5 ms·
I didn't like this at all. I found the one-sentence format distracting and the article lacking a theme. It read more like a laundry list directly out of somebod
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I didn't like this at all. I found the one-sentence format distracting and the article lacking a theme. It read more like a laundry list directly out of somebody's brain. What a strange style for an essay.
I freely admit bias though, since I wrote a functional article just this morning (shameless plug: http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2010/09/functional-tdd.php http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2010/09/functional-td...)
I'm probably still ouching from watching it tank on the "new" page. Very sad experience, that. :)
It just doesn't seem like there is much here. Certainly not enough to warrant the votes it's getting. I must be missing something, because between the odd style and the lack of substance it doesn't seem to match up to the response from the community.
- eru 16y agoPerhaps this piece has a more engaging title than yours? It also has pictures. That makes the page nicer too look at--even if it would just be Sashimi and bore no relation to your content. Often it's also luck, whether your article makes it to the front page. If you want to try again, just post your article under a different URL and re-submit at another time. I guess if you do not do it too often, nobody will have anything against this practice. If you want to be ethical, just do a some work on your article, between each submit. Nearly every piece can profit from rewriting anyway. Just as a suggestion, have a look at Haskell's QuickCheck and see how it applies to your argument. There's also a nice blog post about rolling your own window manager (http://donsbot.wordpress.com/2007/05/17/roll-your-own-window-manager-tracking-focus-with-a-zipper/ http://donsbot.wordpress.com/2007/05/17/roll-your-own-window...), that emphasizes using the right data structures to statically guarantee your invariants with the help of the compiler where possible instead of writing tests.
- DanielBMarkham 16y ago(excuse the meta) Nyah. It's not a big deal either way. What's so interesting/frustrating about the process is the degree of randomness involved. You spend five hours writing a story on something you think important and insightful, it tanks. You spend 30 minutes on a vapid rant, gets voted to the top. Go figure. What I think it boils down to is emotional impact instead of writing quality or topic. Articles, titles and authors that have the greatest emotional impact in with the audience during the first 45 minutes or so (the time it takes to sink off the new page) do well. Others not so much. An interesting "feature" of the voting system is that stories that get voted up a lot in the first part of a 3-hour period stay on front longer than stories with similar vote counts that all occurred at the end of the 3-hour period. The number of people that like it isn't germane -- it's the degree of swiftness with which the upvotes occur. That means that if your article is a hit with 20 folks in the community, you'd better know that those 20 folks are online if you want others to see it. Little things like this probably lead to voting-ring-like behavior on the part of users. I know it certainly can be frustrating.
- ams6110 16y agoI found your piece to be a much better read. It exactly hits why I've never really found TDD to be very practical in my work.