6 ms·
I can't see how it's theoretically possible to do a small scale experiment with UBI. If not everyone gets it, you can't see the big impact on the economy (what
by alkonaut 9y ago
I can't see how it's theoretically possible to do a small scale experiment with UBI. If not everyone gets it, you can't see the big impact on the economy (what happens with supply/demand/inflation). And if it's with a short horizon, then people still have to plan for life after the UBI experiment.
You can't give up the career you are going to need to make a living in 2 years time, just because you get paid a small sum per month for 2 years.
So I can't see how experiments are worthwhile unless you actually go in head first. UBI should be announced as universal and forever, or it isn't "proper" UBI, and doesn't show the effects of UBI.
This is also the reason why no one tries it.
- hawkice 9y agoI am very skeptical of claims that outcomes are discontinuous in policy space. Going one step in direction A should give you information about going further in that same direction, at least on some scale of change. Clearly the people running the experiment agreed, because they designed it with the intent to get that information.
- mrkurt 9y agoIt's good to be skeptical. There are a whole class of problems that are discontinuous, but it's way too tempting to label things that way. That said, UBI _seems_ a lot more like herd immunity than most policy problems, especially social safety net policy.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWell outcomes are discontinuous where the policies are discontinuous. There's a huge leap in the graph from 'this is temporary' to 'this is permanent.' We can't just write off the effect that has on human behavior.
- dwc 9y agoI imagine that researchers designed the experiment they thought would be accepted rather than the experiment they wanted. Yes, they intended to learn some things and most likely did.
- brianwawok 9y ago> Going one step in direction A should give you information about going further in that same direction So eating healthy for 1 day/week will change your blood results and tell you that a year of it will make you lose 50 pounds? So going to 1 day of college will make you measure differently on a test that checks critical thinking? Different things take different amount of time to see results. I could see behaving very differently between * This is a very temporary 1 year test of UBI * vs * You have a social safety net of UBI for your entire life, and can count on the income no matter what happens
- Nomentatus 9y agoIt's more that shorter experiments might tell you whether there are deep downsides even in the short-term. Not great information, not full information, but information; even if it's just a one-way test.
- dogma1138 9y agoIt’s not that they are completely useless it’s that they cannot test the actual affects on the economy. If you have a small scale UBI even if it’s on say a scale of a whole town it’s still not enough to evaluate the economic impact because the supply/demand economy isn’t that localized. We have other experiments that have shown to have a negative effect for example rent allowance in the UK which essentially set the lower limit for rent as no one rents below what the council would pay, this has increased rent prices even in places where there was no negative change in the supply and demand.
- opportune 9y agoFirst, nobody is saying they're discontinuous. But there are plenty of continuous results we can see that are concave up, i.e. they require commitment beyond a certain point to be more effective than not implanting them at all. For example, let's say initially we build a single road from coast to coast in the US, starting with no roads. There wouldn't be many places to drive to, there would be a small market for cars, and as a result of lacking economies of scale, cars would be expensive. There wouldn't be much infrastructure for purchasing or maybe even extracting gas, so that would be more expensive too. The road probably wouldn't get used much, and wouldn't be worth it. But if you build a bunch of roads all over the country between where people want to go, eventually they'll become worth it.
- notahacker 9y agoIf the criticisms of a policy is that subsidies for the voluntarily economically inactive can only be funded with massive tax increases and cuts in benefits for some of the poorest members of society, that the biggest chief beneficiaries will be house-rich early retirees and that it isn't economically sustainable, then a test which tops up a proportion of people's existing benefits out of general government funds for a short period and discovers they like free money isn't very informative.
- pm90 9y agoThere are such things as network effects and thresholds for complex systems. So outcomes can and will be discontinuous in policy space. Perhaps for the simple reason that human society is pretty complex and certain things about it are still not very well understood.
- Koshkin 9y agoRight. It's like promising immortality for two years.
- VMG 9y agoSounds reminiscent of "Socialism doesn't work if not applied globally".
- alkonaut 9y agoI wouldn't go that far, but I'll go as far as saying that socialism near useless for a single person, and only shows any promise whatsoever for two or more people...
- loceng 9y agoAlso, we can predict a lot of the major impacts something like UBI will have, however part of the plan must be to implement plans and strategy to manage for these - in particular, whenever new money is introduced into a system, many for-profit systems will increase their pricing, which then trickles down into every other system requiring to increase their pricing. There has to be a floor created, and there needs to be management of otherwise unmanaged wild west economics.
- alkonaut 9y agoI think it's also important to remember that the effects would be wildly different between countries with big social safety nets (such as Finland), and countries withouot. For countries with lots of extensive welfare programs, a small UBI is shifting money from various programs into UBI, thereby removing administrative overhead - rather than "new money". For example: every parent in sweden gets $160 child allowance ($320 for a single parent), regardless of income, and with no application required. We don't have dental included in the universal health plan - instead there is a subsidy of $70 per person per year. Students get an allowance of nearly $400 a month (allowance, not loans) And so on and so forth. There are lots of these allowances and subsidies that under a UBI system would just disappear and be part of the UBI in the nordic countries. That's why I don't see it as such a massive step. First you go to an enormous welfare state, then you change that to a UBI system. It's then less of a leap.
- loceng 9y agoYou can balance out a UBI program with other programs, it would be better anyhow, as an example, you can incentivize more people to be a student.
- whb07 9y agoThere are already large versions of UBI already in place, just by another name. If you take a look at Saudi Arabia and other rich gulf states, there’s essentially large cash transfers to citizenry for just being alive (and of course not revolting). It is of course telling that Saudi Arabia has no sort of industry and the little they produce via Aramco has large swaths of imported experts working for them. Same applies to the other gulf states, importing everything from house cleaning to engineering labor. As to an American UBI scheme, one can look at the handful of rich pockets of Native American tribes who run successful casino operations. In Florida, the Seminole tribes distribute thousands of dollars/month, to each of their members just for being alive. Many of them end up having chronic issues with drug and alcohol abuse.
- telchar 9y agoOf course that's not just a basic income, that's a full cushy income. A better example with be Alaska which uses ok revenues to give a subsidy to residents of the state.
- japhyr 9y agoWe get about $1000/year, and the cost of living here is higher than just about any other state. You can't really compare the Alaska PFD to a UBI.
- reaperducer 9y agoWhen I lived in Wisconsin, we got $400/year. Officially it was to help pay for heat in the winter, but I always thought of it as a consolation prize for having to live in Wisconsin. I hear Minnesotans get a stipend, too.
- japhyr 9y agoIn 2008, the AK PFD hit its all time high of $2069, and we got an "Alaska Resource Rebate" of $1200. Every family in the state who qualified got $3269 per person. In large families, that was a windfall. That said, I think that was the winter that was extra cold and windy. We were living in a house with a boiler, and it wasn't adjusted right one month. That month's heating bill was over $500. Heating costs are serious business. We got a deal on the house we bought because renters couldn't afford to heat the whole house one winter, and the cold and damp in the rest of the house caused enough damage to bring down the value of the house. I didn't know there were other states that offered blanket assistance like you described, that's pretty interesting to know.