5 ms·
MakerDAO's DAI coin (currently collateralized by ETH) has already proven quite stable in the face of several black swan events and the price of Ethereum crashin
by chrisco255 9y ago
MakerDAO's DAI coin (currently collateralized by ETH) has already proven quite stable in the face of several black swan events and the price of Ethereum crashing nearly 70% over the past couple of months. They're in the process of adding more assets to back the currency to improve stability. The supply is capped by a debt ceiling. There are sound principles behind the currency, and it being an ERC20 token, it's got all the advantages of being pluggable into the ETH ecosystem.
It's not a bad idea, it's actually a great idea and if DAI or BaseCoin turns out to be stable-ish over the long term, then it will be incredibly useful for the crypto ecosystem. Honestly, even if DAI fluctuates a few pennies here and there, if it's stable-ish it will be useful for a wide variety of services and applications.
- klochner 9y agoFrom the DAI site: > If the value of ether held as collateral is worth less than the amount > of Dai it’s supposed to be backing, then Dai would not be worth one dollar > and the system could collapse. > Maker combats this by liquidating CDPs and auctioning off the ether inside before the > value of the ether is less than the amount of Dai it is backing. Note combats not prevents, it will go to zero with probability 1 [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambler%27s_ruin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambler%27s_ruin
- ajiang 9y agoI think the defense of "nothing has happened yet" is a tough one to back, in particular given that during the build up to the last recession, 1) collateralized debt was claimed by wall street to be "as good as cash" and 2) the housing market would "always go up". It works until it doesn't.
- chrisco255 9y agoDAI is set up so that it's not dependent on ETH always going up. People create DAI by locking up ETH (or in the future, other assets) as collateral. Currently for ETH, you have to lock up 150% of the value that you take out in DAI (but you can collateralize higher than that if you like). If the price of ETH falls below a certain value, then a position can be liquidated automatically by the system, to cover the position. DAI has a goal of adding additional forms of collateral in the future. One could see a coin like DAI being backed by a mix of Gold, real estate, commodities, or securities to achieve greater stability.
- drcode 9y agoDAI coin is just diversifying risk by using multiple underlying assets- So instead of a 10% chance of the value dropping 90% due to a failure of an asset guarantor, it will just have a 90% chance of dropping 10% in value. The MakerDAO organization can likely cover this 10% loss in asset value by using their enormous capital, but this is not a sustainable strategy for creating a stable synthetic asset. I think sustainable synthetic blockchain assets are possible, but they will always have complicated risk/reward profiles that won't fully mirror the underlying asset they are designed to model: The dream of a truly "synthetic dollar" will always remain a dream. EDIT: I should clarify that I think DAI coin may still be a useful construct for some situations, but it's going to be an asset with very different properties compared to any target real-world asset.
- zdkl 9y ago>this is not a sustainable strategy for creating a stable synthetic asset Could you give some pointers for further reading on the subject please?
- drcode 9y agoThere's not really much reading on this- You simply can't take 10 assets that are worth less than $1 individually (because of guarantor risk) and mix them together to create an asset that's pegged at exactly $1- This is not a problem that can be solved by "diversification". For other history on synthetic assets, read Preston's posts and also Vitalik's posts such as https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/03/28/schellingcoin-a-minimal-trust-universal-data-feed/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/03/28/schellingcoin-a-minimal...
- chrisco255 9y agoMakerDAO's system over-collateralizes on DAI. Currently, it takes at least $1.50 of ETH to create $1 of DAI. This is based on the volatility and risk profile of ETH. These parameters are adjustable by MakerDAO token holders. Suppose they added gold to the asset basket where 50% of DAI was backed by gold and 50% was backed by ETH. They could require 125% position on gold and 150% position on ETH. In this case, 50% of the supply of DAI would be subject to the whims of ETH price while 50% would depend on gold. If gold or ETH were both to drop to near zero at nearly the same time so rapidly that the CDPs could not be liquidated in time, then the system would be at risk. Seeing as how Gold and ETH are not correlated, this is an unlikely event. Adding 8 more uncorrelated assets to the protocol would only further improve the stability of the system.
- hashsalt 9y agoThe issue is that it is uneconomical. Collateral is set at 4-5x. The market for people who want to make that trade is limited.
- DennisP 9y agoI know people who do it. They expect a long-term rise in ETH value, but they want to spend some money now without paying capital gains. They use Maker to essentially take a loan out on their ETH collateral. (And yes, they talked with their tax advisors.)
- hashsalt 9y agoThats exactly what I had in mind. A reasonably intelligent trader doesnt want to make his operation more capital intensive however. Has use cases, but limited.
- TD-Linux 9y agoThe author of the OP has an article about DAI too: https://prestonbyrne.com/2018/01/11/epicaricacy/ https://prestonbyrne.com/2018/01/11/epicaricacy/ Doesn't seem so hot to me, and what happens when the bot runs out of capital?
- zodiac 9y agoHe has a weird definition of "break". At no point did the value of collateralized ether backing each DAI go below $1 or even anywhere close to that. There are valid arguments to be made against a DAI-like system like capital inefficiency, the appropriateness of the bounded volatility assumptions, and maybe sell spirals, but Preston Byrne's articles include a lot of invalid arguments.
- hashsalt 9y agoThats precisely his point. Contagion causes the break. Analogous to a bank run or the ruinous fall of the Thai baht in 97/98. Nobody has any real info on whether the bank has enough reserves, nor do they care. They just dont want to hold the asset.
- chrisco255 9y agoIn this case, they do. DAI's system is run entirely on the blockchain. It's auditable and decentralized. The biggest risk to DAI is if the value of the collateral crashed below the amount of DAI in circulation. The system has incentives in place to prevent this from happening. I'm not saying it's bullet proof, but I think it's a highly resilient system. I think adding multiple types of collateral should protect against the situation where ETH drops rapidly to near zero.
- hashsalt 9y agoBank eg was an analogy. The issue is contagion, which can be external in source.
- zodiac 9y ago
- thesausageking 9y ago> several black swan events That word doesn't mean what you think it does. Nothing that's happened since it launched is that unexpected.
- iMuzz 9y agoCouldn't agree more.
- thisisit 9y ago> MakerDAO's DAI coin (currently collateralized by ETH) has already proven quite stable in the face of several black swan events and the price of Ethereum crashing nearly 70% over the past couple of months. That is an interesting claim. What were these black swan events which DAI passed with flying colors?
- chrisco255 9y agoI would argue the value of ETH (the asset that backs DAI) crashing from nearly $1400 a couple months ago to a low of almost $350 a few weeks ago is pretty strong. What other asset has these sort of swings in such a low amount of time? The fact that the collateral backing DAI has dipped and yet DAI has remained stable is a testament to the systems underlying it. What could kill DAI would be ETH crashing to near zero rapidly.
- thisisit 9y agoYou could argue that. And that is a good point. But it is simply price swings or volatility. The job of the stable coin is to be stable during periods of volatility, even high one as that. A black swan event is the one you pointed out about ETH crashing to zero. And there were none yet.
- seibelj 9y agoThe crypto hate on HN is enormous, and someone who evaluates MakerDAO for 15 minutes will speak authoritatively over its inevitable failure. The core thing to realize about Maker is that all Maker does is loan Dai against an asset! It's collateralized. Ethereum may be risky to use as collateral, but something like Digix, where tokens are issued one-to-one with gold stored in a vault, means that you are now issuing Dai against a real asset (gold). If you think Maker will fail, you are arguing that the value of the asset backing Maker will fall.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Digix, where tokens are issued one-to-one with gold stored in a vault, means that you are now issuing Dai against a real asset (gold) Marketable collateral is an old idea, and suffers certain intrinsic difficulties. One is counterparty risk. Here we have at least three trust points: the place(s) the gold is physically held, Maker and the mechanism by which one holds Digix. The classic case: Maker lies about the amount of gold in the vault (or steals the gold). Less classic case: the person holding the gold does the same. More realistic case: someone in this chain runs into financial difficulties, or messes up their AML or sanctions compliance program, and has their assets frozen and/or seized by some authority somewhere in the world.
- seibelj 9y agoOnce you have possession of a gold token, no one can stop you from trading it, because of the blockchain. Converting your gold token into gold and having it shipped to you may be problematic, but once you have the gold token, it's transferrable. Maker is decentralized, the problem there would be a bug in the smart contract. And Digix being a failure / scam, that is indeed a failure point. But what MakerDAO and Dai represents is not some "magic blockchain thinking", it is based on rational economic incentives.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Converting your gold token into gold and having it shipped to you may be problematic, but once you have the gold token, it's transferrable "I want to sell you this gold token. You can't convert it to gold, because the gold was all stolen."