5 ms·
So on one hand you have people happy with the neighborhood they live in and not wanting change; on the other hand you have people not happy and wanting change.
by majormajor 9y ago
So on one hand you have people happy with the neighborhood they live in and not wanting change; on the other hand you have people not happy and wanting change.
Why is one group more "horribly selfish" than the other? Especially if you think there's a bubble, you don't want to change the character of the place for a short-term problem.
Why is "build more in one place" a more natural answer than "let tech companies geographically diversify themselves in response to pricing pressure"? Especially given an area that's kind of a natural disaster SPOF.
- epistasis 9y agoBecause the same people that complain about new people were once new people. Also, they do not get the right to decide where people live. That's fundamentally entitled, selfish, and greedy attitude. And since they don't get to control where people move in the United States, they don't actually get to stop change. Change still happens whether they want it or not. Nobody has the right to stop others from interacting, or renting, or anything like that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- biocomputation 9y ago>> Also, they do not get the right to decide where people live. That's fundamentally entitled, selfish, and greedy attitude. Oh but new people do that all the time.
- epistasis 9y agoI think that sentence would have been a lot clearer if I had not omitted the word "other" "Also, they do not get the right to decide other where people live." Otherwise, everybody gets to choose on their own where they live, and that is a freedom that I am absolutely loathe to restrict.
- rofrol 9y ago>everybody gets to choose on their own where they live Why only this? Let's allow people to do everything they want. /s Why can't some group of people, living in some area, set what are some rules that should be respected by all members? BTW. We have too many humans on Earth which causes a global warming.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoYour argument here might have some contradictions. It boils down to the fact that people don't get to force others to behave in a certain way, and I completely agree with you. But then you then use that to argue that therefore people should be able to force others to behave in a certain way. You know? As we don't live in an authoritarian state and we respect individuals' rights, we tend to rely on the market to provide the most fairness. The reason for this is that the market is effectively a democratization of pricing. I don't think it takes a huge degree of empathy to see how some group believe that an individual that believes they should be able to break this democratization of price to force others to enable them to reside wherever they want is what could be called entitled, selfish, and greedy.
- epistasis 9y ago> But then you then use that to argue that therefore people should be able to force others to behave in a certain way. You know? I'm not sure how I'm arguing to be able to force others to behave in certain way. I'm against some people being able to punch others; so in that sort of sense, I'm for that sort of controlling others' behavior. But this is no paradox, it's fundamental about what sort of control we're exerting on others. Is it to increase all our freedom and letting us interact more? Or are we restricting people's behavior to prevent overall freedom? When a cartel forms, and controls the market, is that regular market behavior? It's certainly to the cartel's benefit, and it's most certainly the natural thing for a cartel to act in its own self interest. But we outlaw that in markets, because they overall greatly restrict markets from operating. I'm hugely hesitant to view everything from the point of view of markets, but if we were to do that, it's clear that local municipalities are acting as housing cartels on the behalf of a minority of the residents of a community. It's landowners highly constraining the use of land such they benefit and restrict the rest of the market from using land in ways that the cartel disapproves of (for example, multi-unit apartments).
- rofrol 9y ago> increase all our freedom Not "all our" but of certain group. "your freedom ends where my freedom begins"
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> So on one hand you have people happy with the neighborhood they live in and not wanting change; on the other hand you have people not happy and wanting change I disagree with you, but I'm upvoting because (a) you politely expressed a reasonable thought and (b) I can't think of a succinct counter to your argument, and hope by elevating it someone else will. (If not, I have something deeper to think about.)
- oppositelock 9y agoYou have to react to the state of the world today, not some unknown future state. The Bay Area is very successful financially with tech, biotech, and finance jobs. People from all over the country and world are coming here. We need housing for them. Basically, we can choose between two sets of problems, the problems of increased density, or the problems of gentrification. Yes, there is some amount of subjectivity here, and I clearly prefer the problems of higher density, but living here, I see a lot of very bad effects of gentrification. Service industry people have massive commutes from far away, yet we're dependent on their services, but we don't want to make housing affordable to make their lives better because we don't want change. We prioritize saving three big trees [1] over development, for example. What is really disheartening is people saying, as you do, that we should drive tech away in some capacity. I've lived in the rust belt, in areas of low housing cost due to industrial decline, I really would hate to see that here, it's horrible. [1] https://www.mv-voice.com/news/2017/12/22/downtown-residents-rally-to-save-neighborhood-redwoods https://www.mv-voice.com/news/2017/12/22/downtown-residents-...
- oppositelock 9y agoOh, and one more thing - I'm glad that SB 827 died, despite being pro-housing. This is fundamentally a local decisions, it's just that the locals are being unreasonable. Whenever the state imposes a one-size-fits-all policy, you end up with different problems. San Jose, for example, is building housing like crazy, and tech companies are already building campuses near the new housing, as even Google employees can't afford to buy in Mountain View today. Basic 3 bed / 2 bath houses on < 6,000 ft lots go for over $2.5M in Mountain View. Owner condos are non-existent, rents are on par with Manhattan, but we don't have public transit to move people out into the boroughs. It's not a good situation. I'm lucky because I've been here since the 90's, but today, I'd be forced to leave the bay area given my income level.
- jcoffland 9y ago> San Jose, for example, is building housing like crazy And they have ruined what used to be beautiful farm land and orchards to create ugly urban sprawl punctuated by strip malls and plagued by violent crime. There's a very good reason San Jose, not San Francisco, was the site of the first major European settlement on the West Coast. Aside from having fantastic weather year round, San Jose was once beautiful. Few would argue that now. I know people need jobs and housing but unrestrained urban sprawl is a terrible solution to that problem.
- mozumder 9y agoThis is a question I have as well. Does everyone deserve to live in a place like SF or mid-town Manhattan for cheap, by forcing infinite housing supply? Or is it ok to price people out of areas, creating different classes of people & forcing certain classes of people to migrate to places like Ohio (or Mexico)? Unfortunately, the people that are going to be ruined are the poor that currently live in the expensive places.
- epistasis 9y ago>Does everyone deserve to live in a place like SF or mid-town Manhattan for cheap, by forcing infinite housing supply? This does not reflect anybody's position on the pro-housing side. Extreme exaggerations like "infinite" or "everyone deserving to live" do not facilitate conversations. Saying that more housing should be built is not saying infinite. The idea that all workers in an economy should be able to afford their housing is not saying everybody should get to live in the most expensive place. It may not be intentional but it seems like these statements were meant to take discussion off the rails.
- mozumder 9y ago> The idea that all workers in an economy should be able to afford their housing is not saying everybody should get to live in the most expensive place. But this is exactly what's happening. Look at the discussion here, and you'll see people pushing for high-rises. Should high-rises be placed wherever there's demand? Or is it OK to say no and limit people?
- epistasis 9y agoThere's a huge difference between saying the limit should be changed and also that there should be no limits at all. I do know that the current limit is not working. We should change it somehow. Any move towards more housing will at least help. But this feels like a very false argument, like those who argue against a carbon tax or other Pigovian taxes that correct negative externalities. Sure, we may not know a priori what the best possible setting of the parameter is, but there's a huge range better settings out there, and it would be really hard to get it wrong if we take a single step in one direction. I don't see anybody arguing for high rises. I see some people mentioning Tokyo, but that's not all high rises. This bill was about low rises. And even building some high rises somewhere is not a terrible thing. Just because somebody mentions the possibility do we need to circle the wagons and stop all multi-unit buildings from going up?
- zkms 9y ago> Why is "build more in one place" a more natural answer than "let tech companies geographically diversify themselves in response to pricing pressure"? Because USian land use laws / zoning laws (that enshrine single-family houses while prohibiting/obstructing the construction of most everything else) aren't good at all, and there's no good reason to preserve them as they are, nor any reason to think that they're optimal for anything; except for increasing the value of single-family homes by rigorously prohibiting the construction of alternatives. Even "tradition" doesn't apply here, since the changes that prohibit high-rise/high-density/SROish housing are quite recent compared to the history of US cities. It's really not about "tech companies", it's more about the fact that US jurisdictions have systematically eliminated and prohibited entire categories of housing. > you don't want to change the character of the place for a short-term problem I do want to change the character of the place, and I think that objections (aesthetic or otherwise) to any kind of new structurally-sound housing are bunk and should not be entertained or given any sort of authority. Once you have people literally living and shitting in the street, I sorta feel that these NIMBYs should altogether lose the authority to obstruct/delay the construction of new housing.
- rofrol 9y agoThat is some socialist thinking. Take sth from one group to give another.
- sidlls 9y agoPeople who have want to prevent others from having. Even if one subscribes to the notion that all people are selfish it shouldn't be controversial to consider the former more selfish than the latter, and view the parent's comment in that light, charitably.