2 ms·
To eliminate what such questions? To eliminate any questions about social context or bias or agenda? Totally not possible, social context is an inherent part
by jrochkind1 9y ago
To eliminate what such questions?
To eliminate any questions about social context or bias or agenda? Totally not possible, social context is an inherent part of science, as in all human endeavors.
I think the purpose of reproducibility is to well, make science _possible_, it is the fundamental bedrock of science -- to determine what and how we can make reliable predictions about the world. It doesn't mean bias and effects of social context no longer exists though. Science exists anyway, in a social context -- as evidenced by the past couple hundred years!
In general, I don't think science exists to eliminate _any_ questions, science exists to ask questions. Eliminating questions may be a goal of ideology or religion, but not science. (and in the real world, they certainly influence each other. science is a goal to strive for, not a fait accompli. Scientific understandings of the world are always changing; science is an approach to understanding the world, not a set of settled conclusions).
- jrochkind1 9y agoAlso, if we're looking for the social context that leads to the reproducibility crisis, I think it's a lot more likely to be about academic career incentives (you _gotta_ publish things, a lot of things, that all seem like important and socially useful results, none of which are negative results -- when the actual practice of science means negative results are an expected and useful thing, not indication you are a bad scientist), than the political ideologies/biases of researchers. Maybe I'm wrong. There are probably ways to investigate it. This essay isn't one of them.