuals/aviation/airplane_handbook/media/airplane_flying_handbook.pdf https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/handbooks_manuals/a... [1] https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/handbooks_manuals/aviation/airplane_handbook/media/14_afh_ch12.pdf https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/handbooks_manuals/a...
- phkahler 9y agoIf you put them in back closer to the centerline it helps minimize that yaw and roll tendency. On the other hand, I picture one on each wing to minimize the length of cable needed to deliver the current. Cables for 100-400A add a couple pounds per foot.
- raquo 9y agoPower-to-weight ratio. It's a major weakness of electric power with current technology, and a single engine with a big prop is more efficient than any other configuration. Sometimes you see electric aircraft have multiple smaller engines and props, but that is mostly driven by structural or design concerns of their esoteric missions like needing to distribute the weight along a huge wing (Sunseeker) or needing to land in tight spots (various VTOL designs). Conventional planform electric aircraft don't have such extreme limitations so there is no point in sacrificing performance.
- Gibbon1 9y agoPower to weight ratio's of electric motors are higher than piston engines. But the usable energy to weight ratio of batteries is 5-10 times worse than a gasoline tank. I seen some stuff that indicates that you can use small props at the wing tips to reduce drag. Works by canceling out the wing tip vortexes. Hasn't been done for a lot of reasons but mostly because of structural concerns. I think one prop is more efficient than two for the same thrust. Multi prop airplanes are potentially tricky to fly.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoGiven the fuel density problem it's interesting we haven't seen any hybrid designs that generate electricity with an ICE engine (like the range-extenders in some PE cars like the Volt or the i3). I assume the added weight of the engine would cancel out some of the benefit.
- rdl 9y agoThere are some (for the Octocopter from Workhorse) http://workhorse.com/surefly http://workhorse.com/surefly
- greglindahl 9y agoThere are hybrid designs, and you can also do tricks like charging the batteries from running a prop backwards when descending... similar to regenerative braking in electric and hybrid cars. You'll note that hybrid cars aren't exactly winning in the market.
- bdamm 9y agoElectric motors can also be stacked multiple motors to one shaft, a trick that has also been put to work to bond an electric motor to a gasoline engine to provide "boost" at takeoff. Existing gasoline single-prop engines typically have dual redundant ignition systems with segregated cylinders powering a unified driveshaft and camshaft, and I think your split inverter/motor/battery path is entirely in line with that approach to single-prop internal redundancy. It depends on the weight of the components, of course.