4 ms·
Personally, I think it's fine to expect employers to verify a candidates skills. But they should also limit their verification to the minimum amount necessary.
by mywittyname 9y ago
Personally, I think it's fine to expect employers to verify a candidates skills. But they should also limit their verification to the minimum amount necessary.
People are just arguing where that line should be drawn. Whether it's hours, days, or months of verification. Some careers do require months of unpaid internships in order to get jobs. And it's not because it takes months to verify a person's ability, but because companies will do anything they can to pay people as little as possible for their work.
- newobj 9y agoIt's wrong if the company benefits in any way from your interview/probationary period. (Probationary periods are just wrong period IMHO.) Interviewing is a huge burden to most companies, so if your interview questions are entirely synthetic, it's ONLY a cost to the company to interview you, which they should naturally want to minimize on their own. But you know what's even more expensive than interviewing? Dealing with bad hires. So I think a company is within its rights to do it what takes to ensure a quality hire. But they should not gain any benefit from this process - doing so is crossing a line - other than potentially being able to hire you, or failing that, at least make a good impression on you.
- mywittyname 9y agoYou're not refuting my point though. I agree they should do what they can to ensure they get a good hire, but I also thing they should do the minimum amount necessary to do such. I've worked on many great teams whose interview process was little more than asking intelligent, pointed questions about previous work experience. Of course, this puts the onus on the interviewer to know what they are doing. I personally keep a list of elementary questions about various technologies for interviewing. So when someone says they've worked with ElasticSearch or Python, I ask them how to do a few rudimentary tasks in a few of them and can pretty quickly tell how much they've been fibbing. I've had companies both accept and reject my hiring recommendations, and every person that's been hired despite my objection has been poor quality. So I know at least anecdotally that it's a viable strategy and it only takes ~30 minutes per person.
- newobj 9y agoI wasn't trying to refute your point... in fact I think I was mostly agreeing with you?
- mywittyname 9y agoSeems like we agree on the what, but we're debating the how.