4 ms·
Not the OP, but I've gone through your (very well written and well thought) answer and it reminded me of what it was that turned me away from Wittgenstein (even
by paganel 9y ago
Not the OP, but I've gone through your (very well written and well thought) answer and it reminded me of what it was that turned me away from Wittgenstein (even though at some point I was a big fan of his, in some regards I still am): I'm talking about the tautology that you also remarked about. I couldn't get over it once I realized it was there. At least Hegel (which I'm not a fan of, that's for sure) had the "courage" to surpass said "tautology" by inventing a conflict (thesis, antithesis, synthesis) that at least looked like it was carrying the conversation, that was carrying us, closer to the truth, with Wittgenstein you feel like nothing like that happens, you're just left sitting there. I'm not criticizing him or anything of the sorts, just stating what I felt.
It is also true that with age (I've now approached my late 30s) I've started to become less and less interested in inquiring about the "truth", or what "truth" means, or what "words" mean, i.e. the topics mostly related to philosophers like Wittgenstein and Heidegger (haven't read anything by Derrida yet), and instead I've started becoming more and more interested (and even obsessed) by what us, humans, really are and what we think. As such, I've started reading more and more political philosophy, and as such I can say that (at least for people like me) philosophers like Hobbes and Rousseau are a lot more interesting and thought-provoking compared to the subjects approached by the likes of Wittgenstein or Heidegger.
Later edit: Because I just remembered later after writing most of the above comment: what also drove me away from modern/contemporary philosophers like Wittgenstein was reading a collection of the Heraclitus fragments. After reading them I realized that "truth" was, well, multi-faceted, polyvalent, taken at the limit truth was everything and nothing at all (which you could say that approaches some of Wittgenstein's views as well). More important of all, according to Heraclitus (or to my understanding of his sayings) "truth" and other philosophical-important concepts were on the same "level" as other, less important (from a philosophical point of view) concepts, i.e. that (again, taken to the limit) truth was falseness and falseness was truth. Once I realized that I was no longer interested in pursuing what "truth" is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wanda 9y agoI think that Heidegger was more concerned with the human condition than you give him credit for, at least in Being and Time anyway. Given what you said, I think Derrida will certainly be of interest to you.
- mercer 9y agoHas 'Eastern' philosophy affected your point of view in any way?
- paganel 9y agoNot really, at least not until now (I’m in my late 30s). Technically the most “Eastern” philosopher that has had an influence on me was Lucian of Samosata (afaik Samosata was close to the present border between Syria and Turkey), but other than that I didn’t have the “inner drive”, so to speak, to immerse myself into Eastern philosophy. At least not until now. From a distance I do find some parts of it pretty interesting, but, again, that’s just a “guess”. Come to think of it, I was pretty impressed by Plotinus and the Neoplatonists, who I think are the closest “Western philosophy” got to “Eastern philosophy”, even though I found that they’re not that much discussed in the Anglosphere.