5 ms·
FWIW, SDRAM transfer rate isn't really a big performance driver. The bus is idle almost all the time on modern parts, which are dominated by the precharge/read
by ajross 9y ago
FWIW, SDRAM transfer rate isn't really a big performance driver. The bus is idle almost all the time on modern parts, which are dominated by the precharge/read-write cycle and not transfer. When the 512 bits of data actually arrives, it gets blasted out very fast. Shrinking that transfer time has a measurable effect, but it's not remotely linear in the clock frequency.
- dragontamer 9y agoIts certainly non-linear, and you're right that its dominated by precharge / read-write cycles. But DDR4 RAM has support for 16 banks per stick! A CPU with two memory controllers can have 64 outstanding requests to DDR4 RAM simultaneously (16 per stick, x2 from the chip select, x2 for the 2nd memory controller). And since modern cores are highly multithreaded, and also have prefetchers and whatnot, I'm sure the modern DDR4 bus is quite active. Perhaps it doesn't matter too much for single-threaded situations (single-threads only benefit from prefetch and out-of-order executions). But a Ryzen 2700x is a 8-core / 16-threaded beast, which will surely eat up all of those outstanding DDR4 requests. Intel's 8700k is 6-core/12-threads as well, so they'll rack up those memory requests and keep the bus busy. And if each of your Assembly commands are AVX (256-bit requests per instruction)... well... that's going to be a busy bus.
- walshemj 9y agoRYZEN seems to like fast memory more than Itel one review I just looked at said that the new RYZENS are targeting 3400
- seabrookmx 9y agoThis is because Ryzen's "infinity fabric" or internal interconnect between the cores is tied to the RAM speed. This is kind of like the old days when CPUs used a Front-side Bus (FSB). If you increased the FSB frequency it would increase the CPU frequency, the RAM frequency, and even PCIe depending on how it was wired up. It made things simpler to have the FSB be the sole clock-generator. So despite the increased bandwidth moving from 2600 to 3200mhz RAM not having much impact on performance (in most applications), the increased frequency of the bus between the cores allows for greater performance beyond that. IIRC Intel uses a ring-style bus with it's own clock, hence why it this effect only applies to AMD.
- floatboth 9y agoYeah, up until 3200 MT/s the IF has a lot of impact. > the old days when CPUs used a Front-side Bus (FSB) They still kinda do. It's not the bus, but there is one clock called BCLK (base clock) now and almost everything is derived from it. It's not adjustable on cheaper boards, but with a good board you can absolutely do the same adjustment :)
- seabrookmx 9y agoYeah I have an older box running an i7-920 which is overclocked from 2.6 to 3.6ghz with the base clock. Sandy Bridge and newer get extremely unstable when you toy with the base clock more than a few MHz though. You're basically stuck shelling out an extra few bucks for a "K" chip if you want to overclock on Intel now.
- floatboth 9y agoSkylake and newer have fixed this, they decoupled PCIe and stuff from BCLK. On Skylake you can actually do non-K (I ran a 6400 at up to 4.7GHz): https://overclocking.guide/category/intel-oc-guides/skylake-non-k-oc/ https://overclocking.guide/category/intel-oc-guides/skylake-... Of course on Kaby and later they closed the loophole...