3 ms·
How the distracting pin stripes in OS X up until 10.3 (when they were made significantly lower contrast, before they faded away in 10.5) got past any UI experts
by petercooper 16y ago
How the distracting pin stripes in OS X up until 10.3 (when they were made significantly lower contrast, before they faded away in 10.5) got past any UI experts or even Steve Jobs is beyond me. I'm an ardent OS X user now but I'm surprised to still hold my 2000/2001 Windows user opinion of "eugh, the new Mac OS looks horrible!"
- pohl 16y agoI didn't use Windows back then. Could somebody post a screenshot of what it would have looked like in the same year?
- pmjordan 16y agohttp://www.google.com/images?q=windows+2000+screenshot http://www.google.com/images?q=windows+2000+screenshot although I suppose most people were still using Windows Me, the last DOS-based Windows, rather than Windows 2000, which descended from NT. They looked pretty similar, though: http://www.google.com/images?q=windows+me+screenshot http://www.google.com/images?q=windows+me+screenshot Windows XP was released a year later and was the first release to unify the workstation and desktop lines on the same foundation (with the Home & Professional variants).
- petercooper 16y agohttp://www.granneman.com/images/windows_2000_screenshot.gif http://www.granneman.com/images/windows_2000_screenshot.gif was quite representative of what I was using in 2000/2001. I'm a foaming-at-the-mouth OS X fan now, but I still find Windows 2000 more palatable as a day-to-day sort of UI compared to the first few releases of OS X. At the time, Windows beat OS X in some areas that are no longer important.. like very easy to resize windows and more consistent minimize/maximize behavior, all of which are less important in a high resolution world.
- modeless 16y agoI still think Windows is significantly better in the window management department. Exposé is nice, but Windows 7's mouse gestures for maximize/restore are just brilliant, I prefer the taskbar to the dock, and the top menu is a liability now that many apps are ditching menu bars altogether.
- dasil003 16y agoDo you need to look any further than the fact that the original iMac with its god-forsaken hockey puck mouse was Jobs' first critical step in the revitalization of Apple? It goes to show that great product design is often more fashion than timelessness.
- pohl 16y agoThat was a horrible mouse. Speaking of fashion, remember how it didn't take long before PCs and all manner of peripherals all had to be decked out in translucent turquoise bezels?
- mortenjorck 16y agoWhat was always funny to me was how very few bandwagon-hopping industrial designers ever seemed to actually get what made the iMac's use of translucent teal plastic cool: It's not all the same material. It's balanced out by a variety of textures, some transparent, some opaque, some teal and some white. Most fashion-followers just specced a teal translucent instead of the beige they'd been using, left the design the same, and called it a day.
- nanairo 16y agoMy pet theory about this is that 10.0's look was as much as about setting a clear distance between itself and the old Classic as it was about real innovation. (I'm talking only of the UI look). When Aqua was presented people loved it people hated it but nobody could ignore it. The first time you installed Mac OS X made you feel like you were in a whole new world. Of course it wasn't that practical and funnily most of it has reverted back... before they pinstripes got faded, then we got the metallic grey, and now just a nice subtle grey. All that is left from those old days are the traffic light buttons, the gem-blue scroll bars, and the standard button look.
- blahedo 16y ago> ...funnily most of it has reverted back What are you talking about? The pinstripes date all the way back to System 1. The modern OS X looks different from 10.0 but a lot more like 10.0 than like System 9.
- nanairo 16y agoAre you referring to the strips on the old title bar? True, but they were a _lot_ nicer. I remember at the time people complaining a lot about OS X look, including the stripes, and wanted the old look back. So I guess most of us don't feel like they are really the same. But I get your point. As for the look of Snow Leopard vs. MacOS 9 and MacOS X 10.0 I'd say a lot has reverted back. The old one in particular used a lot of greys, which OS X at the beginning was trying to get away from ("Look, it's all colourful!"). So yeah, maybe I exaggerated when I said most of it, but you've got to admit that the look has moved back to the more subtle ways of Classic than the flashy ways of 10.0, no?
- ben1040 16y agoMy theory was that the point of the pinstripe look was to blur the line between the UI and the hardware it was running on. Mac hardware at the time had a pinstripe look, just the same. Today the interface has an "aluminum" look, as do today's Macs.
- mortenjorck 16y agoI've surprisingly never seen anyone else bring this up, though I always took it for granted. I actually remember thinking, right around the time the original translucent blue iMac came out, "now they just need to make the OS look this good," my hypothesis seemingly being confirmed later by the Aqua preview with its translucent blue visual effects.