4 ms·
> Most people don't real care about money, they just need it to buy status symbols with. I'm pretty sure you have the causality backwards here. Status symbols
by andrewflnr 9y ago
> Most people don't real care about money, they just need it to buy status symbols with.
I'm pretty sure you have the causality backwards here. Status symbols exist to show off that you have money. If someone shows off status symbols but everyone knows they don't actually have money, they'll be seen as a poser, not a clever social hacker.
- sjwright 9y agoThat doesn't seem right to me? Status symbols exist to show off that you have status. If someone shows off status symbols they apparently couldn't afford, the key effect is dilution of the symbol's utility for signalling wealth. (Hundreds of years ago, important signals would be clean skin, clothes and hair. Not to mention your accent, language proficiency and general knowledge. Today these are mostly affordable commodities.)
- andrewflnr 9y agoYes, that's why people hate posers.
- desu_ 9y agoThis has been posted here before but it seems relevant (about explaining the lower Japanese salaries vs US, https://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan...): “Most people want to become wealthy so they can consume social status. Japanese employers believe this is inefficient, and simply award social status directly.” The best employees aren’t compensated with large option grants or eye popping bonuses — they’re simply anointed as “princes”, given their pick of projects to work on, receive plum assignments, and get their status acknowledged (in ways great and small) by the other employees. Regarding the causality, I disagree with you andrewflnr. For instance, jewelry is older than money and there are even statuses in nonhuman circles. I admit that it's debatable, but I think the value of money comes from the power it gives (you buy other people's time and stuff) but status can do the same and has a more permanent feel (it doesn't deplete linearly, unlike money spent). That's why in some communities, the local priest / doctor teacher is still considered more important than wealthier merchants / land owners. That's why Trump is more powerful than many wealthier billionaires.
- sbov 9y agoAnd yet sometimes, having no status symbols shows you have more money and power than everyone in the room.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThat's countersignalling. "I have so much wealth/power and feel so comfortable with it that I need not prove it to anyone, unlike those nouveau riche out there".
- chillacy 9y agoYou can have plenty of status without money. The headmaster at his martial arts studio has more status than a white belt, even if the white belt is loaded. Status is of course situational, ever-changing, and tremendous fun to watch. In Impro, Keith Johnstone talks about status being the most important thing actors add to make their scenes instantly "life-like". Status is everywhere in our lives yet most of us ignore it--we know it happens but we don't like to think about it. It's only when you try to recreate life on the stage that you realize, oh shoot, people are all about status.
- Pamar 9y agoCan you please explain more about the actor’s job according to Intro? It looks very interesting.
- mbrock 9y ago> "Try to get your status just a little above or below your partner's," I said, and I insisted that the gap should be minimal. The actors seemed to know exactly what I meant and the work was transformed. The scenes became "authentic," and actors seemed marvellously observant. Suddenly we understood that every inflection and movement implies a status, and that no action is due to chance, or really "motiveless." It was hysterically funny, but at the same time very alarming. All our secret manouverings were exposed. If someone asked a question we didn't bother to answer it, we concentrated on why it had been asked. No one could make an "innocuous" remark without everyone instantly grasping what lay behind it. Normally we are "forbidden" to see status transactions except when there's a conflict. In reality status transactions continue all the time. In the park we'll notice the ducks squabbling, but not how carefully they keep their distances when they are not.
- Pamar 9y agoThanks! This is really great. I will try to find more about this so if you have anything else to suggest apart from the original reference please share.
- dmitriid 9y ago"New money" can rarely get the status of "old money" even if "old money" has no money.