4 ms·
>Gently, I would suggest that we are neither original nor should we find our identity in material goods While I agree with the first part, identity is tied to
by mc32 9y ago
>Gently, I would suggest that we are neither original nor should we find our identity in material goods
While I agree with the first part, identity is tied to society, unless we are to become reclusive hermits. I would suggest that while better, even people who look back to a pre-consumerist lifestyle, are engaging in lifestyle (and thus identity) unless it's a completely unattached choice (again reclusive hermit).
It reminds me of my High School anti-establishment, anti-in-crowd anti-jocks who in being all things-anti were a definable entity in itself with a prescribed set of attitudes and behavior -and music specially.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoidentity is tied to society, unless we are to become reclusive hermits Ah, but the reclusive hermit is a response to the society - an active rejection - such that the hermit is one of the lifestyles most consumed with society's affects! Similarly the "hipster" has a finely refined vane on popular culture. Calling a hermit/hipster disconnected from society It's like calling an antihistamine disconnected from pollen.
- mc32 9y agoTo me the hermit is different because the hermit is not looking for approval at all --the hermit is only looking to be by themselves and be of themselves. They don't care if they are admired, rejected, remembered or forgotten. Sadly even when they just want to be forgotten, Journalists looking for a story to tell hunt them down, sometimes[1]. Some people just want to be outside of it all. [1]https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/03/homeless-by-choice-how-to-live-for-free-in-america/254118/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/03/homeles...
- goatlover 9y agoIf you leave society altogether, you’re not part of it any longer.
- pnathan 9y agoThat is identity in material good selection - or the material good non-selection. I am suggesting that a, how do you say, Stoic? Zen? Tao? attitude about material goods is something to be desired. They are there, they are useful, they have a social context, but your identity is more than goods.