5 ms·
It's an odd analogy. Musicians frequently advance by learning multiple instruments and genres. Your drums example is good, and there are lots more. Piano's a ve
by jkoudys 9y ago
It's an odd analogy. Musicians frequently advance by learning multiple instruments and genres. Your drums example is good, and there are lots more. Piano's a very common instrument to start with, because it teaches you a bit of everything: rhythm, melody, harmony, coordination, sight reading, and leads easily into learning music theory, and musicians on all instruments often have a piano background. I don't know a single concert violinist that isn't at least competent at strumming out a few chords on an acoustic guitar. Woodwinds players often follow a path of increasingly difficult embouchures, e.g. recorder -> flute -> oboe.
And learning varied "easy" pieces is exactly how anyone practising one instrument advances! The whole grades system used by the RCM is founded on that idea. What's "easy" to you at the time increases slowly with practice, but you learn a variety of pieces in a variety of genres that's at the level you're currently comfortable with.
If someone's going to pick an analogy, they should make sure it doesn't support the exact opposite of the point they're trying to make.
- V-2 9y agoLet's say chess players don't get to top level by playing checkers or Go ;) Actually some grandmasters do, eg. Ivanchuk does play checkers and Morozevich does play Go - and it may have mildly beneficial effect, broadening your horizons etc. - but it's not the primary training you need
- AstralStorm 9y agoThat is because unlike programming, chess nowadays does not utilize too many general skills. Good positional play for instance won't help you enough against an opponent who has memorized many patterns. This is why it was so easily tackled by computers compared to Go or more complex grand strategy games. Programming is much closer to grand strategy than to rote pattern memorization, though there are patterns to be recognized in it. Likewise performing music is a much broader subject than say just moving the pick across strings to a remembered melody. Even more so, composition.