5 ms·
For a properly designed distributed social network, there's no reason your data should be visible to anyone other than those you have approved.
by colordrops 9y ago
For a properly designed distributed social network, there's no reason your data should be visible to anyone other than those you have approved.
- rock_hard 9y agoWhat if people get tricked into approving malicious accounts? Who is gonna police that? How are you gonna prevent anarchy?
- colordrops 9y agoPeople can get tricked into opening their door for robbers. This isn't a silver bullet - it would just avoid a central database with everyone's info that could easily be shared or scraped.
- kabacha 9y ago> What if people get tricked into approving malicious accounts? Do you really need to idiot proof everything? I'd say just let natural selection happen at this point.
- johnny22 9y agoherd immunity is a thing that you're not taking into account. It's rarely about single indviduals, but the entire group.
- newfoundglory 9y agoNatural selection in this case means another Cambridge Analytica. Most people want to avoid that.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y ago> Do you really need to idiot proof everything? I'd say just let natural selection happen at this point. I'd say people with this mindset will be the first to be eliminated through natural selection, not because they're unintelligent, but because of the belief that they're intelligent and smart enough not to fall for this. The reason is: EVERYONE can fall for anything.
- Bizarro 9y agoHow are you gonna prevent anarchy? Cats and dogs living together...oh my. Let me clue you in on something. In free societies there's risks and individuals make bad decisions, and we live with it. We don't need someone policing everything.
- duckMuppet 9y agoAnd this is the crux if the matter. Ideally, there should only be a select few that determine which apps and programs should run for the masses. We should even control which software users have access to.. After all, giving the people too many choices leads to imminent danger on all fronts and is uncontrollable. I'm increasingly convinced that there are a great many who relish the idea that the internet, privacy, software, and ultimately life should be state controlled, similar to China or North Korea, as long as It's their people making the rules.. It's 2018 and that would never happen though.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoI used to think like this too, but once you dive deep into "decentralization", ironically you learn so many things that are infeasible and impossible with decentralization, and you start to appreciate all the shitty rules that you used to despise. For starters, you say "free societies", but try to think deeper about what that exactly means. It's most likely a collection of nation states, each with its own governance and military and law. Everything around you works because of some sort of centralized authority. Most people don't realize this--I myself who's a programmer probably would have died without knowing this if I didn't get into decentralized tech stuff--because they never needed to question why governments exist or why nations exist. TLDR: Anarchy is likely to happen if there's no regulation. Even the Internet itself is regulated if you look into every party involved.
- rock_hard 9y agowe certainly don't need to police everything...but there is a middle ground between that and no policing at all! And that will be hard to do in decentralized networks.
- 9y ago
- brandonjm 9y agoNo one currently polices whether or not I accept a particular friend request on Facebook except me. There is no way for me to guarantee that the person I am accepting a request from is who they say they are and isn't going to scrape all my posts, personal info and photos.