3 ms·
On one hand I agree. It's not only messy, it's designed to be that way. On the other hand, we need to look no further than gerrymandering to see that something
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
On one hand I agree. It's not only messy, it's designed to be that way.
On the other hand, we need to look no further than gerrymandering to see that something has gone wrong.
Furthermore, we are barely a two-party system. We get to vote. What's lacking is choice.
The Fourth Estate is also in a troubling state. Unfortunately, they're not going to report that about themselves.
Finally. Let's not forget the power and influence of lobbyist.
It's hard to imagine Jefferson saying, "Yes. This is it. Great job."
- JasonFruit 9y agoThe messiness of our elections is excessive, and your points are generally good. But to our credit, it's hard to imagine a large, long-lived republic that would get a pat on the head from Jefferson. He had very strict principles that even he found difficult to maintain in practice. That being said, we need a healthy dose of principles that safeguard liberty, and the determination to hold elected officials to them.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYour last paragraph is spot on. As a start, I'd like to suggest we stop using the word leader / leadership when - as your so accurately noted - they are elected officials. Some do lead. But leader is a title that should be reserved for those who actually do. We've been duped into believing they are all leaders. They are not. We haven't even left the gate and already the first step is wrong.
- cal5k 9y agoI live in a parliamentary democracy (Canada). The ability to elect a minority government is actually a super useful protection mechanism because it creates 4 or or more options. 1. Majority for Liberal government 2. Majority for Conservative government 3. Minority for Liberal government 4. Minority for Conservative government 5+ Majority/minority for any of the various other parties (NDP, Green, etc.) <- doesn't really happen federally, but provincially it's definitely possible The downside in Canada is that our appointed Senate is weak compared to an elected one, and you can whip your party to vote along certain lines.