7 ms·
A lesson in wireless engineering from the Raspberry Pi
- vkuruthers 9y agoQuite good performance from that antenna for it's size and cost yes. I wonder what tools they used to design it?
- jcrabtr 9y agoAccording to [1] (which has more info on the antenna design), the resonant cavity antenna was designed by a company called Proant [2]. I remember reading the the antenna is the same on the Pi 3 and Zero W. There are a few options for PCB antenna design software out there, but I had never seen this type of PCB antenna before the Zero W. Not sure what software they use, or whether it's off the shelf or proprietary. Any antenna designers out there? [1]: https://www.raspberrypi.org/magpi/pi-zero-w-wireless-antenna-design/ https://www.raspberrypi.org/magpi/pi-zero-w-wireless-antenna... [2]: http://mob.proant.se/en/home.htm http://mob.proant.se/en/home.htm
- jhallenworld 9y agoNEC? At it's core anyway... Comsol? You can use it for all physics.
- alias_neo 9y agoOne thing the article entirely neglects to mention is that the well engineered design came, via licensing, from an antenna specialist company called "Proant" http://www.proant.se/en/news/2017/03/01/raspberry-pi-zero-w-nbi16.htm http://www.proant.se/en/news/2017/03/01/raspberry-pi-zero-w-...
- jcrabtr 9y agoThere's a huge number of people involved in the design of the rpi. The antenna is a great example of a subsystem designed by a separate team; another is the new PMIC for the 3B+[1]. [1]: https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/pi-power-supply-chip/ https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/pi-power-supply-chip/
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoSame guys who designed the 3D antenna on the latest ESP32 dev board: http://www.proant.se/en/technology/success-stories/espressif.htm http://www.proant.se/en/technology/success-stories/espressif...
- mkesper 9y agoSomeone needs to come up with a better unit for antenna efficiency. Which non-expert can understand how much -3.5dB and -1.25dB differ?
- dingo_bat 9y agoWhich non expert needs to understand the difference in antenna efficiency?
- taneq 9y agoAnyone trying to spec parts for a network-connected gizmo?
- sannee 9y agoIf you don't understand logarithmic scales, maybe you shouldn't be specing parts for a network-connected gizmos?
- lovelearning 9y agoOut of the first 10 or so results for "wifi routers" on Amazon, atleast half of them mention antenna dBi values. What is Joe Buyer supposed to infer if one router says 5 dBi and another says 6 dBi? Is it 5 times more powerful? Is it 10 times more powerful? I've read through the Wikipedia article on antenna gain and I still can't tell for sure. Negative values are even more confusing for people. Ultimately, I think the loss is entirely that of router manufacturers because their preferred units don't help potential buyers judge which is better and by how much. They can use dBi for research and development, but customers really need something more user-friendly. It's a matter of usability.
- gh02t 9y agoTo answer your question: The gain in dBi is 10 * log10(linear gain), so the linear gain is 10^((gain in dBi) / 10). So 5 dBi is a gain of 3.16, and 6 dBi is 3.98. Log rules mean you can just subtract, so the difference is 1 dBi, meaning a 6 dBi antenna is 1.25 times more powerful than 5 dBi. I'm not sure what alternative units you could use, because log units are more natural. Joe consumer can understand "6 dBi is 1dBi better than 5 dBi," he doesn't need to know the details any more than he needs to know exactly how much faster his car will go with 10 extra horsepower. It's the relative comparison that matters (more horsepower == more speed) and using dBi makes those relative comparisons simpler.
- wintorez 9y agoI'm far more impressed by Raspberry Pi Zero W than by the original or even the latest Raspberry Pi. I'm using one as a streaming server for a security camera, and also a web server, and its working beyond my expectations.
- jhallenworld 9y agoIt's nice, but I think you can't easily buy the chips. So still no good for product design.
- michaelt 9y agoThere's a medium-sized market for processor modules like this, as they're plenty good enough for quite a few applications. For example if you need a big PCB, cheaper to make a big 2- or 4-layer PCB and put a module on it than to make your entire PCB 10 layers so you can break out a tiny BGA.
- pjc50 9y agoYou can buy it as a module, but this really isn't the Pi's intended target market. I've seen several commercial products that are just Pi-in-a-box, for small runs it's fine.
- kickout 9y agoCan you give me a brief walk through on how you accomplished this, or a resource you used to guide you? I have been interested in doing streaming security camera for a while but haven't seen a setup i like.
- wintorez 9y agoI basically followed this guide for the web camera parts: https://pimylifeup.com/raspberry-pi-webcam-server/ https://pimylifeup.com/raspberry-pi-webcam-server/ I setup my pi without keyboard and monitor (ssh only), and used this guide to set it up itself: https://www.losant.com/blog/getting-started-with-the-raspberry-pi-zero-w-without-a-monitor https://www.losant.com/blog/getting-started-with-the-raspber... Here's the list of my hardware: https://www.canakit.com/raspberry-pi-zero-wireless.html https://www.canakit.com/raspberry-pi-zero-wireless.html https://www.canakit.com/raspberry-pi-camera-v2-8mp.html https://www.canakit.com/raspberry-pi-camera-v2-8mp.html
- jhallenworld 9y agoIt's interesting to understand the frequency dependency on antenna size by studying the Friis equation. There are three cases: Small rx, small tx: low frequencies are better (lower loss). Small rx, parabolic dish tx (or reversed): frequency does not matter. Parabolic tx and rx: higher is better. Small here means something like resonant dipole, so the antenna has to be physically bigger the lower the frequency. For the case of a parabolic dish, we hold the diameter constant vs. frequency. Anyway for phones lower bands are better as long as the antenna fits.
- jeffreyrogers 9y agoAren't the higher frequency bands wider so data rates are higher?
- tonyarkles 9y agoYeah, it's a really fun set of tradeoffs to play with. You're correct to a first approximation. Channel bandwidth is is easier to come by at higher frequencies (a 20MHz wide channel at 150MHz would be a giant swath of the band, but a 20MHz channel at 5GHz is very small relative to the centre frequency). But... then you start encountering higher path loss. To make up for that, you need to increase transmitter power (whether by increasing actual power, or by using higher gain antennas, etc) or by adding redundancy to the data stream (e.g. FEC). The added redundancy chips away at your bit rate, but corrects errors. In practice, whether you get a better net transfer speed on a narrow lower-frequency band or a wider higher-frequency band is going to depend on a lot of factors. Sometimes it pans out, sometimes not.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI would really like to have access to an antenna chamber like that one :-). Lately I've been building/programming/characterizing SDRs and that generally also includes antenna. I realized I had forgotten most of what I had learned in school about electrodynamics so I've been refreshing all of those neurons as well. The simplest solvers for Antennas do a great job on dipoles or other simple structures, and less well on antennae like the one on the Pi. I found it humorous that a well used tool was called 'Microwave office'[1]. I tried to do some genetic antenna design using a plotter, some conductive ink, and a simple S meter but it is really difficult to reliably connect the plotted antenna to the test fixture. What I have learned, which matches the author, is that there is a lot of subtlety in antenna design that is not obvious by the traces they use on FR-4 or other substrates. That rabbit hole goes pretty far down. [1] http://www.awrcorp.com/products/ni-awr-design-environment/microwave-office http://www.awrcorp.com/products/ni-awr-design-environment/mi...
- barbegal 9y agoTypically you'd use a ceramic antenna on a product like this. What is the difference in radiated efficiency between this antenna and a ceramic one? I'm guessing there are other design considerations though, such as cost and circuit board area consumed.
- zokier 9y agoWithout comparison to other typical PCB and/or ceramic antennas, it is pretty difficult to judge from the article how good the RPiW antenna truly is.
- boznz 9y agoWhat is it with buying an RPi zero? It has been out for a few years now but is never in stock anywhere for the advertised price of $5 ,it's sometimes available bundled with loads of crap you dont need for 10x this price, also you cant buy a qty of more than one anywhere. If they've stuffed up the pricing and trying to reduce their exposure I am pretty sure a lot of people would be happy paying $10 instead. I'm pretty sure there are more Tesla Model 3's being produced than Raspberry Pi Zeros :-)
- StudentStuff 9y agoIts definitely a loss leader with very limited availability, but thankfully it did spur a wave of sub-$10 single board computers, most of which are on par with much more powerful Raspis. http://linuxgizmos.com/worlds-smallest-quad-core-sbc-starts-at-8-dollars/ http://linuxgizmos.com/worlds-smallest-quad-core-sbc-starts-...
- flyinghamster 9y agoMy local Micro Center usually has them in stock, but there's a quantity price penalty if you buy more than one, and the more you buy, the greater the penalty.
- gormz 9y agoMy brother works for their main distributor. He always says the day they get them in stock, they go out of stock. Demand is crazy for the things.
- jmblock2 9y agoThe ceramic chip antenna manufacturers are in a panic!