7 ms·
Mac OS X Public Beta
- thought_alarm 16y agoShadows? Transparency? Compositing Window Manager? It'll never catch on. People don't want that stuff.
- someone_here 16y agoPeople still say that about Compiz!
- thought_alarm 16y agoPeople still use Windows XP.
- patrickaljord 16y agoPeople still use Windows 98.
- beaumartinez 16y agoPeople still use Windows 3.1, but that's not the point: A relevant proportion of the population still uses Windows XP (businesses, universities...). Although I remember seeing an old Windows 98 box in my JCR's office... With a 800x600 CRT monitor stretched to a 1024x768 resolution. It made your eyes bleed.
- ianferrel 16y agoI still use Windows XP. I use OS X for everything I can, but I keep it around because I need compatibility with Windows-only stuff. I'm really glad that there's still a bunch of people on XP; it means that I don't have to bother upgrading, because anyone who targets Windows has to support XP. Sure, it's old and clunky, but that's what it's for: to run programs that are old and clunky.
- danudey 16y agoCompiz copies the effects present in OS X (and Windows 7), but they seem to ignore the reasons behind them. Mac OS uses the 'shrinking window' effect to show you where your window has gone, and drop-shadows to give you a sense of depth. Translucency in menus gives a subtle feeling of impermanence, and subtle transparency emulates the effect of paper-on-paper, where you can kind of, but not quite, make out the letters on the page below the one you're viewing. Compiz, however, seems to be based on the philosophy of 'Now that windows are textures, we can do arbitrary transforms on them' and throws in a lot of effects that make little sense. Menus that wobble into place, windows that behave like they're made of Jell-O, and so on. They're neat conceptually, but I tired ages ago of people pointing out how Linux was better because I could configure my windows to burn up in a puff of smoke whenever I closed them.
- Pengwin 16y agoCompiz does make usability of Gnome on Ubuntu better. Super-E (which displays workspaces overview) and Super-W (a clone of OSX expose) for starters. The added workspace switcher animation when switching to left and right is nice to show you which workspace you are transferring to. Sure a lot of the stuff Compiz is silly. Granted that wobbly windows is a wow factor thing, but why not? its the little nice touches that keep peoples interest in things, and makes it an enjoyable experience.
- someone_here 16y agoCompiz actually had all the Windows 7 effects before Windows 7 even came out.
- mdasen 16y agoWow, that takes me back. I remember installing it on my G3/300MHz. It was so slow. That really can't be over-emphasized. I'd try all sorts of things to get more speed like turning off the dock bounce, running prelinking, messing with all sorts of hidden settings. It remained slow. Having been an Apple customer since the Apple IIc, I was worried. OS 9 had a snappiness to it. OS X would struggle to change windows. At the time, Windows 98 and even moreso Windows NT could run circles around OS X. With XP dropping the same year, Windows consumers were running a really well optimized OS compared to an OS X that needed a lot of work. Apple has come a long way since those dark times to having a truly enviable OS. They quickly got 10.1 out the door and 10.2 and 10.3 shipped in around 1-year increments (with 10.4 shipping a year and a half after 10.3). Apple really did a lot of work and, at this point, I don't think anyone questions Apple's ability to push a great OS, but there were some really bad times. I remember people questioning whether it was that the Mach kernel was just inherently slow (igniting lots of micro vs monolithic debates) or whether the compositing window manager was worth anything or coming up with theories that it was because Apple replaced Display PostScript with Display PDF to get around Adobe licensing or whatnot. Today, the majority of Mac users probably never experienced that bad time of trepidation when the future of the Mac platform was in doubt. Today, it's really great to be a Mac user. It's hard to imagine a time when Apple's products were so fringe. At nearly 10% of the market (and nearly all of the premium market), Apple feels so strong and people really know Apple (both for computers and other devices). Kudos to Apple for taking the risk and getting through the bad transition to what is a really wonderful OS. And kudos for making each new OS version feel better than the previous.
- danilocampos 16y agoGreat retrospective. Change was, indeed, scary. I was so scared of OS X, I stuck around on OS 9 until, I think 10.2. I might have stayed longer but my G3/266 (with AV personality card!) ended up biting the dust. The G4 that replaced it shipped with OS X and I took the plunge. It was tough, at first. At that point I'd been a Mac user for ten years. I was a power user. OS X made me a newb again. It was all for the best. OS X has been perfect for both home and work use. In the end, I give it so much less thought than what System 6 - Mac OS 9 required. It stays out of the way and just lets me work. In addition, Apple gave developers a boatload of APIs and UI classes that let you build a surprisingly solid app with minimal effort. I cranked out a little desktop app a few weeks ago in about 25 hours. This results in an amazing freeware and shareware scene. What a long way to come, for Apple and for all of us.
- protomyth 16y agogotta love 1.5GB being described as unlimited memory
- orangecat 16y agoAnd storage for only $5 per GB!
- petercooper 16y agoHow the distracting pin stripes in OS X up until 10.3 (when they were made significantly lower contrast, before they faded away in 10.5) got past any UI experts or even Steve Jobs is beyond me. I'm an ardent OS X user now but I'm surprised to still hold my 2000/2001 Windows user opinion of "eugh, the new Mac OS looks horrible!"
- pohl 16y agoI didn't use Windows back then. Could somebody post a screenshot of what it would have looked like in the same year?
- pmjordan 16y agohttp://www.google.com/images?q=windows+2000+screenshot http://www.google.com/images?q=windows+2000+screenshot although I suppose most people were still using Windows Me, the last DOS-based Windows, rather than Windows 2000, which descended from NT. They looked pretty similar, though: http://www.google.com/images?q=windows+me+screenshot http://www.google.com/images?q=windows+me+screenshot Windows XP was released a year later and was the first release to unify the workstation and desktop lines on the same foundation (with the Home & Professional variants).
- petercooper 16y agohttp://www.granneman.com/images/windows_2000_screenshot.gif http://www.granneman.com/images/windows_2000_screenshot.gif was quite representative of what I was using in 2000/2001. I'm a foaming-at-the-mouth OS X fan now, but I still find Windows 2000 more palatable as a day-to-day sort of UI compared to the first few releases of OS X. At the time, Windows beat OS X in some areas that are no longer important.. like very easy to resize windows and more consistent minimize/maximize behavior, all of which are less important in a high resolution world.
- modeless 16y agoI still think Windows is significantly better in the window management department. Exposé is nice, but Windows 7's mouse gestures for maximize/restore are just brilliant, I prefer the taskbar to the dock, and the top menu is a liability now that many apps are ditching menu bars altogether.
- dasil003 16y agoI remember buying my first Mac in a decade when this was announced. Microsoft practically drove me into Apple's arms when I tried to install Internet Explorer 6 and it hosed the boot sector on my HD, and I didn't have a CD-ROM driver for the restore disk that came with my machine. I had to spend 3 hours reinstalling from Win 95 floppies, and then upgrading the OS. To say that experience made any hiccups with the OS X Public Beta seem tolerable would be a vast understatement.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoThings today's Apple fans won't let their competitors get away with (possibly because they didn't live through this): "beta" A name that needs an explanatory paragraph to pronounce correctly and doesn't really make logical sense. Sound technical foundations that run slow on today's hardware. Having two OSes and a transition strategy. Crazy UI like pinstripes and brushed metal. Letting the Unix/Next underpinnings shine through the gaps in the UI shell.
- protomyth 16y agoLooking back, I do wish they had kept some of the UI elements from OpenStep / NEXTstep. I liked the dock on the right side (without all the desktop crud), the Workspace Manager was nicer than Finder, and the NeXT menu bar works better on bigger monitors than the Apple bar. A modern version of the Librarian.app is what I miss most. It would have been so much nicer if that had been kept and expanded to include music, movies, etc.
- rbanffy 16y ago> and the NeXT menu bar works better on bigger monitors than the Apple bar. Still, it would be annoying to find it when you have three 30 inch screens... The menu bar right on the window containing the data it's supposed to operate on is still a better solution.
- protomyth 16y agoNah, it was a pretty easy thing to find and the ability to tear off stuff was perfect. The vertical stack with left to right menu / submenu selection gave it a really nice feel. I have never gotten that feel from a horizontal starting bar.
- rbanffy 16y agoIt was pretty easy to find on a 17" screen. I agree it's a better solution than the fixed menu bar at the top, but that doesn't make it easy to find if your program is on 30" screen #1 and its menu is on 30" screen #2. You can give it a try with the GNUStep apps that come with modern Linuxes.
- iuguy 16y agoI left the Mac behind after OS 8.1 on a Quadra. 8.5 was too slow (but very nice) but 9 just seemed to be a step backwards. I also didn't like the transition from 68k to PPC on Mac. I never did it on Amiga either. When I first saw OSX I thought it was ugly and slow compared to Windows 2000, although it looked better than RedHat, which was my main OS at the time. I didn't like OSX for a really long, long time. In fact I still don't trust it. Yes it's a nice desktop OS for end users and I'm typing this from a Mac Mini hooked up to my TV, but it still has it's quirks and sometimes just doesn't feel 'right'. Having said that, a lot of what used to distinguish OSes (UI paradigms, available software, hardware architecture) has either fizzled out or become less relevant, so each to their own I guess. Mind you, I live in a house with everything from AROS to Windows in terms of popular OSes.
- blahedo 16y agoFrom p. 14: > The Bad: Continued > 6. The new Finder defeats spatial orientation. Et plus ça change, ...