2 ms·
I don't think it's correct to say that compliance is "mandatory". The set of circumstances in which a pilot ordinarily must disobey direct instructions from ATC
by tialaramex 9y ago
I don't think it's correct to say that compliance is "mandatory". The set of circumstances in which a pilot ordinarily must disobey direct instructions from ATC is small, but it's not empty. And ATC rarely gives direct instructions anyway, a lot of what is said by ATC is phrased in terms of permission for the pilot to do things they should probably choose to do. If they respond "Unable" the ATC isn't going to write them up for violating some rule, they're going to look at how to work around this.
A very obvious example where the Rules explicitly tell pilots to disobey ATC is instructions from local technology that isn't co-ordinated with the ground, such as Ground Proximity Warning System and Traffic Collision Avoidance System. If these systems decide that overall "Climb, Crossing Climb, Climb Now!" is the correct instruction, but your controller suggests descending, the Rules are clear that you should all obey the machine and it will probably be fine because the machine is doing its own real time conflict resolution and re-assessing the local situation.
The Rules say you should tell the controller why you didn't obey their instructions but again, not as a greater priority than flying the plane.
- danaliv 9y agoI think we’re in agreement. :) I was referring to § 91.123 (a), which reads in part (emphasis added): “When an ATC clearance has been obtained, no pilot in command may deviate from that clearance unless an amended clearance is obtained, an emergency exists, or the deviation is in response to a traffic alert and collision avoidance system resolution advisory.” I.e. when ATC tells you “turn left heading 135,” unless you have a very good reason not to, you must turn left to heading 135. The part I didn’t emphasize is of course exactly what you’re saying. I suppose another way to phrase what I meant is that while ATC is the boss “in the small,” the PIC is the boss “in the large,” and I don’t think non-pilots think of it that way.