5 ms·
Maybe the missing feature here is that GitHub should "just" automatically minimize +1 comments. Or even better, delete them without sending a notification to ma
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
Maybe the missing feature here is that GitHub should "just" automatically minimize +1 comments. Or even better, delete them without sending a notification to maintainers/watchers, and automagically have the user who posted it add a thumbs up to the original issue.
(Personally, I would consider them spam.)
- reificator 9y agoI think they were valuable back when you couldn't react to a specific comment. I also think they're still valuable when you have Github and another VCS host, where one mirrors the other automatically.
- joshfriend 9y ago> automagically have the user who posted it add a thumbs up to the original issue. I was astonished that they didn't do this when they introduced the emoji reactions feature.
- michaelmior 9y agoPart of the problem is deciding what the +1 should be attached to. Some people comment +1 just because they want to see a PR merged. Some +1s are intended to be associated with a specific comment.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoBut there's other systems for that; what you're describing are 'bumps' that have been in forums and such for forever now, and I'm sure that e.g. an upvote system (or sort by +1 reactions) would replace that system. I think it could be done on a per repository basis, like, basic behaviour rules just like at forums and other such communities. It's then up to the maintainer / moderators / whatever to allow or disallow +1-style comments, and what the 'punishment' would be. They could then also tweak a setting that auto hides comments if they're shorter than X characters.
- tuespetre 9y agoYou can sort by reactions on the issues list, if that’s what you meant.
- craftyguy 9y ago> Or even better Well then the user would learn nothing. A better solution would be to notify them that this is wrong, delete their comment, and then prevent them from commenting on github.com for a period of time (1 hour? or more?)