3 ms·
"Now he claims to want to make the world a more open and honest place. Why would making all this information about yourself public make the world a better place
by philwelch 16y ago
"Now he claims to want to make the world a more open and honest place. Why would making all this information about yourself public make the world a better place? We've spent thousands of years developing social protocols for how and what we reveal to others about ourselves, our families and our friends. Now we should just forgo all that because some guy thinks that would somehow make the world a better place?"
That's not an argument against Zuckerberg, it's a fully general argument against any social change. You have discovered the Fully General Social Conservative Argument. It wouldn't take much work to adapt your argument to critique the birth control pill or desegregation (at least before they each became a fait accompli[1]).
(The rest of your post questions Zuckerberg's motives, which is not of interest to me so I'm not addressing it.)
[1] (Edit) At this point, social conservatives have to argue that the change, which has already happened, hurt society. Segregation is too taboo to argue for anymore, but you'll still find some committed social conservatives still resisting the Pill, the Catholic Church for instance. If the world really becomes more open and transparent, we'll have at least a generation of pro-privacy social conservatives saying the world is going to hell because your uncle isn't keeping his leather fetish a closely guarded secret anymore.
- yequalsx 16y agoI would distinguish between incremental change and radical change. Yes, it's in the eye of the beholder. The loss of privacy is a radical change from the past for those who live in cities. (Privacy is a different beast in a village life.) The argument the OP presented is general but applies to radical changes and I think it applies to Facebook and Zuckerberg. Is this change in privacy a good thing or a bad thing? I don't know. Is Facebook (and Zuckerberg) the right agent to bring this change about - definitely not in my mind.
- philwelch 16y agoWas a eugenicist who favored compulsory sterilization the right agent to bring about social acceptance of contraception? [1] It's a misguided question--changes like this happen for reasons much bigger than one individual, movement, or corporation, or any ulterior motives they may have. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Sanger#Eugenics_and_euthanasia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Sanger#Eugenics_and_eu...
- yequalsx 16y agoApparently yes. At the time I would probably say no. It depends on the argument being presented and not on who is presenting it. Though the messenger often times becomes the focus of the debate. In the case of Zuckerburg I don't trust his motives and - here's the rub - he's in a position to abuse trust. Now if a dictator is in favor of eugenics and starts talking about increasing contraception one might reasonably fear what comes next. When someone is not in a position to takes things to the next level then their ulterior motives are not relevant.
- loewenskind 16y ago>You have discovered the Fully General Social Conservative Argument. I'm not arguing against any change. I'm questioning the validity of Zuckerberg's claim that he just wants to make the world a better place. Anyone should want to change the world and make it a better place, but to do that we need to investigate what would actually make things better. Zuckerberg offers no reasoning as to why giving up all privacy would make anything even slightly better. I don't personally see how this would intuitively make the world a better place, but I do see very clearly how it would benefit Zuckerberg personally.