20 ms·
Are the people they're up against really all that morally superior? I'm not making a whataboutist point, it's just that if you're picking a side you have to lo
by simonh 9y ago
Are the people they're up against really all that morally superior?
I'm not making a whataboutist point, it's just that if you're picking a side you have to look at more than just one of them. So absolutely soldiers should be held accountable for their treatment of captives, and e.g. Israeli soldiers have been jailed for assaulting prisoners, but I don't see many Palestinians being jailed by their own administrative authority for killing Israeli civilians.
Neither side should be above criticism, but when it comes to actively supporting one side or the other you have to look at the record of both.
- bhouston 9y agoIt is the occupation and the every expanding settlements that is generally seen as the problem. One people who do not have rights under the control of another for the last 50 or so years. The same issue in apartheid South Africa. That is the fundamental and core issue, everything else is noise around it. And the occupation can not end because so many want to keep the settlements expanding.
- srean 9y agoI would agree with some of the point you raise: no clear moral superiority of some of the people they are against. Do recall that that Israel has followed a policy of assassination based on political disagreement. People have been assassinated for their speech and opinion.
- simonh 9y agoThat is reprehensible. The fact that Israeli civilians are routinely murdered for being Israeli, and that doing that is considered the primary tool of policy by one side in the conflict, is also reprehensible. On a specific issue such as a particular crime or incident I don't believe whataboutist rhetoric is justifiable. In fact it appalls me. But I'm not going to boycott Israel on the basis of a moral argument for their behaviour in a conflict without also hearing why we're not also boycotting the other side too. There are several sides in that conflict. If we want to understand and address it, that needs to be done with the blinkers off.