> I posted about Whittaker … not because I thought OP was making a serious scientific claim to which I had contradictory evidence > This hypothesis is somewhat

> I posted about Whittaker … not because I thought OP was making a serious scientific claim to which I had contradictory evidence > This hypothesis is somewhat contradicted by the experience of Jack Whittaker[0] You may not have meant it that way, but I can see how your response can be taken that way